Music Debates: Re-Up ~ The 2nd Wave (Tulisa VS Alesha)

[reece(:]

Rules:
I post a controversial musical opinion and participants debate out their side whilst staying as classy and elegant as they can be. Once a debate reaches a natural conclusion we move onto another.

THE RE~UP: After the debate has finished, the result is decided by a separate poll!

Debate 1:

Both have been used by Timbaland to break him out into stardom but who's the best of Keri and Nelly (take into account; vocals, presence, diversity, relevance and charts)

The Canadian queen has shown to go from urban RnB to the indie pop of the The Legend Indestructible with effortlessness.

Maneater alone ****s on Jesus' discography which is only a few songs isn't it? Slay a little, Furtado
http://i.minus.com/ibaUga3oeaZzsV.gif

Results so far:

Nelly Furtado vs Keri Hilson - Nelly
The Saturdays vs Little Mix - The Saturdays
Jessica Mauboy vs Kat Deluna - Draw
Cheryl Cole vs Nicole Schzeringer - Nicole
Fergie vs Gwen Stefani - Gwen
Miley vs Demi vs Selena - NewMiley
Spice Girls vs Girls Aloud - Girls Aloud
Christina Milian vs Cassie vs Ciara - Christina
Kelly Clarkson vs P!nk - P!nk
Ellie Goulding vs Marina & the Diamonds - Ellie
Nicki Minaj vs Lil' Kim - Nicki
Jennifer Hudson vs Kelly Rowland - Kelly
Sia vs Foxes vs Paloma Faith - Sia

[Me. I Am Salman]

Jesus had one great album and after that I lost interest tbh. Also Loose > In a Perfect World I have to be realistic

[Saph]

I love a bit of our lord and savior kween keri but Nelly >>>>>>

http://i.minus.com/i4WC8WDZrk485.gif

[Saph]

6JnGBs88sL0

http://i.minus.com/i4WC8WDZrk485.gif

[Joelle.]

I have no opinion on Hilson so Kween Nelly is victorious

[reece(:]

6JnGBs88sL0

http://i.minus.com/i4WC8WDZrk485.gif
This song > discographies

Have to say I haven't listened to her first album except I'm Like A Bird, is it worth a go?

Keri can have a few props for Return The Favor, which is a cute bop
http://i.minus.com/ibaUga3oeaZzsV.gif

[Jordan.]

Say It Right & Promiscuous > the other ones existence

[Saph]

tbh Nellys first two albums do nothing for me

Loose >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.

although Like A Bird, Turn Off The Light and One Trick Pony are jams

http://i.minus.com/i4WC8WDZrk485.gif

[Joelle.]

Also Reece this is one of the greatest thread ideas since the creation of the word

http://static.tumblr.com/v1asjlx/SGAlysuxp/other_preach_gif.gif

[Saph]

remember this song :dazzler:

mKOO2oNGVcI

[Z]

Keri Hilson was a flash in the pan, utterly forgettable IMO. If it weren't for the way Nelly Furtado debuted, I'd have said the same thing about her - the music she's made since reinventing herself as Timbaland's muse has been kind of awful but then you remember that this is the same woman who released I'm Like A Bird

[Me. I Am Salman]

Undoubtedly one of the best songs from Loose, SO underrated

Asy6Cpbtwfs

ok the beat was plagiarised but who cares

[Me. I Am Salman]

I used to be OBSESSED with Nelly when I was like 11, I remember having a picture of the loose album cover on my Piczo page & when my friends laughed at it I said I was hacked :laugh:

[Locke.]

Keri Hilson is at least 7 times better

[reece(:]

Also Reece this is one of the greatest thread ideas since the creation of the word

http://static.tumblr.com/v1asjlx/SGAlysuxp/other_preach_gif.gif
:worship:

Thought we may as well hash it all out in one thread instead of new ones for each musical difference one has.
http://i.minus.com/ibaUga3oeaZzsV.gif

[Saph]

I used to be OBSESSED with Nelly when I was like 11, I remember having a picture of the loose album cover on my Piczo page & when my friends laughed at it I said I was hacked :laugh:

:joker:

[reece(:]

I used to be OBSESSED with Nelly when I was like 11, I remember having a picture of the loose album cover on my Piczo page & when my friends laughed at it I said I was hacked :laugh:
Promiscuous was on my Piczo page at 11 :laugh: and ironically the site that provided the song was called musicjesus. Slay a little, Nelly

[Me. I Am Salman]

omg I was really bad at Piczo my page was literally just pictures

[Joelle.]

The Spirit Indestructable slays it deserved so much better

2vGF2Ux2ypI

[Joelle.]

remember this song :dazzler:

mKOO2oNGVcI

:dazzler:

[reece(:]

The Spirit Indestructable slays it deserved so much better

2vGF2Ux2ypI
This is one of the best songs of recent times, Nelly slaying those rock anthems.

[reece(:]

The general consensus (bar Locke) appears to have reached an agreement that Legend Furtado is vastly superior....
http://i.cbc.ca/1.673486.1378504678!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/original_300/furtado-nelly-cp-11592714.jpg

Swiftly moving on
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/d/d2/The_Saturdays_in_Sept_2011.jpg/711px-The_Saturdays_in_Sept_2011.jpg
vs
http://www.hellomagazine.com/imagenes/healthandbeauty/2013042512198/little-mix-launch-nail-collection/0-62-315/little-mix-nails--a.jpg

[Benjamin]

Nelly Furtado's 2nd album 'Folklore' remains her greatest work. :love:

[reece(:]

Nelly Furtado's 2nd album 'Folklore' remains her greatest work. :love:

Are there any songs from that album you could recommend? :spin:

[Joelle.]

