The X Factor 2015 Week 2 Live Show Discussion Thread: ITVHD 8PM

[Johnnyuk123]

James Arthur 2. :joker::joker::joker:

[Denver]

All the judges must have cramp.

[Will.]

wow!

[King Gizzard]

9/10

Best of the season so far

[Drew.]

That was trash

you can't be serious

[Natalie.]

Love his voice but this song is boring, it reminds me of adverts for butter or something with pictures of fields

:joker::joker:

[Jordan.]

4th Impact - 6.5/10
Mason Noise - 6/10
Anton - 2/10
Keira - 7/10
Che - 8/10

[LukeB]

Kiera - 8/10
4th Impact - 7.5/10
Mason - 7/10
Che - 7/10
Anton - 3/10

[Vanessa]

I'm voting for Anton. He was sabotaged. :nono:

[Magicqueen]

It was the best performance so far but it just didn't have that kind of wow factor so I'm just waiting for Monica now to bring it

[Locke.]

Can Anton move to Nick's category please so he can have someone that will actually give him songs that suit him

[Kazanne]

Best of the night

[Amy Jade]

4th Impact - 3
Mason - 6
Anton - 6
Keira - 8
Che - 8

[King Gizzard]

His voice is 10 times better than James Arthur's and it doesn't sound like he's killing his vocal chords every time like James did

And he has far more control than Jahmene..Jahmene was trash

[Lostie!]

That was good. :clap1:

1. Kiera Weathers
2. Che Chesterman
3. 4th Impact
4. Mason Noise
5. Anton Stephans

[Natalie.]

The judges should have one from each category

[Ross.]

ngl Nick has been a pretty good mentor

[Ammi]

..'you are so current right now'....

[Denver]

what is Simon on about? you just saw his VT so you know who was singing.

[Johnnyuk123]

They have him on a strict diet and by week 4 the contacts go in and the eyebrows get plucked to death. :hehe:

[lewis111]

why do they pass to the other host just for them to say "don't forget to vote... later"

[Drew.]

His voice is 10 times better than James Arthur's and it doesn't sound like he's killing his vocal chords every time like James did

And he has far more control than Jahmene..Jahmene was trash

not to mention he's not a complete twat like James

[Samm]

Louisa and Seann :love:

[Jason.]

Ross have you gone off Max?

Shall I stan Louisa on your behalf now?

[LukeB]

Louisa <3, not keen on Sean if he continues to be musical

[Kate!]

you can't be serious

Imo. :shrug: he'd flop as hard as James Arthur if he won. Would you fork out to go to a concert of his as opposed to someone like Louisa who has the full package. He can sing ok but he's no charisma.

[Shaun]

*actually just grimaced @ Jason having a big bang theory avatar*

[Jason.]

Louisa <3, not keen on Sean if he continues to be musical

Well it is a singing show? :conf:

[Ross.]

Ross have you gone off Max?

Shall I stan Louisa on your behalf now?

He's still in my sig :suspect:

[Jason.]

*actually just grimaced @ Jason having a big bang theory avatar*

:nono:

[Ross.]

*actually just grimaced @ Jason having a big bang theory avatar*

Finally someone agrees

[Drew.]

Imo. :shrug: he'd flop as hard as James Arthur if he won. Would you fork out to go to a concert of his as opposed to someone like Louisa who has the full package. He can sing ok but he's no charisma.

I don't do concerts so can't really answer that.. if he produced an album though he'd be making money no question, does the job for Sam Smith. Louisa isn't a good person to compare him to, two completely different types of performers

[Ammi]

..Livia loves The Big Bang Theory...

[Shaun]

Finally someone agrees

It is actually the worst

Ok ty ammi for bringing her up after my original post. *hasty edit*

[Ross.]

Also Jason what are you even doing in here you don't watch the XFactor :joker:

[LukeB]

Well it is a singing show? :conf:

I know :laugh: but I don't like musicals

[Jason.]

Finally someone agrees

If you're going to bully me, I'll just stan one of Luke's silly favourites instead. :hmph:

[Jason.]

