BB17 v BB18

[Jodie.]

Say which series you feel done better in these areas :blush:

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB18
House Design: BB18
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB18
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB18

Eye:
Graphics:
House Design:
Emma’s excitement:
Arguments:
Fun:
Tasks:
Overall:

[Epic.]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB18
House Design: BB18
Emma's excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB18
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB18

so many options yet 'Cast' isn't one of them

[TomC]

I'm quite liking BB18 at the moment, but compared to the first two weeks of last year, BB18 isn't a patch on 17.

[Epic.]

BB17 is so overrated imo. The only time I really enjoyed it was the first two/three weeks

[Oaker]

BB17 is so overrated imo. The only time I really enjoyed it was the first two/three weeks

Week 3 and the last week sucked but the other ones were good

[Daniel-X]

I loved BB17, BB18 is okay at the moment but I doubt I'll look back on it like 'oh that was a really good series'

[Jodie.]

so many options yet 'Cast' isn't one of them

I thought that was abit too general, so I split it into arguments and fun x

[Jodie.]

If BB17 had Chanelle and Raph :flutter:

[supertv247]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB17
Twists: BB17
Cast: BB17
Overall: BB17

But... BB18 isn't that bad :laugh:

[*mazedsalv**]

Considering it's only been 2 weeks I can't comment on twists, tasks and "overall" as there haven't really been any twists really and only 1 shopping task.

But others...

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB17
Cast: BB17

First 2 weeks of BB17- 8.5/10
First 2 weeks of BB18- 3/10

[Time]

BB17 was pretty good so it'll take something to top it. BB18 was quite **** to start with, but I'm starting to get into it now.

[armand.kay]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB18
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

[Jason.]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17 (The graphics for that series were great)
House Design: BB18
Emma’s excitement: Hard to tell, she hasn't been excited since Secrets & Lies
Arguments: BB17 (bc Natalie and they weren't as draining as this year's)
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

[Jodie.]

Anyone changed opinions?

I’d probably rate BB18’s arguments better than BB17 now:dance:

[Nicky91]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB18
House Design: BB18
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB18
Tasks: BB17
Overall: BB17

[Cal.]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB18
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

[Cal.]

BB18's tasks have had effort put into them. Sukhvinder being the Mayor :love: BB17's was very much 'Who Said What?' and 'Eat something gross'.

Saying that most tasks have blended in together over the years .The last series that felt like there was a defined shopping task every week was BB15. I remember the farm one, the battery one, the murder mystery one, the Armageddon one etc.

[Jay28jay2]

Eye: 17
Graphics: 17
House Design: 18
Emma’s excitement: 17
Arguments: 18
Fun: 17
Tasks: None, they have all been awful in both seasons
Overall: Can't judge atm, wait till this season is over

[sungrass]

bb17 was great for me- great house mates and good ideas - sane people and nuts makes an interesting combination.

[sungrass]

Eye: 17
Graphics: 17
House Design: 18
Emma’s excitement: 17
Arguments: 18
Fun: 17
Tasks: None, they have all been awful in both seasons
Overall: Can't judge atm, wait till this season is over

you forget Andys newscaster task which was hilarious - and the time Jayne fake fainted because a foam brick got chucked at her head - and Hughies drunken dancing

[Lostie!]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: No idea
Arguments: BB18
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

Both have been returns to form after the terrible couple of years with BB15 and BB16 though.

[Jake.]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: BB18
Arguments: BB17/18 (would probably rate them the same)
Fun: BB18
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

[Jodie.]

Anyone changed opinions yet? I’m sticking with what I said in the OP

But the gap is closing between what I prefer: BB17 or BB18. This last week has let it down a bit :(

[Oaker]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

.

[Macie Lightfoot]

k so I only Wiki watched BB17 but I've found this year's tasks to be pretty ****ty. The ~Den of Dilemma~ hardly felt like a shopping task and it was just cobbled together to be done in a day and a half, and then the ~Survival Room~ was hilariously unimaginative as it was just a checklist of things for them to do to pass.

[reece(:]

Natalie vs Sukhvinder basically :think:

BB18!

[Oaker]

k so I only Wiki watched BB17 but I've found this year's tasks to be pretty ****ty. The ~Den of Dilemma~ hardly felt like a shopping task and it was just cobbled together to be done in a day and a half, and then the ~Survival Room~ was hilariously unimaginative as it was just a checklist of things for them to do to pass.

Oh yeah the tasks this year are crap but BB17's were even worse.

The amount of nomination reveals, outside contact and ~exposing secret conversations~ was ridiculous. Like 90% of the tasks had at least 1 of those 3 things :bored:.

[TomC]

BB17, no question.

[LukeB]

I'm not sure. I found BB17 to be quite boring after Georgina got evicted (Not saying she was the reason)

[Greg!]

Both are good but BB17 just edges it. I agree with the comments about tasks, BB18's aren't that great but BB17's ones were awful.