The Saturdays for this masterpiece alone:

93iIib5oLOw

[reece(:]

I'm TeamSats due to their flawless discography however Little Mix are better vocalists on the whole (if not including Vanessa White The PowerHouseGoddess).

[Z]

If we could swap Vanessa from The Saturdays into Little Mix it would be fantastic.

Little Mix are by far superior - they sing well, they dance well, they've got it all.

The Saturdays are a piss poor version of Girls Aloud, none of them can sing well and dance well, some of them are only good at one and some of them are good at neither. They're just a bit safe and boring and I think they'll just fade away soon rather than going out on a high.

[Benjamin]

Are there any songs from that album you could recommend? :spin:

Forca, Powerless, Fresh Off the Boat, Island Of Wonder and this amazing song

3--1Kw2UHDQ

[james130]

Little Mix are probably more talented as a whole. But in terms of actual songs and catchiness The Saturdays >>>>>>>> >>>>>> >>>>>>>>> Little Mix

[Joelle.]

The Sats are just getting started. That flawfree discography will just continue to get more flawfree. Disco Love is their best single since Ego :love:

[Me. I Am Salman]

both suck but The Saturdays have some rare good singles

[james130]

This is one of the greatest pop songs of the 21st Century.

r656v3dYXls

[Z]

The Saturdays have had about 4 years more of a career than Little Mix though; give them time and I bet Little Mix will have the better discography.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Little Mix are cheesy and basically the female version of One Direction

[Me. I Am Salman]

Up and Issues >>>

[james130]

True.
I thought Change Your Life was decent.
But if we take Wings, DNA, Change Your Life and How You Doing, <<<<<<<< If This Is Love, Up, Issues & Work

[Me. I Am Salman]

One of the best British songs of 2009

ylJ7eNrvrug

[Joelle.]

The worst single from Chasing Lights is still better than Change Your Life

[reece(:]

Another plus for The Sats is their collection of flawless B-sides, Wildfire is one of their best and Turn Myself In:love:

If we could swap Vanessa from The Saturdays into Little Mix it would be fantastic.

Little Mix are by far superior - they sing well, they dance well, they've got it all.

The Saturdays are a piss poor version of Girls Aloud, none of them can sing well and dance well, some of them are only good at one and some of them are good at neither. They're just a bit safe and boring and I think they'll just fade away soon rather than going out on a high.
I'd say GA are a lot more versatile, shown by their discography but The Sats bring something different than GA for me.. (not sure what it is though:laugh:)
Forca, Powerless, Fresh Off the Boat, Island Of Wonder and this amazing song

3--1Kw2UHDQ
Her voice, what a soothing song :love: will have to add it to my "to check out" list!
The Sats are just getting started.
Disco Love is their best single since Ego :love:
They've been in the game 5 years :joker: but yes Disco Love is perf, have you heard Love Come Down, it's a lot like it (I RECOMMEND<3).

This is one of the greatest pop songs of the 21st Century.

r656v3dYXls
This is where Britney Jean got her inspiration :dazzler:
The Saturdays have had about 4 years more of a career than Little Mix though; give them time and I bet Little Mix will have the better discography.
For me it depends where Little Mix go, because they've tried a lot of genres on their first album; they should stick with one now and market it.

[reece(:]

Little Mix are cheesy and basically the female version of One Direction
This may fit well in that unpopular opinions thread, wowzer :laugh:

[Benjamin]

I have to agree that both are crap.

[james130]

These songs will probably top anything Little Mix ever put out.

Gj6tMZ9oows

KdtIfp7WB0w

[reece(:]

Not Giving Up is one of my favs from the new album :love:

All Little Mix singles have fell flat for me, the only contender for them would be;

bCUC_wAZPPI

[Joelle.]

Wildfire is perfect, and Somebody Elses Life from the current album :love:

And I haven't heard it Reece but I'm gonna listen now

[MeMyselfAndI]

Little Mix atm > Saturdays

[reece(:]

Also "Move" sucks compared to The Sats latest "Disco Love" :love:

[james130]

Just listened to that track Reece.
Yeah, probably the best i've heard from them but not good.

[Joelle.]

Oh god it slays

As much as I like WAU and Gentlemen can you imagine if the singles for this album had been Disco Love, Wildfire and Love Come Down http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[reece(:]

Wildfire is perfect, and Somebody Elses Life from the current album :love:

And I haven't heard it Reece but I'm gonna listen now
You better stan :dazzler:

[reece(:]

Oh god it slays

As much as I like WAU and Gentlemen can you imagine if the singles for this album had been Disco Love, Wildfire and Love Come Down http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png
It would've been brilliance. Negating Wildfire and Love Come Down to B-sides is an absolute atrocity. http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[Joelle.]

It would've been brilliance. Negating Wildfire and Love Come Down to B-sides is an absolute atrocity. http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

4th single Not Giving Up though. I'm stanning for that http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[reece(:]

Just listened to that track Reece.
Yeah, probably the best i've heard from them but not good.
Which, Love Come Down? :dazzler:

Apparently it's a cover as well, get those receipts Sats http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[james130]

I love 'Love Come Down' but love Gentleman much more than Wildfire. It's so different for them.

[james130]

Which, Love Come Down? :dazzler:

Apparently it's a cover as well, get those receipts Sats http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

Nahh that Little Sh1ts one.

But what?! LCD's a cover?
Well the Sats just rendered whoever it was irrelevant.