Luke who do you like?

[Daniel-X]

So far for me tonight

1. Mason Noise
2. 4th Impact
3. Kiera Weathers
4. Che Chesterman
5. Anton Stephans

I've really really liked all of them apart from Anton (wtf what that) tonight

[Jason.]

Also Jason what are you even doing in here you don't watch the XFactor :joker:

I'm bored ngl.

[Kate!]

He has to be compared to Louisa. She's part of his competition. And she's knocking him into a hat so far.

[LukeB]

The best singer is up

[King Gizzard]

Urgh this Favourite Things cover

[Ammi]

It is actually the worst

Ok ty ammi for bringing her up after my original post. *hasty edit*

...I didn't see yours until after and thought...ok, should I delete...

[Denver]

Louisa is ruining this song :facepalm:

[Jason.]

I'll stan 4th Impact from now on.

GO 4TH IMPACT!

[Ross.]

It is actually the worst


:clap1:

Marry me please

[Ross.]

I'll stan 4th Impact from now on.

GO 4TH IMPACT!

That's fine by me. :smug:

[King Gizzard]

Louisa doesn't know the beach boys so she can go to hell

[Babayaro.]

He has to be compared to Louisa. She's part of his competition. And she's knocking him into a hat so far.

It's a marathon not a sprint

[Samm]

Louisa is ruining this song :facepalm:

um it hasn't even started yet

[Jason.]

:clap1:

Marry me please

Ugh get a room...just not the chat room

[King Gizzard]

And she looks really smug

[Lostie!]

Also Jason what are you even doing in here you don't watch the XFactor :joker:

He just has a lot of feelings.

[Kate!]

Gwan Louisa

[Denver]

um it hasn't even started yet

I come from the future

[Jordan.]

Soul diva

[Jason.]

He just has a lot of feelings.

:joker:

[Amy Jade]

Louisa grabs my attention as soon as she starts singing

[Samm]

This is amazing ugshsjbssi :love:

[Drew.]

He has to be compared to Louisa. She's part of his competition. And she's knocking him into a hat so far.

Shes probably the best in the competition so thats fair enough, this thing that every singer has to dance or move about on stage to be relevant is a myth though

[LukeB]

:clap1: this is already amazing!

[Shaun]

Great version. I'm sure it'll come out to be someone else's though.

[Johnnyuk123]

She is murdering this classic MJ song.

[Kate!]

Credible Louisa :love:

[Denver]

Louisa i dont want to worry you but i think you ripped your jeans.

[Jason.]

Ugh get a room...just not the chat room

or Sheldon's room...cause nobody goes into this room

[Ross.]

Omg Louisa :love:

[Babayaro.]

Great version. I'm sure it'll come out to be someone else's though.

Jay James teas

[Lostie!]

NOT another Illumianti pyramid. #StopTheBrainwashing

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/f/f3/Tin_foil_hat_2.jpg

[Jordan.]

:mewithoutmywig:

[Samm]

<3333

[LukeB]

Louisa stealing the show yet again :clap1:

[King Gizzard]

She surely didn't need this show to become a pop star, she sounds like she's already there

[Jason.]

Louisa :love:

[Locke.]

Very good performance but I'm not sure which part was supposed to be making it her own

[lewis111]

no need for that last note, made it seem to try hard IMO

[Ammi]

..I love her, I love her vocals but I didn't like the song version..:sad:...

[Natalie.]

I like her voice but didn't really like this version

[LukeB]

Louisa - 10/10
Kiera - 8/10
4th Impact - 7.5/10
Mason - 7/10
Che - 7/10
Anton - 3/10

[Babayaro.]

That was good but too shouty at times

[Daniel-X]

I usually really like Louisa. But I didn't like that as much as I usually like her performances.

[Samm]

That was good but too shouty at times

I don't get the whole "too shouty" thing and never will

[Ross.]

..I love her, I love her vocals but I didn't like the song version..:sad:...

