Live or not live Judges Houses?

[zakman440]

After seeing how the live Judges Houses format works, which format do you prefer - live or not live?

Personally, not live will always be the best. Tonight is just demonstrating that having this stage live will not work, what with the constant audio issues and the audience being worse than Big Brother's rent-a-mob.

[Firewire]

I miss the Whitney Houston instrumental segments with contestants bawling their eyes out

[lewis111]

I miss the Whitney Houston instrumental segments with contestants bawling their eyes out

This 100%

[zakman440]

Now the shows over, which format are you preferring?

[lewis111]

Non live, they can edit it to actual feel dramatic instead of a BB eviction style countdown which leads to 20 more seconds of thinking

[Daniel-X]

Non live >

[Kate!]

I miss the Whitney Houston instrumental segments with contestants bawling their eyes out

This

I like the emotions of proper judges houses

[Denver]

They could have at least had someone like Tesco Mary perform to bring in the viewer's

[Jordan.]

It was okay but too dragged out

[Liam-]

I actually really like this format, it's a lot more suspenseful and lot less cheesy.

[Kate!]

Its too clinical

[andybigbro]

Not live.

I like when they sit and tell them alone

[LukeB]

Its too clinical

It's looks trashy r.i.p to judges houses

[LukeB]

Not live.

I like when they sit and tell them alone

"Pet i'm taking you through to the live shows" with westlife playing in the background >>>> "Cheryl please reveal your 1st choice bla bla bla!

[BigSister]

Not live. I wouldn't have minded pre recorded with Olly and Caroline in the Studio and a little interview with the judges saying why they picked each act and then maybe bringing them on but tonight it just seemed rushed and dragged out.

[Cal.]

Live is more tense.

Plus I could do without the endless What About Now/Say Something instrumentals complete with contestants looking dramatically beyond the horizon

[JoshBB]

I much prefer this new format.

[Smithy]

Live, non live is far too dragged out with montages and unnecessary interviews

[joeysteele]

Last night was chronic and endlessly tedious to watch, far too long so for me I am now of the view this show has had its day and it is time it was rested.
I really hate the all bout the drama nonsense it has become.
Awful, just awful.

[Lostie!]

It was a mess. Not only was it unnecessary but the pleas and the audience literally drowning everything out was just a shambles.