Are you happy with tonight's result?

[Josy]

Well?

[Shaun]

:D

[MTVN]

Why yes I am thank you Josy

[reece(:]

No, what does it matter. I've pressed the "No" option every week so far.

[Josy]

I am, Ella was depressing as hell.

[Black Dagger]

Yes.

Rylan stayed and we get two performances from him next week. Great stuff.

[thesheriff443]

im not bothered.

[Firewire]

no. christopher should have went.

[Brother Leon]

Rylan & Chris are safe and James gets rebound vote next week.

Great.

[MeMyselfAndI]

I would have prefured Christopher to go, but was glad James stayed.
So I'm not bothered

[Roy Mars III]

yes, now Jahmene just has to go

[AnnieK]

Just so glad James stayed. Ella is boring but fantastic voice

[Marc]

Overall no. She was better than everybody bar James.

I was happy with the B2 result though.

[Wonderful Woman]

yes, Jahmene and Chris are going to storm this competition now :D

[Doogle]

Would've been better with Chris going but the second he was safe and everyone started going crazy it was worth it. Good result out of the B2, though.

[joeysteele]

No but I didn't want James to go out either. It was a bad song choice for Ella last night, that song has too special a place as it was with people.

[Maia]

Yes because I love seeing talent voted out over the deludedly atrocious

[Marc]

Bit weird, Mollie

[Kate!]

Happy that Ella went rather than James in the B2 so chose yes in the poll.

Overall though, it was the wrong bottom two. Maloney should be on the train back to Liverpool to have tea eith his nan.

[Apple202]

Yes because I love seeing talent voted out over the deludedly atrocious

This! Can't wait for James to leave next week in the sing off with Rylan :elephant:

[Maia]

Wasn't being serious I'm obviously disgusted

[Black Dagger]

Yes because I love seeing talent voted out over the deludedly atrocious

If she sung in-tune tonight she might have stayed <3.

[Locke.]

Brilliant result, probably the best one in the history of X Factor.. the 2 favourites in the bottom 2.

[Doogle]

If she sung in-tune tonight she might have stayed <3.

Not even that could save her. Too little too late

[Petershaw1984]

Yes.

Rylan stayed and we get two performances from him next week. Great stuff.

This

[Jamie585]

no

[Maia]

If she sung in-tune tonight she might have stayed <3.

Not singing in tune hasn't hindered Rylan's chances <3

[Apple202]

sorry (well im not sorry at all) but how me yet not them


this isn't directed at anyone on this thread..........

[Black Dagger]

Not singing in tune hasn't hindered Rylan's chances <3

Least he sung in-tune when he did a sing-off <3.

[Novo]

Now Now you two

[Z]

Yes, I was so sick of Ella's dreary singing style and her approach to her performances. Last night's took the piss - turning an uptempo classic into a ballad? Get a grip Tulisa/Ella, just goes to show that the public don't like a one trick pony. I really hope Jahmene is next out, he's equally as bad for it.

[Maia]

Least he sung in-tune when he did a sing-off <3.

He squealed like a strangled kitten <3

[Brother Leon]

Not singing in tune hasn't hindered Rylan's chances <3

Rylan is fun and entertaining enough to make up for it, Ella isn't unfortunately <3

[Apple202]

Go Mollie :cheer:

[Me. I Am Salman]

He squealed like a strangled kitten <3

:love:

[Me. I Am Salman]

Rylan is fun and entertaining enough to make up for it, Ella isn't unfortunately <3

But the prize is a record deal
and he's not entertaining, it's just a bunch of flashy lights and upbeat music

[Josy]

sorry (well im not sorry at all) but how me yet not them


this isn't directed at anyone on this thread..........

I don't know what you are on about, but it doesn't seem to be anything to do with this thread so stop going off topic please.

[Novo]

But the prize is a record deal
and he's not entertaining

which you can easily get anyway without winning

[Me. I Am Salman]

Didn't know TiBB was full of TOWIE fans

[Maia]

Rylan is fun and entertaining enough to make up for it, Ella isn't unfortunately <3

Yes prancing about squealing 7-song medleys badly with a load of gimmicky backup dancers like you're at a TOWIE-themed Butlins show is the height of entertainment <3

[Maia]

This show isn't even about being "fun and entertaining" anyway it's supposed to be about looking for talent, and Rylan is quite frankly as talented as a goldfish

[Roy Mars III]

Not singing in tune hasn't hindered Rylan's chances <3

Rylan is entertaining and is a decent singer, Ella has no talent and no entertainment value at all

[Locke.]