:shocked:

Love it Ammi or else.. :fist:

[Jordan.]

4th Impact - 6.5/10
Mason Noise - 6/10
Anton - 2/10
Keira - 7/10
Che - 8/10
Louisa - 8.5/10

[Magicqueen]

When I look at Louisa I keep thinking she's 21 not 17

[Daniel-X]

I like her voice but didn't really like this version

[2]

[Ammi]

I like her voice but didn't really like this version

..I think technically she was faultless but she just didn't bring any life to the song for me...

[Ross.]

And you Natalie, Marc and Daniel :fist:

[Drew.]

Joint top with Che yet again

[Kate!]

She is murdering this classic MJ song.

:nono: don't be silly. She reinvented it which is what's been asked of them this week.

[Amy Jade]

4th Impact - 3
Mason - 6
Anton - 6
Keira - 8
Che - 8
Louisa - 8

[Will.]

Theres still an hour and 10 mins, thought theres only like 4 acts left?

[Lostie!]

1. Louise Johnson
2. Kiera Weathers
3. Che Chesterman
4. 4th Impact
5. Mason Noise
6. Anton Stephans

[Babayaro.]

Said from bootcamp it will be a Che and Louisa final 2. Still think this

[Jason.]

[3]

I'm just agreeing with people and pretending I'm actually watching this

[LeatherTrumpet]

Louisa singing a song she does not understand

Pathetic

[Natalie.]

And you Natalie, Marc and Daniel :fist:

:hehe:

[Ammi]

:shocked:

Love it Ammi or else.. :fist:

..I love her though..:laugh:..and she'll stay I'm sure so next week the song will be amazing for her as well.../true story...

[Drew.]

Said from bootcamp it will be a Che and Louisa final 2. Still think this

with any luck

Definitely going to be the two with the most success after the show

[Amy Jade]

I don't stand Seann

[LeatherTrumpet]

Anton please go now before tomorrow

[Kate!]

Louisa singing a song she does not understand

Pathetic

Bit harsh.

[King Gizzard]

Theres still an hour and 10 mins, thought theres only like 4 acts left?

Reggie and Bollie are doing All the Trapped in the closet's

[Jason.]

1. Louise Johnson
2. Kiera Weathers
3. Che Chesterman
4. 4th Impact
5. Mason Noise
6. Anton Stephans

Liking the uniqueness of ranking them rather than rating them /10

[Babayaro.]

I don't get the whole "too shouty" thing and never will

She shouted too much :shrug:

[Natalie.]

Reggie and Bollie are doing All the Trapped in the closet's

:joker::joker::joker:

[LeatherTrumpet]

These fkg xmas ads ffs

Fck OFF

[Daniel-X]

1. Mason Noise - 8.5/10
2. 4th Impact - 8/10
3. Kiera Weathers - 7.5/10
4. Che Chesterman - 7/10
5. Louisa Johnson - 6/10
6. Anton Stephans - 2/10

[Lostie!]

Liking the uniqueness of ranking them rather than rating them /10

I love any opportunity for a good rank. :hee:

[Johnnyuk123]

Louisa singing a song she does not understand

Pathetic

She's going for the lesbian voters.:joker:

[LeatherTrumpet]

Bit harsh.

No its not

That song was written for a reason by mj

A man

Not for a wee lassie to cover

[LukeB]

She shouted too much :shrug:

She was doing a high note, Whitney,Adele,Mariah and Leona all do the same :laugh:

[Ammi]

.I'm looking forward to Lucas coming in from work, 10 minutes before the end and screaming at them all...xoxoxoxoxoxox...

[Jason.]

She was doing a high note, Whitney,Adele,Mariah and Leona all do the same :laugh:

i agree.

no really i do

[King Gizzard]

They've shipped Olly backstage cause he's so ****e

[Samm]

She shouted too much :shrug:

I could say the same for Che last week, but since shouting is completely different I won't.

[Babayaro.]

.I'm looking forward to Lucas coming in from work, 10 minutes before the end and screaming at them all...xoxoxoxoxoxox...

