Your views on the 'Peoples Muppet'

[Benjamin]

I know it's only been two days and it's hard to come to a proper valid opinion, but what are your views on him?

I just can't see it working, his acting is a bit too dramatic and unbelievable. I mean the fact he deliberated for a while over the new h/mates suitcases for a pizza, really? He would have been better just saying no straight away, again it didn't suit the ditzy, nice guy image he is meant to be portraying.

[Vladimir]

I love the twist, but they should've hired a better actor.

[Lwize]

I think it'll work out, though I would have preferred not using an actor.
BBUSA did this a few years a go with "America's Player", and it was fun.

[GiRTh]

The HM's are too savvy and dont think their suitcases have actually been shredded so its failing. The nomination twist might retrieve it but its not been a good start.

[Marc]

I really hate the twist, it's really really poor. I don't like him either so it doesn't work at all for me

[oathbreaker]

I love the twist, but they should've hired a better actor.

This ^^
Think it would have worked better telling the guy just be himself but knowing he will be brutal he wont need to make friends or bond with people basically just be a total sociopath..:devil:

trouble with Mario in BB11 he knew a failure would mean eviction this guy doesn't have that worry and can play it a lot cooler. On the live feed last night he totally blended in yet when it was showtime out came the actor again.

[psychtracker]

he kinda works in a way, for me. because so many HMs have 'played' up to the cameras over the years! ..especially in the diary room..with noms. theres nothing 'new' about 'bad' acting.

[Drew.]

during the pizza/suitcase task last night his personality changed a bit too dramatically and quickly when deciding what to do, he needs to tone it down a bit.. but i dont mind him so far and there's still potential for him to cause a lot of drama so fingers crossed he does.

[MTVN]

His acting isn't bad really considering the environment he's in and the fact he has to keep it up literally 24/7, I'm not that keen on the twist though and look forward to it ending

[Marc]

during the pizza/suitcase task last night his personality changed a bit too dramatically and quickly when deciding what to do, he needs to tone it down a bit.. but i dont mind him so far and there's still potential for him to cause a lot of drama so fingers crossed he does.

Terrible acting :pipe:

[Josy]

I'm liking it at the moment and I think he's doing pretty well with keeping the act up so far, I also think it's good the way we are getting a say on the things he does.

That said though I don't want them to take the piss with it and make it far too obvious too soon and I'm also wondering what the plan is to save him from next weeks nominations process.

[Marcus.]

he doning ok at mo

[Jack_]

I really like it and I don't think people are giving him or the twist a fair chance.

I don't think people have really understood what last night was about either, although to be fair I was confused at first. Basically, Michael would have been called to the Diary Room earlier in the night (he was in there for a long time during the 5* live feed, the twins mentioned it) and told the results of the suitcase poll and what was going to happen. He was obviously in on the fact that the housemates would be watching him (as in Michael the actor knew that, but Michael the housemate has to pretend he doesn't), that was confirmed on the C5 website. So whilst the housemates think he doesn't know they were watching, he can show a different side to the Michael character, i.e. what he's like inside the Diary Room when he knows he doesn't have to pander or be nice to the others, making them question whether he's such a nice guy after all because they can see what he's like behind their backs. Now this of course was all part of the act, as I said Michael knew he was being watched but had to pretend he wasn't and so hammed it up and went on about how he didn't care about their suitcases and he already has a few people to nominate in mind so that they all think they've now seen what he's really like (when of course it's all part of the act, but they don't know that). That adds a whole other dimension and I really liked the way they did that, I thought they were going to reveal he was an actor at first but I was pleasantly surprised.

On the whole I think he's doing a decent job, the first night he overacted a bit but last night as I've already said I think the whole thing was done really well, he also seems to be fitting in with the others when he's not the focus either so that's a good thing.

I'm just glad they've tried something different, I'm impressed and really like the idea of us having polls to decide what he does, I just hope they up the ante a bit soon and make him nastier and sneakier. And I also hope it doesn't end any time soon either and I really don't understand why people want it to, IMO it should last at least a month but to be honest I'd rather it just lasted the entire series. It doesn't mean it has to take over the series, people are over exaggerating by saying that (I mean it hardly took over the highlights last night, most of the focus was on Sam and Jemima and Dexter and Sallie, he only had a little bit), and it's perfectly possible to balance him with other house action. You could have one or two decisions to make for him a week I reckon and that'd balance both sides of the show enough.