[reece(:]

4th single Not Giving Up though. I'm stanning for that http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png
and Don't Let Me Dance Alone for 5th :dazzler:
I love 'Love Come Down' but love Gentleman much more than Wildfire. It's so different for them.
They're putting Evelyn King to shame with these disco-funk songs :dazzler: Gentleman is an odd one for me, at times I enjoy it but it can get annoying too.

[reece(:]

Nahh that Little Sh1ts one.

But what?! LCD's a cover?
Well the Sats just rendered whoever it was irrelevant.

The Little Sh1ts http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/lmao.gifhttp://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/lmao.gif

Yes it is their best song :dazzler:

and yes LCD is a cover of Evelyn King (who?)

[Z]

Also "Move" sucks compared to The Sats latest "Disco Love" :love:

WhAT?!

[Me. I Am Salman]

Gentleman got annoying pretty quickly, especially Rochelle's part in the chorus

[Joelle.]

Gentleman grew on me a little, but still Wildfire >>>

I'm stanning hard

http://www.gifsforum.com/images/gif/cry/grand/26494072_cry_gif.gif

[Me. I Am Salman]

I don't know any of these songs you're talking about

[Z]

Gentleman got annoying pretty quickly, especially Rochelle's part in the chorus

That's because Rochelle is awful

[Joelle.]

and Don't Let Me Dance Alone for 5th :dazzler:

YASS :dazzler:

Quite like Leave a Light On too. Oh god this album is almost flawfree

[reece(:]

WhAT?!

Move just doesn't go anywhere for me and the song is a bit mix mash for my liking, I love the funkiness of Disco Love

[reece(:]

YASS :dazzler:

Quite like Leave a Light On too. Oh god this album is almost flawfree
Don't forget Lease My Love :dazzler:

[Joelle.]

I don't know any of these songs you're talking about

The B sides are better than the actual singles on this album

[Z]

Move just doesn't go anywhere for me and the song is a bit mix mash for my liking, I love the funkiness of Disco Love

Disco Love is horribly cheesy, plods along and sounds like an album track that somebody accidentally sent to radio. Move is funky, has an interesting structure and actually manages to sound fairly original! Couldn't disagree with you more :laugh:

[reece(:]

I don't know any of these songs you're talking about

0RFozUKEJlg

GKvdfjRZ22A

LmncQGy_7Lk

[james130]

SOMEBODY ELSE'S LIFE. :|

tM6AveuQzaw

http://24.media.tumblr.com/989c85717d6d4e6b49f7ca04e50a859d/tumblr_m4jhbr9nr81qfjc3io5_r1_250.gif

[reece(:]

That's because Rochelle is awful
But she is the 2nd best vocalist.

[reece(:]

Disco Love is horribly cheesy, plods along and sounds like an album track that somebody accidentally sent to radio. Move is funky, has an interesting structure and actually manages to sound fairly original! Couldn't disagree with you more :laugh:
What about this legendary cover?! I'm shocked you think Disco Love is cheesy (bar the "baby baby baby" bit).
GKvdfjRZ22A

[Joelle.]

Don't forget Lease My Love :dazzler:

All this flawless material they had but still decided to release 30 Days first http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[reece(:]

All this flawless material they had but still decided to release 30 Days first http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png
Terrible label it seems. http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[Joelle.]

Also Notorious was groundbreaking

[Jordan.]

Little Mix cause talent

Plus their debut album > every Saturdays album I've not listened to (all of them)

[Me. I Am Salman]

I liked 30 Days

[Z]

But she is the 2nd best vocalist.

Vanessa > Una > Rochelle > dying hyenas > the others



Notorious, All Fired Up, Up, Work and What About Us are their only songs that are actually good songs in my opinion.

[Joelle.]

All Fired Up is probably their least interesting song

[Me. I Am Salman]

I can't believe Una is 32

[Z]

All Fired Up is probably their least interesting song

The production is phenomenal; the lyrics are naff and repetitive (just like all of their other songs :idc:) but the beat is undeniable

[reece(:]

All Fired Up is probably their least interesting song
It isn't when you're at a house party :dazzler:

[reece(:]

I have the next set of gorls lined up for discussion :dazzler:

[james130]

The production is phenomenal; the lyrics are naff and repetitive (just like all of their other songs :idc:) but the beat is undeniable

:worship:

[Brother Leon]

Little Mix are whack.

Sturdays>>>

that is all peeps.

[Joelle.]

I think we can call this one a draw at least

[Z]

I have the next set of gorls lined up for discussion :dazzler:

I'm gonna go to bed before I get sucked into discussing music for hours :laugh:

[Jordan.]

Disco Love is one of the best song this year though why is it being dragged

[Joelle.]

It isn't when you're at a house party :dazzler:

Oh I know it, but Not Giving Up is how it should have sounded in the first place :dazzler:

[reece(:]

Little Mix are whack.

Sturdays>>>

that is all peeps.
Very nice contribution Leon :worship:
I'm gonna go to bed before I get sucked into discussing music for hours :laugh:
There'll be plenty to discuss tomorrow anyway [hint at a MKS appearance] :hugesmile:

[Z]

Disco Love is one of the best song this year though why is it being dragged

Because Una Healy reminiscing about her childhood in a song where none of her bandmates even know what a Donna Summer song is just pains me to listen to

[Joelle.]

There'll be plenty to discuss tomorrow anyway [hint at a MKS appearance] :hugesmile:

I'm guessing a relevent Sugababes vs irrelevent Sugababes duel :laugh:

[Joelle.]

One last thing, this remix > the original

FiYZRbtxTIo

[james130]

Oh I know it, but Not Giving Up is how it should have sounded in the first place :dazzler:

I layered an Acapella over the All Fired Up instrumental the other day and they are pretty much the same song. But I love them both.