Calling Max everything under the sun too :hehe:

[Kate!]

No its not

That song was written for a reason by mj

A man

Not for a wee lassie to cover

:p sexist claptrap. She nailed it.

[Ross.]

They've shipped Olly backstage cause he's so ****e

:joker:

[Jason.]

Crap I forgot to take a shower.

[Amy Jade]

No its not

That song was written for a reason by mj

A man

Not for a wee lassie to cover
So what? she can't sing it because it's not sung by a man?

[LeatherTrumpet]

1. Mason Noise - 8.5/10
2. 4th Impact - 8/10
3. Kiera Weathers - 7.5/10
4. Che Chesterman - 7/10
5. Louisa Johnson - 6/10
6. Anton Stephans - 2/10

Oh ffs

Do u even know that terrible womak song?

[Shaun]

Flashbacks to last year and people claiming Andrea was too shouty and as if he didn't have one of the greatest voices the shows ever had.

[Ammi]

Calling Max everything under the sun too :hehe:

...:laugh:..yeah, and hey luvvies btw...xoxoxoxox...

[LeatherTrumpet]

So what? she can't sing it because it's not sung by a man?

Yes
As it sounds ridiculous

[Amy Jade]

If he keeps crying he'll wipe his hideous brows off

[Babayaro.]

I could say the same for Che last week, but since shouting is completely different I won't.

Go for it. I do not care

[Kate!]

Perched for Seann appearing makeup free one of the weeks

[King Gizzard]

Jahmene was shouty

[LukeB]

Yes
As it sounds ridiculous

What do you think of Che last week? he sang an Amy Winehouse song.

[Amy Jade]

Yes
As it sounds ridiculous

You sound ridiculous tbh :idc:

[Samm]

King of art

[Jason.]

I'm trying my absolute hardest to not liberate this thread. I've typed out like 10 posts and thought twice before posting them. :worry:

[Denver]

Seann giving the best ever vocal performance in history.

[Ammi]

...wow, he's doing it as well..:love:..

[Natalie.]

Lostie do you like the leaves and that

[Babayaro.]

Btw I do like Louisa, just saying

[Kate!]

Seann is doing well

[LeatherTrumpet]

What do you think of Che last week? he sang an Amy Winehouse song.

Was that song about a guy who got a bird up the duff?

[King Gizzard]

He's good

[Daniel-X]

They're trying to make Seann cabaret and I'm not here for it tbh but I prefer this a lot more to last weeks performance

[Amy Jade]

Does Seann not own another pair of heels, he's had them on every time we've seen him

[Ammi]

I'm trying my absolute hardest to not liberate this thread. I've typed out like 10 posts and thought twice before posting them. :worry:

...feel that inner teacher and let it out..:laugh:..

[Shaun]

I like the version but his voice always sounds so strained to me

[Natalie.]

He's great,lovely song choice

[Withano]

Hes incredible

[Samm]

:love:

[LeatherTrumpet]

Zzzżzźzzy

[LukeB]

Louisa - 10/10
Kiera - 8/10
4th Impact - 7.5/10
Mason - 7/10
Che - 7/10
Sean 6.5/10
Anton - 3/10

[Ninastar]

wooooooooow...that was incredible. Just stop with the crazy make up

[Lostie!]

Lostie do you like the leaves and that

Lovely. :hee:

A little incorrect since the song specifies brown leaves, though. :idc:

[LukeB]

Sean had such a good reception from the crowd

[Jordan.]

Bored of him

[Ammi]

..I thought I'd hate it/Beach Boys..:love:..but I loved it..:flutter:..

[Ross.]

That vocal :love:

[Babayaro.]

Why do these performances seem so short?

[LeatherTrumpet]

It was rubbish

Rita copying nick

Dreadful

[LukeB]

Why do these performances seem so short?

Seann shouted too:smug:

[Jason.]

...feel that inner teacher and let it out..:laugh:..

:hehe:

[Natalie.]

