Do you agree that Andy has been a better all round HM than Jason?

[Beso]

I AINT SURE:shrug:

[joeysteele]

Yes, for me anyway.

[Jordan.]

In the same way drowning is probably better than burning to death

[Visage]

Yes definitely


I can't remember ever show, but someone correct me if I'm wrong, has he been given any warnings or has he done anything that warrants a punishment to the rest of the house?


That aside I've really enjoyed his views on the house and the people inside, I thought he's spoken a lot of sense and stayed pretty true to who he is

[Visage]

In the same way drowning is probably better than burning to death

I don't know if I fancy my insides bursting out under water.

[armand.kay]

In the same way drowning is probably better than burning to death

Basically this.

[sampvt]

andy is a traditional gamer but Jason is better and more likable

[Shaun]

Not even close.

[Withano]

Jasons had one great episodes and 30 where you barely knew he was there. Andys been consistantly a main character. So yeh. Andy is a better housemate and imo a more likable person.

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

Andy buy far he just seems genuinely more likeable, & I've liked how he's played the game.

[mysargasso]

He's way more consistent, that's for sure.

[_Tom_]

Overall, yeah

[hot2go]

Definitely....Andy has been consistent since day one...has stood against the status quo since day one and has been witty and funny since day one.....a great guy

[Braden]

idk Jason has had one or two amusing moments throughout the show. I feel as if Andy has just been a sanctimonious and unlikable negative energy for most of it.

Jason did bring on one of the most tense moments in C5 BB history too.

[Lostie!]

He's been a better housemate than most of them.

[jet]

Yes. Andy has been consistent from Day One and that shows he has been real, whether you like him or not. He's honest, he's loyal and he's straightforward and the best thing of all for me has been his dry sense of humour which I absolutely get and love....and he has something else that I put great stock in - DIGNITY.
He's had a rough ride in there yet he has taken it on the chin and not whinged or played the victim. And throughout all this he's managed to ruffle feathers, cause controversy and create that love/hate divide that means a HM has been a GREAT one. He's actually in my top 2 HM's of all time. He's been brilliant and has MADE the series for me.

Jason is my 2nd choice. A decent, open , good guy who has been woefully misunderstood.

[jet]

I AINT SURE:shrug:

Since your posts have shown you dislike both and most fans of Andy also like Jason and they are good friends I'm not sure of your motives here. Hoping to create some bad feeling maybe? Pit people against each other? haha
:think:

[camertone]

andy and jason are my top 2. i like evelyn too.

[Clootie Dumpling]

Undoubtedly, Andy has been a better HM than Jason.

He seemed a little cold and calculating at the start, but has shown that he has integrity, intelligence and, unlike so many of the other HMs, has been employed in a 'proper' job rather than being a wannabe Z List celebrity.

Compare his sanguine analysis of relationships and incidents in the House with Jason's clumsy attempts to talk strategy and it should be obvious that Andy is by far the superior HM.

[letmein]

That's like asking which is better: **** or vomit?

[johne]

Don't like Andy much as a person but his diary room speeches have been superb. The other HM's have just moaned/screamed in the diary room, it's only Andy who has used it properly to give us an insiders analysis as to what's really going on in the house. This for me gives him the edge over Jason.

[Cherie]

Don't like Andy much as a person but his diary room speeches have been superb. The other HM's have just moaned/screamed in the diary room, it's only Andy who has used it properly to give us an insiders analysis as to what's really going on in the house. This for me gives him the edge over Jason.

I'd agree with this, that said we haven't seen much of any of them in the DR apart from Andy, I can't recall seeing Jason in the DR at all apart from nominations and tasks :unsure:

[jennyjuniper]

Andy has put himself out in the firing line more so than Jason, but I still like them equally, for different reasons.

[kirklancaster]

That's like asking which is better: **** or vomit?

So sayeth the one whose avatar is the most repulsive, self-contradictory, two-faced, fake, game-playing, overacting, immature little RAT that the BB house has ever been infested by. LOL.

[Beso]

Since your posts have shown you dislike both and most fans of Andy also like Jason and they are good friends I'm not sure of your motives here. Hoping to create some bad feeling maybe? Pit people against each other? haha
:think:

stop being so judgemental and suspicious.



oh and btw i think they have both been great hms.

jason pipping andy for me, bb robbed us a bit with jason.

[Jamie89]

Jasons had one great episodes and 30 where you barely knew he was there. Andys been consistantly a main character. So yeh. Andy is a better housemate and imo a more likable person.

Kind of agree this. But even though Jason's only really had one iconic moment... it was huge! And it's things like that which make HM's more memorable, so it's possible he'll be remembered as a 'better' housemate because of it, in terms of his impact. Maybe. But right now, I think Andy's overall contribution has been better (although I think that post-show, he might be quite forgettable).

[JTM45]

I like Andy and he's contributed more than a lot of them in there to the series.

I think Jason probably just pips it though for the monumental excellence he displayed when he ousted that waste of space Lateysha! It'll be remembered as the defining and most entertaining moment of the series.
We'll also see more of Hughie, Sam, Ryan and Jane around the house now she's gone as well because they no longer have to congregate around her bed throwing digestive crumbs into her mouth and fanning her ego.

Didn't seem to effect them for too long either. They looked like they were well over it by tonight's episode.

Looks like it wasn't only us that Jason did a massive favour by sending her packing. I bet her kid will be grateful to Jason as well for sending its mother home before too much long-term damage is done!

What a fantastic bloke Jason is!!!:clap1:

[ebandit]

andy is a traditional gamer but Jason is better and more likable

how i dislike jason.........however andy is way smugger and far

more self righteous

Mark L

[Ellen]

I like them both, in their own ways they have both been great HM's.