[reece(:]

I'm guessing a relevent Sugababes vs irrelevent Sugababes duel :laugh:
Oh that is a must.

We shall declare it 60/40 to The Saturdays (counting Apple's views)

[Z]

I'm guessing a relevent Sugababes vs irrelevent Sugababes duel :laugh:

That's no contest; but a Sugababes 1.0 v Sugababes 2.0 v Sugababes 3.0 would be far more interesting to discuss

[reece(:]

One last thing, this remix > the original

FiYZRbtxTIo
And this remix > original too
-_3P_zqyDYo

[reece(:]

To help Zee get to bed, the next debate consists of shameless promo for two generic flop goddesses who deserve some talk since they aren't scoring discussions anywhere else. I'm sure Juan will have heard of these. Take a few mins out of your lives to check them out and post your fave.

Jessica Mauboy (buy her new album on iTunes NOW)
http://image.take40.com/300x400/jessica_mauboy_official_dec08_smile_white_plunging _top_300x400.jpg
_lqbbEm460Q
cynEO9RyZhs

vs

Kat Deluna
http://images.askmen.com/galleries/celeb-profiles-singer/kat-deluna/pictures/kat-deluna-picture-3.jpg
3Hz64-_2Gu8
MyMrZV1I1EM

[Joelle.]

Oh that is a must.

We shall declare it 60/40 to The Saturdays (counting Apple's views)

Sound about right, including Leon's stanning :dazzler:

That's no contest; but a Sugababes 1.0 v Sugababes 2.0 v Sugababes 3.0 would be far more interesting to discuss

Actually yes I was just thinking this after I posted

And this remix > original too
-_3P_zqyDYo

Flawless :love:

I layered an Acapella over the All Fired Up instrumental the other day and they are pretty much the same song. But I love them both.

Not Giving Up is basically the same song with much better lyrics

[Joelle.]

I have stanned for Kat Deluna for years but JLo keeps shamelessly snatching her weave. Flawless goddess http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[reece(:]

Drop It Low being the original twerk anthem :dazzler: I prefer that to Jessica's stuff but I prefer Jessica's discography overall.

TTEOTE slaying lives http://i.minus.com/ibxGcSrGbHG5Rr.gif

[Me. I Am Salman]

Kat Deluna
Wanna See U Dance is a bop

[Jordan.]

Don't know these flops, none.

[reece(:]

Don't know these flops, none.
And that is why they are flops :dazzler:

[Joelle.]

Dancing Tonight is perfect, pretty sure I made a thread a while ago called The Most Underrated Woman in Pop and it flopped cos people kept posting other names http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[reece(:]

I have stanned for Kat Deluna for years but JLo keeps shamelessly snatching her weave. Flawless goddess http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png
She deserved so much better with so many bops but has been one of the most eternal flops in history http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/noparty.gif

[reece(:]

Dancing Tonight is perfect, pretty sure I made a thread a while ago called The Most Underrated Woman in Pop and it flopped cos people kept posting other names http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png
It would only happen to FlopDeluna
http://i.minus.com/ibcsR3OdeVlEgu.gif

[Joelle.]

She deserved so much better with so many bops but has been one of the most eternal flops in history http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/noparty.gif

Dancing Tonight
Push Push
Whine Up
Run The Show
Drop It Low
Party O' Clock
Wanna See You Dance (La La La)
In The End

This queen deserved so much better :sad:

[Joelle.]

jcMXZjYqIog

http://static.tumblr.com/v1asjlx/SGAlysuxp/other_preach_gif.gif

[reece(:]

Party O' Clock was my jam back in the day

Me with the hairbrush: "REDONE, it's Party O'Clock" :dance:

[reece(:]

Kat is looking like she might be snatching her first victory in the music industry since debuting :shocked:

[Joelle.]

Don't know these flops, none.

Should be ashamed, snubbing the true Queen of Latin Pop http://i.imgur.com/i2BFVD2.png

[reece(:]

Should be ashamed, snubbing the true Queen of Latin Pop http://i.imgur.com/i2BFVD2.png
The Latin Twerkstar deserves morehttp://i.imgur.com/i2BFVD2.png

[Joelle.]

Kat is looking like she might be snatching her first victory in the music industry since debuting :shocked:

I have her first 2 albums - both flawfree ofcourse, but her 3rd is supposted to come out at the end of this year
http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m5spp1JzBh1qh4k47.gif

[reece(:]

I have her first 2 albums - both flawfree ofcourse, but her 3rd is supposted to come out at the end of this year
http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m5spp1JzBh1qh4k47.gif
Not a new Jessica AND Kat album in the space of a few months?
http://i.minus.com/ib0ca5AGHkceFo.gif

[Joelle.]

Party O' Clock was my jam back in the day

Me with the hairbrush: "REDONE, it's Party O'Clock" :dance:

"Hello World, Hello World, Wake Up, Wake Up, Its Party O'Clock" :dazzler:

[reece(:]

"Hello World, Hello World, Wake Up, Wake Up, Its Party O'Clock" :dazzler:
And I woke up every single time http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/4b2bd7de.gif

[Joelle.]

Not a new Jessica AND Kat album in the space of a few months?
http://i.minus.com/ib0ca5AGHkceFo.gif

Sorry I forgot this is a debate, just went overboard on my Kat stanning and forgot about the other flop goddess http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/everything/LoGdNS6.gif

[reece(:]

Sorry I forgot this is a debate, just went overboard on my Kat stanning and forgot about the other flop goddess http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/everything/LoGdNS6.gif
It's got to happen, one flop goddess will outshine another in a discussion of said flop goddesses. Poor Jessica
http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/tumblr_inline_mqis9ru5ty1qz4rgp.jpg

[Joelle.]