I also don't think it should end early because of how much they plugged this twist, it was the main 'secret' as part of the ad campaign and for them to end it after like a week as they usually do would just be sh*te and the same as always. And plus, contrast the housemates reactions if it would be revealed in a week to what it'd be like after 10 weeks. I just have this vision on finale night of them all sitting round and Big Brother showing them a VT of all the times across the series when they've said 'I think Michael's an actor' or questioned stuff about him, and then at the end of it they tag on the second creepy VT we got shown of him on the first launch night...that'd be MILES better than next week them going 'Michael you've been acting, your task is over, say goodbye'...YAWN.

So yeah, I like it and think people need to give it a chance to develop.

[arista]

I know it's only been two days and it's hard to come to a proper valid opinion, but what are your views on him?

I just can't see it working, his acting is a bit too dramatic and unbelievable. I mean the fact he deliberated for a while over the new h/mates suitcases for a pizza, really? He would have been better just saying no straight away, again it didn't suit the ditzy, nice guy image he is meant to be portraying.



Feck Me Ben - They all are,

We would need 24/7 viewing to know the truth

[Marcus.]

I really like it and I don't think people are giving him or the twist a fair chance.

I don't think people have really understood what last night was about either, although to be fair I was confused at first. Basically, Michael would have been called to the Diary Room earlier in the night (he was in there for a long time during the 5* live feed, the twins mentioned it) and told the results of the suitcase poll and what was going to happen. He was obviously in on the fact that the housemates would be watching him (as in Michael the actor knew that, but Michael the housemate has to pretend he doesn't), that was confirmed on the C5 website. So whilst the housemates think he doesn't know they were watching, he can show a different side to the Michael character, i.e. what he's like inside the Diary Room when he knows he doesn't have to pander or be nice to the others, making them question whether he's such a nice guy after all because they can see what he's like behind their backs. Now this of course was all part of the act, as I said Michael knew he was being watched but had to pretend he wasn't and so hammed it up and went on about how he didn't care about their suitcases and he already has a few people to nominate in mind so that they all think they've now seen what he's really like (when of course it's all part of the act, but they don't know that). That adds a whole other dimension and I really liked the way they did that, I thought they were going to reveal he was an actor at first but I was pleasantly surprised.

On the whole I think he's doing a decent job, the first night he overacted a bit but last night as I've already said I think the whole thing was done really well, he also seems to be fitting in with the others when he's not the focus either so that's a good thing.

I'm just glad they've tried something different, I'm impressed and really like the idea of us having polls to decide what he does, I just hope they up the ante a bit soon and make him nastier and sneakier. And I also hope it doesn't end any time soon either and I really don't understand why people want it to, IMO it should last at least a month but to be honest I'd rather it just lasted the entire series. It doesn't mean it has to take over the series, people are over exaggerating by saying that (I mean it hardly took over the highlights last night, most of the focus was on Sam and Jemima and Dexter and Sallie, he only had a little bit), and it's perfectly possible to balance him with other house action. You could have one or two decisions to make for him a week I reckon and that'd balance both sides of the show enough.

I also don't think it should end early because of how much they plugged this twist, it was the main 'secret' as part of the ad campaign and for them to end it after like a week as they usually do would just be sh*te and the same as always. And plus, contrast the housemates reactions if it would be revealed in a week to what it'd be like after 10 weeks. I just have this vision on finale night of them all sitting round and Big Brother showing them a VT of all the times across the series when they've said 'I think Michael's an actor' or questioned stuff about him, and then at the end of it they tag on the second creepy VT we got shown of him on the first launch night...that'd be MILES better than next week them going 'Michael you've been acting, your task is over, say goodbye'...YAWN.

So yeah, I like it and think people need to give it a chance to develop.

hear hear

[YodaBB]

I Like Him And The Twist.

[Benjamin]

Feck Me Ben - They all are,

We would need 24/7 viewing to know the truth

I mean when he has to do something. I just think the deliberation of whether to take the pizza was a bit unbelievable. Had it been money, even £1000, then maybe deliberation, but for a pizza?

C5 could make this really work, but they need to make it more believable.

[R0B1S]

He is ok I guess. I just don't understand one thing - why the hell they made him play a character? Why could not he just be himself? It would have been a lot easier for him and it would not seem so awkward and forced at times.

[arista]

I mean when he has to do something. I just think the deliberation of whether to take the pizza was a bit unbelievable. Had it been money, even £1000, then maybe deliberation, but for a pizza?

C5 could make this really work, but they need to make it more believable.