Lovely. :hee:

A little incorrect since the song specifies brown leaves, though. :idc:

love that you noticed that :laugh:

[Kate!]

Why is Simon so patronising.

[Amy Jade]

4th Impact - 3
Mason - 6
Anton - 6
Keira - 8
Che - 8
Louisa - 8
Seann - 4

[King Gizzard]

It was rubbish

Rita copying nick

Dreadful

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar37810_725.gif

[LukeB]

Seann didn't get much claps from the audience :laugh:

[King Gizzard]

Boring Essex girl and the other brunette to go this week pls

[Natalie.]

Tell him Nick
Save Anton

[Jordan.]

4th Impact - 6.5/10
Mason Noise - 6/10
Anton - 2/10
Keira - 7/10
Che - 8/10
Louisa - 8.5/10
Seann - 6/10

[Ross.]

Sean had such a good reception from the crowd

Seann didn't get much claps from the audience :laugh:

sowhatisthetruth.gif

[Jason.]

Seann didn't get much claps from the audience :laugh:

http://i.imgur.com/wWczyUe.gif

[Lostie!]

1. Seann Miley Moore
2. Louisa Johnson
3. Kiera Weathers
4. Che Chesterman
5. 4th Impact
6. Mason Noise
7. Anton Stephans

Again, I wouldn't say it was reinvented since it was basically a cover of the Sia version but it was great.

[Ross.]

No thanks Caroline I'll pass @ Monica

[LukeB]

sowhatisthetruth.gif

the 1st one was clearly sarcasm :smug:

[Denver]

Simon is trying to sabotage Seann

[Jason.]

the 1st one was clearly sarcasm :smug:

t'was stale tbf

[LukeB]

No thanks Caroline I'll pass @ Monica

Let's go to starbucks we won't miss much but lets make sure we are back in time for Max

[LukeB]

t'was stale tbf

Are you even watching xf?

[Kate!]

Simon is trying to sabotage Seann

He was very very patronising towards him.

[Amy Jade]

Simon is trying to sabotage Seann

He doesn't have to, the poor song choices, mehhh vocals and cliché staging and outfits are what's sabotaging him.

[Jason.]

Are you even watching xf?

ofc i am :nono:

[King Gizzard]

Ellie should retire

[LukeB]

ofc i am :nono:

I believe you:smug:

[Jason.]

I believe you:smug:

Sarcasm?

/sheldon

[LukeB]

awaits for the coco cola advert

[LukeB]

Sarcasm?

/sheldon

https://38.media.tumblr.com/ee729fe51c22a3431e105992fd1f0eaa/tumblr_inline_nx02kthmn21sc6o7n_500.gif

[Ammi]

awaits for the coco cola advert

..we have the Coca Cola lorry coming to our local town next Thursday/this Thursday...

[Ross.]

Where are Reggie n Bollie to liven this up

[Jason.]

https://38.media.tumblr.com/ee729fe51c22a3431e105992fd1f0eaa/tumblr_inline_nx02kthmn21sc6o7n_500.gif

ffs :joker:

yeah that picture just reminded me i need to take my shower. I'll go now.

[Amy Jade]

The testco advert posses me off because people do actually argue over prices but I normally get called a bitch at the end :(

[LukeB]

..we have the Coca Cola lorry coming to our local town next Thursday/this Thursday...

Apparently they are not coming to Birmingham :bawling:

[Jason.]

Reggie and Bollie sound like some CBBC duo act ngl

[Denver]

Where are Reggie n Bollie to liven this up

Closing the show :worship:

[Ross.]

I'm patiently waiting on Lucas doing a talk talk advert

[Black Dagger]

As if Max is going to stay again. The ****ing bland ****.

[Lostie!]

awaits for the coco cola advert

Is it even airing tonight? I expected next week.

[Ammi]

Apparently they are not coming to Birmingham :bawling:

...:sad:...have you seen it before, Luke..?..

[Jason.]

As if Max is going to stay again. The ****ing bland ****.

I've gone off him too. As has Ross.

