Rank the winners

[Daniel.]

1. Nadia
2. Isabelle
3. Sophie
4. Chloe
5. Kate
6. Rachel
7. Luke A
8. Pete
9. Brian
10. Josie
11. Anthony
12. Sam
13. Helen
14. Aaron
15. Jason

Haven't seen 1, 2, 4

[Novo]

1) Aaron
2) Kate

^ the only two I have ever liked

[Wizard.]

1. Isabelle
2. Sophie
3. Helen
4. Nadia
5. Pete
6. Josy
7. Brian Belo
8. Brian Dowling
9. Luke A
10. Chloe
11. Rachel
12. Jason
13. Anthony
14. Aaron
15. Sam

[reece(:]

1. Nadia
2. Isabelle
3. Sophie
4. Kate
5. Chloe
6. Brian Belo
7. Luke
8. Josie
9. Rachel
10. Brian Dowling
11. Pete
12. Anthony
13. Craig
14. Sam
15. Helen
16. Jason
17. Aaron
18. Cameron

[Jordan.]

1. Nadia
2. Isabelle
3. Sophie
4. Chloe
5. Pete
6. Brian B
7. Rachel
8. Luke A
9. Anthony
10. Josie
11. Sam
12. Helen
13. Jason
14. Aaron

[Merry Mockmas]

I've not seen some of them so here it goes.

1. Nadia (BB5)
2. Aaron (BB12)
3. Josie (BB11)
4. LukeA (BB13)
5. Helen (BB15)
6. Isabelle (BB18)
7. Brian (BB2) tbf I only watched 2 weeks of his series and he was amusing
8. Sophie (BB10)
9. Sam (BB14)
10. Kate (BB3)
11. Brian (BB8)
12. Rachel (BB9)
13. Chloe (BB16)
14. Jason (BB17)
15. Anthony (BB6)
16. Pete (BB7)

I'm not normally very keen on BB winners too much or Reality Show winners fullstop (probably because I'm not any of the show's target demographic) but there is the odd gem amongst them I think. Especially on BB.

[jet]

Just Brian Dowling and Isabelle for me really.

[Jack_]

1) Helen
2) Aaron

3) Jason
4) Josie
5) Anthony
6) Brian B

7) Isabelle
8) Pete

9) Luke A

10) Chloe
11) Sophie
12) Rachel

13) Sam

It's actually quite disgusting I have to put Jason and Josie 3rd/4th respectively, thats how bad the winners of BBUK are for me

[Rob!]

1) Helen
2) Aaron

3) Jason
4) Josie
5) Anthony
6) Brian B

7) Isabelle
8) Pete

9) Luke A

10) Chloe
11) Sophie
12) Rachel

13) Sam

It's actually quite disgusting I have to put Jason and Josie 3rd/4th respectively, thats how bad the winners of BBUK are for me

HELEN is your number one? You need Jesus

[Epic.]

1) Helen
2) Aaron

3) Jason
4) Josie
5) Anthony
6) Brian B

7) Isabelle
8) Pete

9) Luke A

10) Chloe
11) Sophie
12) Rachel

13) Sam

wtf

[Jack_]

It's pretty close between her and Aaron, ask me on a different day and they'd be switched

Not that that'll make any difference for most people on here :joker:

[Jordan.]

Jason 3rd when he grunted and frowned his way to victory?

[Rob!]

It's pretty close between her and Aaron, ask me on a different day and they'd be switched

Not that that'll make any difference for most people on here :joker:

Her being anywhere near the top is awful :joker:

I know you prefer housemates who make good television and keep the show dramatic and interesting so I kind of get it if it's purely based on that but honestly, she is the biggest **** to walk through those doors and she should in no way have been rewarded for her behaviour.

[Gstar]

1) Helen
2) Aaron

3) Jason
4) Josie
5) Anthony
6) Brian B

7) Isabelle
8) Pete

9) Luke A

10) Chloe
11) Sophie
12) Rachel

13) Sam

It's actually quite disgusting I have to put Jason and Josie 3rd/4th respectively, thats how bad the winners of BBUK are for me

https://68.media.tumblr.com/020d993f19d745127f72b798dda28ad5/tumblr_inline_n9nlvjXQyY1scovuq.gif

[James]

1. Aaron
2. Brian Dowling
3. Kate

Honestly all the others are at the same level. Most of the winners aren't the most memorable HMs to me. Though to be fair I did quite like Josie at the time, having only watched the last few weeks of the series, but didn't like the publicity she did afterwards. I quite like Craig also out of nostalgia for BB1.