I'll get it back on track, this is a flawless bop :dazzler:

cynEO9RyZhs

[Joelle.]

Just realised you already posted this. Kat distracted me tho http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/everything/LoGdNS6.gif

[reece(:]

Oh she got #1 with that song, so maybe she isn't that much of a flop...:suspect: well deserved though it is a jam :dazzler:

[Joelle.]

Oh dear TTEOTE also slays. Kat could have some competition

http://24.media.tumblr.com/bca4435136968752b0d311211e29fa0b/tumblr_mv6qvgBoR01rnjdzho4_400.gif

[reece(:]

Oh dear TTEOTE also slays. Kat could have some competition

http://24.media.tumblr.com/bca4435136968752b0d311211e29fa0b/tumblr_mv6qvgBoR01rnjdzho4_400.gif
Another bop heading your way:dazzler:
zeBqpqdBXAc
http://24.media.tumblr.com/bca4435136968752b0d311211e29fa0b/tumblr_mv6qvgBoR01rnjdzho4_400.gif

[Joelle.]

Another bop heading your way:dazzler:
zeBqpqdBXAc
http://24.media.tumblr.com/bca4435136968752b0d311211e29fa0b/tumblr_mv6qvgBoR01rnjdzho4_400.gif

She slays hard with this one :dazzler:

Why couldn't Australia/NZ have sent us her instead of Lorde http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[reece(:]

She slays hard with this one :dazzler:

Why couldn't Australia/NZ have sent us her instead of Lorde http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

If only they did and I hope when it's Lorde's turn that she will be getting debated 10 foot under. :dazzler:

[Joelle.]

I didn't realise she was in that film called The Sapphires :amazed:

[Me. I Am Salman]

She slays hard with this one :dazzler:

Why couldn't Australia/NZ have sent us her instead of Lorde http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

:joker:

[reece(:]

I didn't realise she was in that film called The Sapphires :amazed:
No one ever does.... the Story Of A Flop
http://i.minus.com/ibcsR3OdeVlEgu.gif

[Joelle.]

elznTvx8l50

Shes like Kat in the way she collaborates with people you would only collaborate with to gain status, makes flawfree tunes, but flops anyway

http://i.minus.com/ibcsR3OdeVlEgu.gif

[reece(:]

elznTvx8l50

Shes like Kat in the way she collaborates with people you would only collaborate with to gain status, makes flawfree tunes, but flops anyway

http://i.minus.com/ibcsR3OdeVlEgu.gif
Not even the Flo Ridas, Pitbulls or Ludacris' of the world could save either of these gorls.

[Joelle.]

Reece you may have discovered my new stan

http://cdn.uproxx.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/crying1.gif

[reece(:]

Reece you may have discovered my new stan

http://cdn.uproxx.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/crying1.gif
Only me getting new fans onboard the flop wagon http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[Joelle.]

Can't get over this shameless JLo ripoff of Whine Up though, even though I stanned for it before I discovered Kat

6XbIuSLaCnk

[reece(:]

I'm sure Kat had a lawsuit against her for something as well :joker:

[reece(:]

Yeah, here :joker:

Not only does 41-year-old Jennifer Lopez’s new single “On the Floor” bear an uncanny resemblance to 23-year-old Kat DeLuna’s single “Party O’Clock” that was released in Europe last fall, but now so does Jennifer’s video. In a behind the scenes clip of the making of for Lopez’s music video, there are a few scenes which seem straight ripped from Kat’s. Please explain this, Gatecrasher!

When J.Lo’s video is compared to the clip for “Party O’Clock,” there are frames in which the singers look as if they dressed from the same wardrobe.

In “Party O’Clock,” DeLuna rocks leopard-print leggings and a black strapless leotard as she gyrates in a club scene.

In her video, J.Lo dons a blue leopard-print leotard with dark blue leopard leggings. According to a source who scrutinized a rough cut of Lopez’s video, J.Lo also imitates DeLuna’s “dance hall moves” as she … gyrates in a club scene.

The fact that RedOne produced both singles could account for the lyrical similarities but not for the video. A source argues that Lopez’s video is “inspired” by DeLuna’s and all J.Lo did was give Kat’s vision a bigger budget. So, you see, Jennifer is actually helping Kat. If anything, Kat should be thanking her. Or not.

A former Sony BMG employee says this isn’t the first time Lopez has been “inspired” by Kat. Back in 2007, they both recorded for the same record company. DeLuna was working on her first album and her label suggested using the song “Miles in These Shoes” as her first single.

Jennifer laughed a hearty laugh, pointed her bony finger at record execs and told them to bring the song and some donuts to her. She “specifically urged executives to withdraw the song from Kat” so she could record it for the 2007 album “Brave.”

On Wednesday, DeLuna may have had enough and through a spokespersons said:

“I’ve seen this before, where the more established artist tries to take the vision and artistic ideas away from an emerging artist, and assumes no one will notice because of their bigger shadow,” DeLuna said through her spokesman. “Luckily, my loyal fans and the power of the Internet have let the ‘Kat’ out of the bag.”

DeLuna remains a good sport about the situation: “Business is business,” she says, adding she’s focusing on positive feedback from her upcoming single, “Dancing Tonight.”

Jennifer Lopez sounds like a bitch. She acts sweet and nice but that image is directly contrasted by these stories of her screwing people over and acting like a diva.

If you haven’t already, go check out Gatecrasher’s side-by-side of Jennifer and DeLuna. Jennifer’s photo is perfect. It makes her look like a soul-sucking she-devil. Also, Jennifer’s behind the scenes and Kat’s video below.