[Kate!]

As if Max is going to stay again. The ****ing bland ****.

:joker: :joker:

[LukeB]

Is it even airing tonight? I expected next week.

With all the christmas adverts suddenly appearing I assume it' any time soon.

[Amy Jade]

Rita forgot her omg haha mess

[Ammi]

As if Max is going to stay again. The ****ing bland ****.

...evening gorgeous...:love:.../we missed you again...

[Ross.]

If only we could actually forget Monica

[Denver]

Messy Rita LovesOral

[Shaun]

Here's hoping she doesn't bother singing and just reads out a list of puppies she's killed.

[LukeB]

...:sad:...have you seen it before, Luke..?..

2 years ago i went :laugh:

[Jason.]

With all the christmas adverts suddenly appearing I assume it' any time soon.

The cola one is the best one.

[Drew.]

annoying song, annoying woman

[Ross.]

I've gone off him too. As has Ross.

No I haven't um

[Jordan.]

Hew is this gal telling vocal diva Monica she is wrong

[Kate!]

Pyjamas Monica

[King Gizzard]

"Stubbed my toe so vote for me"

[Black Dagger]

Oh not her doing this version.

[Samm]

Legend soul singer Monica will top beyonce

[LeatherTrumpet]

Rita

Wtaf

[Amy Jade]

She's going to look like Les from Eastenders in a dress

[Babayaro.]

As if Max is going to stay again. The ****ing bland ****.

Here he is

[Ross.]

She's going to look like Les from Eastenders in a dress

:joker:

[LukeB]

Yep. not her own

[Shaun]

So she's doing the Antony and the Johnsons version which is basically as famous as the regular bc of adverts then?

[Denver]

better then Beyonce but still ****e

[LukeB]

wth is she doing?

[Drew.]

Hagrid glammed up

[LukeB]

awful note there

[Lostie!]

Again, this is basically a cover of an already-reinvented version. But I don't know why I'm still expected this show to stick to themes. :laugh:

[Ammi]

2 years ago i went :laugh:

...ahhh, I bet it's an amazing thing when you see it in person...:flutter:../I think this is a first for us, big things don't often happen in little towns like us...

[Amy Jade]

Nadia Almada's return to prime time TV

[LeatherTrumpet]

Im still on mess monica and not on delay

:umm2:

[King Gizzard]

Awful. Isn't this exact version on the Shades of Grey soundtrack

[Ammi]

..I like this, she did a good job..:love:..

[LukeB]

that was absolutely awful

[Jordan.]

Better than Beyonce

[Samm]

The jealousy of Monica's lóok is seething

[Ross.]

Hagrid glammed up

:joker:

That was **** but I didn't expect anything else

[Kate!]

Legend soul singer Monica will top beyonce

Dear god no

She's going to look like Les from Eastenders in a dress

:laugh2:

That was dreadful Monica.

[Babayaro.]

Hagrid glammed up

:joker:

[Lostie!]

Annoyance with the disregarded theme aside, I really liked that. :clap1:

[Magicqueen]

I think Monica could have done better. I'm disappointed.

[LukeB]

Louisa - 10/10
Kiera - 8/10
4th Impact - 7.5/10
Mason - 7/10
Che - 7/10
Sean 6.5/10
Anton - 3/10
Monica - 1.5/10

[Natalie.]

Loved it and I think she looks great :laugh:

[Amy Jade]

Those gloves are hideous. I mean it's the least of her problems but still ew

[Babayaro.]

:joker: :joker: classic Simon

[Jordan.]

Yas Rita clocking

[LukeB]

"I didn't like it...i hated it" :clap1:

[Ross.]

Simon clocking that she's **** :clap1:

[Drew.]

The irony Si

[Jordan.]

Who is 'they' when it's his show :unsure:

[Lostie!]

Um Simon, David Walliams already did that.

[Ross.]

"You put more effort into the other girls"

oop

[LukeB]

:fc: Monica for bottom 2

[Kate!]

Grimmy up Simons ass