Rylan is probably a better singer than Ella

[Roy Mars III]

This show isn't even about being "fun and entertaining" anyway it's supposed to be about looking for talent, and Rylan is quite frankly as talented as a goldfish

it's about the 'X' factor, which is more than just singing talent

[Black Dagger]

Rylan's pre show Kissing You > Ella Henderson.

[Marc]

Mollie I wouldn't bother, you'll only get angry

We all know today was silly, viewers are a tad bit retarded it seems

[Brother Leon]

Well said Sir Royston.


This ain't The Voice :idc:

[Black Dagger]

Ella should have done The Voice tbh, she'd have won. Bland and inoffensive, just like their winner.

[Black Dagger]

Yes prancing about squealing 7-song medleys badly with a load of gimmicky backup dancers like you're at a TOWIE-themed Butlins show is the height of entertainment <3

He's never done more than 3 <3

He should do 7 when he makes the final.

[Maia]

Rylan is entertaining and is a decent singer, Ella has no talent and no entertainment value at all

Decent singer rofl, and he's not remotely entertaining he's only surviving off of the gimmicked up performances and the fact he's from Essex

it's about the 'X' factor, which is more than just singing talent

I said talent not singing talent, and the X Factor is still calling itself a show that's looking for "talent", and he is just not talented

[Me. I Am Salman]

Well said Sir Royston.


This ain't The Voice :idc:

Wagner was the only 'entertaining' joke act, fact
but if the likes of Harry Derbridge, Ashleigh from Big Brother 13 and Amy Childs float your boat then I guess there's nothing else left to say :pipe:

[Black Dagger]

SloPuPWmlKE

> Kye and Ella

[Roy Mars III]

Rylan isn't a joke act

[Black Dagger]

Wagner was the only 'entertaining' joke act, fact
but if the likes of Harry Derbridge, Ashleigh from Big Brother 13 and Amy Childs float your boat then I guess there's nothing else left to say :pipe:

Erm because liking one person from Essex means you like them all? Don't be so bloody stupid Salman.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Erm because liking one person from Essex means you like them all? Don't be so bloody stupid Salman.

they're all the same :nono:
it's not because they're from Essex, it's because they're try to play the whole Essex stereotype

[Brother Leon]

Wagner was the only 'entertaining' joke act, fact
but if the likes of Harry Derbridge, Ashleigh from Big Brother 13 and Amy Childs float your boat then I guess there's nothing else left to say :pipe:

Who??

[Maia]

Rylan isn't a joke act

Very true, joke acts are meant to be amusing

[Kazanne]

I think it serves Tulisa right for slagging Christopher off every week and being so nasty to him and praising Ryland so much,shame Ella was collateral damage,but kinda worth it to bring Tulisa down to earth with a bump!!!!

[Jake.]

Most stupid result yet, this is why I do not watch anymore :pipe:

[Harry!]

Yes as fabulous Rylan is through another week <3

[Jack_]

A few ways I can view this:

1) No, because Christopher stayed and I'm close to vomiting at the thought of him making the final.

2) Yes, because Union J stayed and made the two songs stage.

3) No, because Ella was one of my favourites.

4) Yes, because those twenty minutes made for some of the best TV X Factor has ever produced.

[Ramsay]

AMAZING result
Ella and James bottom 2 was the best possible thing to happen
Great stuff

[GypsyGoth]

I didn't watch the show tonight, and after I heard the result I'm glad I skipped it. It would have annoyed me too much seeing those two getting the least votes.

[Locke.]

But it was so good Claudia!!! Feel the love!!

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mdniypJy2C1reewq7o2_500.jpg

[GypsyGoth]

:laugh2:

I would laugh if him and Rylan were the last two.

[Maia]

Anyone who can seriously say to themselves that an Ella/James bottom 2 was the best possible result to happen with the finalists we have left......I feel a bit sorry for you

[Iceman]

Yes, she was the most boring contestant since Leona..... oh wow great you can sing but you've the personality of a sheet of paper love.

[Maia]

I didn't watch the show tonight, and after I heard the result I'm glad I skipped it. It would have annoyed me too much seeing those two getting the least votes.