Jennifer Lopez is oblivious to allegations her new song “On the Floor” bears striking similarities to a track by R&B singer Kat Deluna, insisting she is “not aware” of the brewing controversy.

The “Love Don’t Cost a Thing” hitmaker debuted her single last month, but the tune immediately caught the attention of music fans who pointed out its resemblance to DeLuna’s track “Party O’Clock,” which was released in Europe in November.

Both songs were produced by RedOne and feature similar lyrics and harmonies, while Lopez’s promo for “On The Floor” is also said to borrow elements from DeLuna’s video.


Dominique Charriau/Getty Images

DeLuna recently accused the superstar of “taking away” her ideas, but insisted she had no plans to sue Lopez, saying, “Business is business.”

Now Lopez has broken her silence about the controversy and dismissed the criticism after being quizzed about the claims during an appearance on Spanish TV show, “Despierta America.”

Speaking in Spanish, she replied, “I’m not aware of that… No, I didn’t hear about it.”

[Joelle.]

I thought she had :joker:

I miss the days of Love Down Cost A Thing JLo and the kween of R&B jams, not this flop goddess ripoff.

[reece(:]

By tradition, the flop goddesses have flopped. So we shall move on. Both of these have been in successful girl bands but who is best?

http://i.huffpost.com/gen/895614/thumbs/o-CHERYL-COLE-570.jpg?6
http://marieclaire.media.ipcdigital.co.uk/11116/00004364b/b238_orh355w322/Cheryl-Cole-218.jpg
vs
http://images.askmen.com/photos/nicole-scherzinger/36338.jpg
http://www.aceshowbiz.com/images/wennpic/nicole-scherzinger-national-television-awards-2013-01.jpg

[Joelle.]

One more point on the flop goddesses. I think we can call it a draw, Jessica might have a number 1 in Australia and starred in a successful film, but Kat's Run The Show is a playable song on Just Dance 4, so all in all I'd say it's a close one. Gotta give it to Kat though :lovedup:

[reece(:]

One more point on the flop goddesses. I think we can call it a draw, Jessica might have a number 1 in Australia, but Kat's Run The Show is a playable song on Just Dance 4, so all in all I'd say it's a close one. Gotta give it to Kat though :lovedup:
I thought a draw too and can agree on that (since we were the only valid debaters for that round).

[Joelle.]

Hmm as much as I want to stan for Nicole on this one, Sexy Den A Mutha has me swayed http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[reece(:]

Cheryl has some jams but Poison/Don't Hold Your Breath just edges it for me and Nicole has much better vocals and is tolerable

[Joelle.]

Yeah I would say Call My Name, Under The Sun, FFTL and Sexy Den A Mutha are jams, but unfortunately it's Cheryl...

http://marieclaire.media.ipcdigital.co.uk/11116/00004364b/b238_orh355w322/Cheryl-Cole-218.jpg

[reece(:]

Boomerang wasn't all that great though and it shocks me how she got #1 with it :shocked:

[Joelle.]

Nicole on the other hand is a 'not flawless but close' goddess. Poison, Don't Hold Your Breath and Killer Love are her best jams but Boomerang lets her down.

[Joelle.]

This is a jam too :dazzler:

cKxrSMEkbMs

[reece(:]

v__h2wgNwCc

This is her best from that album, "I've been picking little fight with the girl in the mirror" :dazzler:

[Joelle.]

Kat Deluna fans could easily be called Delunatics. I don't get how this hasn't been picked up on by the big labels. :suspect:

Its actually not a bad album A Million Lights, most of her jams seem to be on there.

But this jam from Nicole, I can't...
_yjeROQh9Bk

[reece(:]

Kat Deluna fans could easily be called Delunatics. I don't get how this hasn't been picked up on by the big labels. :suspect:

Or they could be called Delusionals :laugh:

[reece(:]

Nicole's album is full of bops but most are forgettable sadly http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/sosad.gif

[Joelle.]

Or they could be called Delusionals :laugh:

Most likely considering I'm stanning for a flop thats probably never getting anywhere :joker:

[Joelle.]

Nicole's album is full of bops but most are forgettable sadly http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/sosad.gif

Aside from the first three flawfree bops, the rest of the album isn't great. Wet was okay but I remember it basically sounding like a rip off of Only Girl http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[reece(:]

Right There as well though, how could I forget :love:

[Joelle.]

Right There was flawless I agree :dazzler:

[reece(:]

She hasn't properly WOWed me since PCD days though :(

[Joelle.]

A flawless feature from Nic :love:

gOfOt76D3MM

[Joelle.]

She hasn't properly WOWed me since PCD days though :(

She needs to sort her weave out, make up with Ashley and Kimberley etc. and bring us Don't Cha Part 2

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar68662_20.gif

[reece(:]

A flawless feature from Nic :love:

gOfOt76D3MM
Omg that song, I can't :laugh2:
She needs to sort her weave out, make up with Ashley and Kimberley etc. and bring us Don't Cha Part 2

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar68662_20.gif

And she needs to serve another Buttons-bop :dazzler:

[Joelle.]

Off topic a flawless R&B duel for the future: Ashanti vs Christina Milian :love:

We require more bops such as this though

qBsEF7Qx09o

[reece(:]

I Don't Need A Man http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/ccd10a8e.gifhttp://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/ccd10a8e.gifhttp://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/ccd10a8e.gifhttp://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/ccd10a8e.gif

[Joelle.]

Disney Miley Cyrus vs unhinged Miley Cyrus

[Joelle.]