I kind of lost a lot of interest in series 13-17. Got more into it this year with a forum member being in the house.

[Epic.]

1) Brian D
2) Isabelle
3) Nadia
4) Pete
5) Rachel
6) Sophie
7) Josie
8) Luke A
9) Jason
10) Chloe
11) Anthony
12) Kate
13) Brian B
14) Craig
15) Helen
16) Aaron
17) Sam
18) Cameron

If I remember correctly, although it could always change

[Gstar]

1. Aaron
2. Brian Dowling
3. Kate

Honestly all the others are at the same level. Most of the winners aren't the most memorable HMs to me. Though to be fair I did quite like Josie at the time, having only watched the last few weeks of the series, but didn't like the publicity she did afterwards. I quite like Craig also out of nostalgia for BB1.

I kind of lost a lot of interest in series 13-17. Got more into it this year with a forum member being in the house.

https://68.media.tumblr.com/020d993f19d745127f72b798dda28ad5/tumblr_inline_n9nlvjXQyY1scovuq.gif

[Jack_]

okay I'll have some fun with you guys and reorder the list if I were judging them in terms of who I like as ~people~, this will probably be pretty different :laugh:

1) Isabelle

2) Brian B
3) Pete

4) Sophie
5) Rachel
6) Luke

7) Aaron
8) Anthony
9) Josie

10) Sam
11) Chloe
12) Jason

13) Helen

Enjoy cause that's the first and last time you'll see me rank Rachel above Aaron!

[Mullens123]

1. Brian D
2. Jason
3. Isabelle
4. Kate
5. Aaron
6. Luke A
7. Rachel
8. Sophie
9. Nadia
10. Chloe
11. Anthony
12. Helen
13. Cameron
14. Sam

Can't rank Craig, Josie, Brian B or Pete until rewatch

[Epic.]

okay I'll have some fun with you guys and reorder the list if I were judging them in terms of who I like as ~people~, this will probably be pretty different :laugh:

1) Isabelle

2) Brian B
3) Pete

4) Sophie
5) Rachel
6) Luke

7) Aaron
8) Anthony
9) Josie

10) Sam
11) Chloe
12) Jason

13) Helen

Enjoy cause that's the first and last time you'll see me rank Rachel above Aaron!

Wouldn't liking someone as a person factor into a rank like this overall though?

[Shaun]

1) Nadia
2) Kate
3) Brian D
4) Isabelle
5) Rachel
6) Jason
7) Sam
8) Brian B
9) Chloe
10) Luke A
11) Josie
12) Anthony
13) Pete
14) Aaron
15) Sophie
16) Craig
17) Cameron
18) Helen

[Jack_]

Jason 3rd when he grunted and frowned his way to victory?

That's why I find it disgusting, the thing with Jason is he was the second-worst finalist and a disappointing winner given the series but he really wasn't that bad a housemate and much like Josie (in fact their stories are pretty much the same) played a part in their series but weren't anywhere near the best

They're just at the top cause the rest start to become more and more MOTR to irrelevant

I always do badly on BBUK, why do y'all think I complain about the eviction orders so much? :joker:

Her being anywhere near the top is awful :joker:

I know you prefer housemates who make good television and keep the show dramatic and interesting so I kind of get it if it's purely based on that but honestly, she is the biggest **** to walk through those doors and she should in no way have been rewarded for her behaviour.

I do understand why people think that and completely respect it, but I just don't personally see Big Brother as a charity or a morality competition so it's never really about 'rewarding' anyone for me, just merely who I believe has brought the most to an entertainment programme, the cash prize or title is secondary. She is atrocious don't get me wrong and her BB16 appearance really soured any appreciation I still had for her but if we're judging winners we're doing it by their own series and without wanting to get into this debate again, I never really felt like she did anything that bad? Certainly not compared to the Brian stuff anyway

[Mitchell]

1) Josie
2) Isabelle
3) Brian Dowling
4) Nadia
5) Brian Belo

6) Pete
7) Chloe
8) Kate
9) Craig
10) Sam
11) Luke A
12) Jason
13 ) Rachel
14) Sophie (from the little I saw of BB10)
15) Cameron

16) Aaron
17) Anthony (forgot he existed tbh)
18) Helen

[Jack_]

Wouldn't liking someone as a person factor into a rank like this overall though?