Yes
but we are not Up To Date
until the Live Feed starts tonight on 5*
7 - 9PM

[Marcus.]

maybe to up the challage

[Cherie]

He is Ok so far and he is can only be as good as what the producers give him, the shredding of the suitcases was just a joke, it would have been far more believable if they had to hand over a few treasured items from their suitcases, like make up, cigarettes etc.

[Tom4784]

It would have been a better twist if they got someone else to do it. Every time he's on screen I just roll my eyes and wonder how no one has sussed it out yet. The sooner this twist is over the better.

[Marcus.]

how long the twist is for

[Visage]

It's hard to judge him as an actor.

Are BB scripting him and asking to play this ditzy guy? (by that I mean in the diary room when he was told to keep his suitcase)

Are BB leaving him to ad-lib his way through the diary room scenes?

So is it the actor who isn't doing a convincing job, or is he a great actor by following BB's instructions to the letter..?

[Visage]

I would like to see more of the actor than the housemate he's playing to make a better judgement.

[Ammi]

..I like him and I actually thought he was ok in the diary room when choosing between the suitcases and the pizza, I think it's only because we know he's and actor that we're looking at him differently, it's not unusual for a housemate to be OTT and adapt their personality in the diary room to make the most of their one to one air time...

[fruit_cake]

I am surprised the HM's aren't more suspicious, it'd be only natural to suspect a mole in that situation, and then there's the fact that he's gone to the DR twice and also that I'm not sure an ordinary person would deliberate so much.

He kept saying oh I really need my stuff...it was a bit OTT imo

[Visage]

I am surprised the HM's aren't more suspicious, it'd be only natural to suspect a mole in that situation, and then there's the fact that he's gone to the DR twice and also that I'm not sure an ordinary person would deliberate so much.

He kept saying oh I really need my stuff...it was a bit OTT imo

But, if we didn't know he was acting, it might have felt normal.

[fruit_cake]

But, if we didn't know he was acting, it might have felt normal.

true but in fairness the situation is not normal. In normal life you don't suspect moles, but in the BB house it would be normal to suspect one seems to me. :blush:

[Marcus.]

the housemates need to up there game

[Visage]

true but in fairness the situation is not normal. In normal life you don't suspect moles, but in the BB house it would be normal to suspect one seems to me. :blush:

Yeah I know what you mean.

I just think that for years and years housemates have always suspected a mole/plant and it's never happened, so that alone would play with their heads and all the usual paranoia that follows.

[Jords]

He did over-do it a bit but Im liking the twist so far.

[daniel-lewis-1985]

I think hes a knob.

[Marcus.]

I think hes a knob.

dont mince your words there

[smeagol]

he is great,but bb need to stop making it obvious ,why pick him to do anything just let him be a housemate then do sneaky stuff on the sly would be far easier. the wya they are singerlign him out he will be sussed soon

[Jordan.]

The idea is good but I don't like 'Michael'. They should have put someone in who'd be a dick so it'd be believable. His innocent act ruins it.

[joeysteele]

I am not impressed, I could have happily done without this twist.

I cannot see it getting better as I don't find him convincing at all.
He is in place now so I'll wait to see what happens.
He isn't a 'proper' housemate,so I have little interest as to what he may do or will be doing so for me he is an irrelevance.

If I was in there, I would have been massively suspicious of him from his first race up the stairs to the diary room,also, I would have likely done a Speidi and asked for a solicitor if I had really believed they had shredded my items and/or clothing.
That was all just silly in my view.

[ThisIsNickkk]

The twist isn't the problem, the twist could be amazing. It just depends on whether BB gets him doing silly stuff that will have just about no impact.

It needs to be psychological as well as opposed to silly games. We need some insider info in the house, he needs to tell one of the housemates that they probably won't be liked on the outside, he needs to mess with their head's and make them all paranoid, or get them all bitching.

[Braden]

I don't mind him as an actor, he had me convinced in his VT. I just feel like the producers have went far-fetched in regards to their own ideas. Shredding the housemates' suitcases is a bit extreme, and looked unrealistic. I think a better idea would've been to have Michael pick just one housemate not to have their suitcase throughout their entire stay. That way it wouldn't have looked fishy, because he would've been forced to make a decision and it still would've caused tension, especially if he chose somebody like Sallie. She would've been even more annoyed if it was only her I reckon.

The recent task sounds silly too. I hate it when people get too personal in the house regardless of it being a mission, so the idea of his secret being "I hate fat people" comes across completely childish.