I forgot how utterly flawfree this song was until I posted it. I just can't...

http://cdn.uproxx.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/crying1.gif

[Saph]

Chavryl can't even compete with Nicole

Right There was the best song of 2011
YkdkX6_3iGI

[Z]

Nicole Scherzinger is superior in every way.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Baby Love, Whatever U Like, Puakenikeni, Don't Hold Your Breath and Right There > anything by Cheryl

[james130]

Nicole in this debate, but Melody. :love:

and tehe at Nicole messing up in this
2nPDKtVWylY

RNInfvQqgDI

[james130]

But back to Nicole...

Cheryl could never get close to this vocal.
tE6SRBnDHx8

[Me. I Am Salman]

Beep is one of the best songs of all time.

[Jordan.]

Nicole cause Right There :worship:

Also this classic feat

NVk4vENObiI

[Me. I Am Salman]

Omg Heartbeat :worship:

[james130]

Yes! Heartbeat should have done so much better. :idc:

[reece(:]

Beep is one of the best songs of all time.
Preach dat sis :dazzler:

[Joelle.]

Looks like this could be a close call

http://marieclaire.media.ipcdigital.co.uk/11116/00004364b/b238_orh355w322/Cheryl-Cole-218.jpg

[reece(:]

So much Chavryl bashing
http://marieclaire.media.ipcdigital.co.uk/11116/00004364b/b238_orh355w322/Cheryl-Cole-218.jpg

[Joelle.]

Way too much shade directed at the Kween of Newcastle

http://www.reactiongifs.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Cheryl-Cole-sad.gif

[reece(:]

I think Nicole has owned Chavryl here.

[Me. I Am Salman]

can we have a new one pls

[Joelle.]

Aside from the fact it is Chavryl, she loses regardless for being Will.i.am's muse

http://www.reactiongifs.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Cheryl-Cole-sad.gif

[reece(:]

Yas we can, I declare Nicole victor.
new: The next is between two pop kweens who were significant in the mid noughties.

http://www4.pictures.zimbio.com/bg/Fergie+Logo+NewNowNext+Awards+2013+5yjfmgCOvUYl.jp g

vs

http://shelookbook.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/The-mane-of-Gwen-Stefani.jpg

[Me. I Am Salman]

I would like a new one please http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar59229_46.gif

[Me. I Am Salman]

Oh wait

[Me. I Am Salman]

Fergie tbh

[Joelle.]

Glamorous is such a flawless bop :dazzler:

q0SyUgw98tE

[reece(:]

Such a difficult one for me, I like them both so much...
http://marieclaire.media.ipcdigital.co.uk/11116/00004364b/b238_orh355w322/Cheryl-Cole-218.jpg

[reece(:]

Glamorous is such a flawless bop :dazzler:

q0SyUgw98tE
Glamorous is one of the best songs of the noughties <3

That last verse http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/52b0f867.gif

[Joelle.]

But then Gwen has

TGwZ7MNtBFU

I think this takes it :love:

[Me. I Am Salman]

I like Glamorous (loved it a lot when I was younger) but lbr London Bridge & Fergalicious >

[Joelle.]

Gwen's two album discography is flawless though :dazzler:

Also No Doubt > Black Eyed Peas

[Joelle.]

Glamorous is one of the best songs of the noughties <3

That last verse http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/52b0f867.gif

http://cdn.uproxx.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/crying1.gif

[reece(:]

Glamorous > Gwen > Rest of Fergie's stuff

[Joelle.]

Glamorous > Gwen > Rest of Fergie's stuff

I agree with this tbh but there is one song that runs Glamorous close

9rlNpWYQunY

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ed2305b7.png

[reece(:]

What an underrated gem
http://i.minus.com/irFEFSqaDROFK.gif

[BBfanUSA]

Finally is a great ballad.

[Joelle.]

"What, come together all over the world
From the hoods of Japan, Harajuku girls
What"
:dazzler:

[Jordan.]

I only use Glamorous and Sweet Escape from either of them so I call a draw

http://www4.pictures.zimbio.com/bg/Fergie+Logo+NewNowNext+Awards+2013+5yjfmgCOvUYl.jp g

[james130]

I find this so hard. :(

Agree with everyone on the flawlesity of Glamorous and I loved Longon Bridge as well.
So I think Fergie might just take it for me.

[Samm]

Gwen 100%

[Niamh.]

Gwen by a landslide

[Samm]

O0lf_fE3HwA
:love:

gZHjRQjbHrE
:worship:

f5qICl3Fr3w
:lovedup:

[Niamh.]

Wt88GMJmVk0

[Samm]

and... Gwen looks natural and beautiful and Fergie face looks like some one sat on it

[Samm]

Wt88GMJmVk0

:love:

[Saph]

Gwen > Fergie

both are flawless queens of pop

All of Gwens singles are amazing (the rest of her albums are a bit less amazing) and Fergie is fierce

[Samm]

the only fergie single that I like is Fergalicious

[Niamh.]

and... Gwen looks natural and beautiful and Fergie face looks like some one sat on it

Yeah, Gwen is absolutely stunning and I love her style

[Gstar]

Sorry I've arrived so late to this thread. Keri Hilson >>>>>>>>>> Nelly Furtado.

ok, now,

This is probably the hardest ones because they're both equally great and did more less the same things career wise (going solo from a group). As flawless as Fergie's solo career was I have to stick to my real childhood nostalgia and pick Gwen.