Not at all! I don't have to like a housemate as a person to support them cause I've always thought that like I don't watch this show looking for a friend or someone to relate to, merely for escapism so in actuality many of the housemates I support I wouldn't want anything to do with in the real world :laugh: I support people solely on their contribution to a particular series

Obviously if I actually love someone as a person too (say Ashleigh for example) it's great but it's never a necessity for me

[Epic.]

Not at all! I don't have to like a housemate as a person to support them cause I've always thought that like I don't watch this show looking for a friend or someone to relate to, merely for escapism so in actuality many of the housemates I support I wouldn't want anything to do with in the real world :laugh: I support people solely on their contribution to a particular series

Obviously if I actually love someone as a person too (say Ashleigh for example) it's great but it's never a necessity for me

Why weren't you entertained by Isabelle again?

[Jack_]

Why weren't you entertained by Isabelle again?

It's not that I wasn't, when Issy was on form she was amazing but my problem with her was she was so inconsistent, she had the Lotan thing and then disappeared for two weeks, had a reasonably good final fortnight (which is why she won) but overall wasn't as good as the likes of Chanelle

My thoughts on all of the finalists could be summed up in one emoticon: :shrug:

[Lostie!]

1. Nadia
2. Rachel
3. Isabelle
4. Jason
5. Aaron
6. Pete
7. Luke A
8. Chloe
9. Sophie
10. Josie
11. Sam
12. Anthony
13. Brian B
14. Helen

[CherryTango]

Best
Nadia (still vividly remember that winning moment :hee:)

Worst
Helen (by a mile)

The others are lost in the chasm between Nadia and Helen.

[Merry Mockmas]

okay I'll have some fun with you guys and reorder the list if I were judging them in terms of who I like as ~people~, this will probably be pretty different :laugh:

1) Isabelle

2) Brian B
3) Pete

4) Sophie
5) Rachel
6) Luke

7) Aaron
8) Anthony
9) Josie

10) Sam
11) Chloe
12) Jason

13) Helen

Enjoy cause that's the first and last time you'll see me rank Rachel above Aaron!

As people this is an interesting one for me.

1. Isabelle
2. LukeA
3. Brian Dowling
4. Nadia
5. Sam
6. Rachel
7. Kate
8. Jason
9. Aaron
10. Brian Belo
11. Sophie
12. Josie (I've really gone off her as a person after the show) I even pity John James
13. Chloe
14. Anthony
15. Helen
16. Pete

I know that people will disagree with me on the likability front with Helen and Pete, but I felt like she at least genuinely liked Ash. I honestly don't think that Pete genuinely liked anybody in his series, including Nikki, Richard, Aisleyne, and Lea.

[Epic.]

It's not that I wasn't, when Issy was on form she was amazing but my problem with her was she was so inconsistent, she had the Lotan thing and then disappeared for two weeks, had a reasonably good final fortnight (which is why she won) but overall wasn't as good as the likes of Chanelle

My thoughts on all of the finalists could be summed up in one emoticon: :shrug:

I wouldn't say she dissapeared. Maybe for one week but she still had that whole week where she kept sacrificing herself for people for the entire week, which was Week 6 even though she "dissapeared"

Also:

1) Helen
2) Aaron

3) Jason
4) Josie
5) Anthony
6) Brian B

7) Isabelle
8) Pete

9) Luke A

10) Chloe
11) Sophie
12) Rachel

13) Sam

Helen and Aaron i can kind of get with how you view the show, but I'm confused on how Jason, Josie, Anthony, or Belo are above her. Jason & Anthony both had interesting storylines but they themselves weren't interesting at all? Same goes for Josie to an extent. Brian B was just MOTR too tbh, much more than the likes of Isabelle

[_Tom_]

1. Nadia
2. Isabelle
3. Rachel
4. Pete
5. Brian B
6. Luke A
7. Josie
8. Jason
9. Sophie
10. Chloe
11. Anthony
12. Sam
13. Helen

Haven't seen 1-4 or 12.