:worship: Sensible Claudia

[Glenn.]

Anyone who can seriously say to themselves that an Ella/James bottom 2 was the best possible result to happen with the finalists we have left......I feel a bit sorry for you

[2]

Its pathetic.

[Ramsay]

I understand you're upset Mollie, but please don't take it out on me

http://img.metro.co.uk/i/pix/2012/09/24/article-1348487727407-152B3A08000005DC-567509_466x358.jpg

[Ramsay]

Yes, she was the most boring contestant since Leona..... oh wow great you can sing but you've the personality of a sheet of paper love.

Amen brother!

[Glenn.]

He's so orange it makes me laugh.

And Karl's just proving my point I made in the other thread. Christopher Maloney has no real fans, just people hell bent on annoying others.

[Ramsay]

I'll have you know that i have all of the songs he's done on the show so far on my itunes actually Glenn :idc:

[Glenn.]

:joker:

[Locke.]

It is people like Glen that make me sick!! Just hating on Chris to make sure his nan feels sick

[Ramsay]

Yeah, internet bullies :bored:

[Glenn.]

If his Nan had any sense she would disown him.

[Jords]

Yepp, she was repetative. Great vocals, boring tone.

[Mrluvaluva]

I despair. Not only at the programme itself but some of these comments. I know people have different tastes but seriously. Some people would not recognise talent if it bit them on the arse.

[Shaun]

some would expect talent to be nurtured without the aid of a TV show fixated on its own controversy

[Me. I Am Salman]

It is people like Glen that make me sick!! Just hating on Chris to make sure his nan feels sick

his nan looks quite healthy judging from this photo (which I will never get over)

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/A5JyUZjCcAAKQZo.jpg:large

[Mystic Mock]

Yes just for something shocking actually happening, plus Ella was really bad this weekend imo.

[jet]

I despair. Not only at the programme itself but some of these comments. I know people have different tastes but seriously. Some people would not recognise talent if it bit them on the arse.

Yes. They do it year after year - they vote for a winner who ends up being a loser (Steve, Shane, Leon, Matt) with a few obvious exceptions. Talented people have ended up voted off but doing better after the show.
Take heart. It won't matter who wins, the ones who are going to get the serious record deals and sell are Ella, Jahmene and James.
Winning is fleeting and you soon plunge into obscurity unless you are good enough (like Leona, Alexandra and Little Mix). Chris and Rylan will be a distant memory this time next year. They will probably get steady work singing (I bet Rylan will be booked solid for a good while to come - he IS entertaining) but they aren't going to be big stars. X factor voters obviously don't know their Leona's from their Leon's. At the end of the day it doesn't matter who wins - real talent will rise to the top anyway and the rest will fade away.

[Mystic Mock]

Yes prancing about squealing 7-song medleys badly with a load of gimmicky backup dancers like you're at a TOWIE-themed Butlins show is the height of entertainment <3

I agree with this, Rylan is not that entertaining imo, all he does is dress up in some freaky costume every week and look like his on the Catwalk, oh and mumble a few words.

[Z]

I'd much rather watch Rylan work the stage than Ella turn everything into a ballad and do the same wounded bambi voice every time she sings, and now I don't have to. Ideally Chris and Jahmene will be out before the final, but I'd be quite happy for Chris to win because I think it might make the show buck up its ideas.

[Iceman]

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mdoutf1A4i1rn2nvyo1_500.gif

[Marc]

I just don't think James should've been bottom 2

Tis silly

[Kazanne]

He's so orange it makes me laugh.

And Karl's just proving my point I made in the other thread. Christopher Maloney has no real fans, just people hell bent on annoying others.

You cant speak for everyone! or are these fans the same ones who are voting for Ryland aswell

[Alf]

Yes, she was the most boring contestant since Leona..... oh wow great you can sing but you've the personality of a sheet of paper love.
are you saying when you listen to music, your not listening for the music ability? your listening for the personality?

[Black Dagger]

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mdoutf1A4i1rn2nvyo1_500.gif

That is a perfect signature :lovedup:

[Iceman]

are you saying when you listen to music, your not listening for the music ability? your listening for the personality?

No but when im watching TV its nice to see people be something other than a cardboard cut out.

[Glenn.]

You cant speak for everyone! or are these fans the same ones who are voting for Ryland aswell

Rylan is entertaining. Christopher is as entertaining as a bruised satsuma.