Gwen's songs with Eve > your faves discography and their mommas too

[Saph]

Gwen's songs with Eve > your faves discography and their mommas too

http://media.tumblr.com/7878470fe7f2185f6c6d139b599def83/tumblr_inline_mv3n2ttZGr1r1fh7e.gif

[Shaun]

gwen. hands down.

and What You Waiting For & Early Winter > Glamourous :idc:

[Me. I Am Salman]

Rich Girl is crap tho

[Me. I Am Salman]

and... Gwen looks natural and beautiful and Fergie face looks like some one sat on it

omg

[Saph]

Rich Girl is a defining moment in music history

[Me. I Am Salman]

ew no
Luxorious is however

[Shaun]

yeah Rich Girl is terrible.

[Kate!]

I like Fergie but Gwen is of pop goddess status and therefore wins hands down.

[reece(:]

Also taking into account their latest offerings, I think I know which I prefer....
0ZgjmE6xdaw

hunha8UtqCk

[Samm]

I also find it annoying when people on YouTube go on and comment under Gwen's videos and say that she has copied gaga :bored: gaga *******ing copy's everyone And Gwen was before gaga errrrr

[reece(:]

They're a joke, they go on Xtina's 2006 videos saying she copied Gaga then.. all you can do is cackle. :laugh:

[Gstar]

Ya'll need to re evaluate your lives before disliking "Rich Girl"

http://24.media.tumblr.com/bca4435136968752b0d311211e29fa0b/tumblr_mv6qvgBoR01rnjdzho4_400.gif

[Samm]

Sweet escape > rich girl

[Niamh.]

yeah Rich Girl is terrible.

Rich girl is fantastic

[Shaun]

songs that have to go to Fiddler on the Roof for melodies are far from fantastic.

[Me. I Am Salman]

I like Sweet Escape but tbh that's not groundbreaking either

[Niamh.]

songs that have to go to Fiddler on the Roof for melodies are far from fantastic.

I like the sound of it, that's good enough for me

[reece(:]

It seems Gwen has taken this debate by a landslide.

[Jordan.]

Well what's the next debate http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar16878_16.gif

[reece(:]

It's a truel. http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/8f70c6ea.gif Between the three main disney chicas... let this debate begin.

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2013/11/10/article-2498471-1955CFEA00000578-983_634x1014.jpg
vs
http://media1.onsugar.com/files/2013/11/08/737/n/1922398/17a7c45b7a49a552_Selena.preview/i/Selena-Gomez-Flaunt-Magazine-November-2013.jpg
vs
http://i.minus.com/ix2ndyZ7EdFLD.gif

[Saph]

Miley > Selena > Demetria

http://i.minus.com/ix2ndyZ7EdFLD.gif

[reece(:]

Miley > Selena > Demetria

http://i.minus.com/ix2ndyZ7EdFLD.gif
[2]

BANGERZ ****s on discographies and Come and Get It was my jam of the spring. http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/ec20fb7f.gif

Demi has a few cute hits though.

[Saph]

is > a downwards arrow because someone told me that it actually means 'greater than'

so like if I said Miley > Selena meaning Miley is better, it actually means the other way around :s

[Jordan.]

AByfaYcOm4A

3KKsu68Knss

>> the lessers

[reece(:]

is > a downwards arrow because someone told me that it actually means 'greater than'

so like if I said Miley > Selena meaning Miley is better, it actually means the other way around :s
Don't confuse me like dat http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/19971843.gif

[reece(:]

AByfaYcOm4A

3KKsu68Knss

>> the lessers
Demi's greatest two songs.

[Saph]

(demis only songs)

[Brother Leon]

New Miley>Demi>Old Miley>Selena

[Jake.]

Miley>>

[Jake.]

New Miley>Demi>Old Miley>Selena

This tbh

[reece(:]

(demis only songs)
Not y'all dragging Neon Lights like that
I25IBwGIyRc

[Samm]

Selena>Miley>Demi

[reece(:]

Also this song with Missy Elliott she did needs some recognition :worship:
8JhLhslZSSc

[smeagol]

3 people no one will remember not worth debating surely lol
whos best out of crap turd and poo hard to say as they all stink lol

[reece(:]

Nice to see all the Miley love in here. http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/67d90ee8.gif

[Saph]

3 people no one will remember not worth debating surely lol
whos best out of crap turd and poo hard to say as they all stink lol

Miley will live on forever tbh

Demi and Selena.. maybe not

[reece(:]

Miley has shown she can reinvent herself and it has worked.
http://i.minus.com/iWThWC6qlcflX.gif

[james130]

The real disney queen >>>>>>>>>

http://26.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_llc4vbAg2A1qhfnj9o1_500.gif

[Saph]

britney and xtina are the original disney queens tbh

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0007Z9QX0.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

[Smithy]

Demi > Miley > Selena

Demi easily has the best voice and albums, mileys older stuff was better, like the time of our lives EP and selena uses so much autotune it could be anyone singing her songs

[MeMyselfAndI]

Miley's old stuff > Selena > Demi > Miley's new stuff

Probably Selena purely because of the mess that is Miley now

[Joelle.]

http://cdn.idolator.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/01/demi-lovato-album-cover-art-2013-400x400.jpg

This album was my jam for the first half of 2013, but tbh SMS (Bangerz) alone ****s all over it and Selena's existence (apart for Come and Get It). The forum deity has spoken, now ya'll preach.

http://i.minus.com/ibn6CfFw83egJF.gif

[reece(:]

SMS (Bangerz) alone ****s all over it


Reminding us why you are the deity. http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/67d90ee8.gif

[Joelle.]

I need some recognition for this bop also http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ATRLSmilies/Halloween%202013/alexz2_zps0e303d31.gif

tn-UK953aIU

[Me. I Am Salman]

*agrees with the SMS statement*

[Me. I Am Salman]

Oh and I ****ing hate Demi, Heartattack is the worst song of the year
Selena is meh, I loved Naturally