[Jack_]

I wouldn't say she dissapeared. Maybe for one week but she still had that whole week where she kept sacrificing herself for people for the entire week, which was Week 6 even though she "dissapeared"

Also:



Helen and Aaron i can kind of get with how you view the show, but I'm confused on how Jason, Josie, Anthony, or Belo are above her. Jason & Anthony both had interesting storylines but they themselves weren't interesting at all? Same goes for Josie to an extent. Brian B was just MOTR too tbh, much more than the likes of Isabelle

Jason had a series-long storyline and although he was the worse half of the pair and the second-least deserving finalist, he still played his part in the series (like 99% of the cast did in BB17 tbf) and became the subject of a lot of discussion. Anthony's only (rightly) slated because he was one of the more feeble characters in a house full of gigantic ones, he still had storylines (and the Craig one remains one of my favourite ever) and again brought more to his series than Isabelle did to this. The same reasons I've given for these two apply to Josie as well, and as for Belo, he's actually an example of a housemate I enjoy without him being loud or shouting a lot (which I've been criticised for in the past) but just for being amusing and still being a huge part of the series. The list would be broken down like this

Deserving Winners (best housemate of their series):

1) Helen
2) Aaron

Acceptable Winners (but not the best possible option):

3) Jason
4) Josie
5) Anthony
6) Brian B

MOTR/Mediocre Winners:

7) Isabelle
8) Pete

Disappointing Winner:

9) Luke A

Appalling Winners:

10) Chloe
11) Sophie
12) Rachel

The Worst Winner of Any Reality Television Show Ever Broadcast:

13) Sam

[Daniel.]

Jack you will think Nadia a good winner so WATCH BB5

[Jack_]

Someone told me I'd stan Victor once :worry:

One day hun!

[Merry Mockmas]

Jack you will think Nadia a good winner so WATCH BB5

She wanted to kill a bug, and punched Jason (although that part doesn't make the highlights but have heard about)

[Merry Mockmas]

Someone told me I'd stan Victor once :worry:

One day hun!

His a legend.

[Daniel.]

Someone told me I'd stan Victor once :worry:

One day hun!

You will stan Nadia, Michelle, Victor, Ahmed, Jason, Marco, Emma and Kitten

You will dislike Shell and Stuart (though imo Shell isn't boring)

Bookmark

[Daniel.]

She wanted to kill a bug, and punched Jason (although that part doesn't make the highlights but have heard about)

Not wanting to kill a bug making her a winner

For me she was the most entertaining in a house of great characters

[Jack_]

That's a lot of faves :cheer2:

Perched!

[Daniel.]

That's a lot of faves :cheer2:

Perched!

I'm just thinking of what you consider entertainment

[Epic.]

The Worst Winner of Any Reality Television Show Ever Broadcast:

13) Sam

:joker:

[Daniel.]

Wait did you like Nadia, Michelle and Victor on UBB?.

[Jack_]

Wait did you like Nadia, Michelle and Victor on UBB?.

Nadia and Victor yes, Michelle no

[Daniel.]

Erm well Nadia is pretty much the same, as is Victor, Michelle is different

[Jack_]

Yeah I did think that Michelle was a lot quieter than I expected her to be given what I'd seen/heard :laugh:

[Jason.]

Yeah I can see Jack rooting so hard for Victor and Ahmed, but you'll love Nadia and Michelle too.

[Merry Mockmas]

Nadia and Victor yes, Michelle no

You'll love Michelle in particular once the Army task starts up and you will just not stop loving her afterwards I'm willing to make a bet on it knowing your taste.:joker:

[Cal.]

1. Helen
2. Nadia
3. Isabelle
4. Brian D
5. Chloe
6. Pete
7. Brian B
8. Josie
9. Luke A
10. Anthony
11. Sam
12. Jason

Haven't seen enough of 3, 9 or 10 to comment and haven't seen any of 1, 4 or 12.

[millyrose]

1. Nadia
2. Pete
3. Aaron
4. Jason
5. Brian D
6. Luke A
7. Isabelle

[Nicky91]

1. Isabelle

2. Jason

3. Brian D

4. Helen

only series i did really watch so, i can't make a full ranking

[supertv247]

1. Isabelle
2. Chloe
3. Josie
4. Brian D
5. Nadia
6. Sophie
7. Brian B
8. Rachel
9. Pete
10. Anthony
11. Sam
12. Luke
13. Aaron
14. Jason
15. Helen

[Alf]

1 Brian Dowling
2 Josie
3 Aaron
4 Sophie
5 Helen


Worst: Nadia

[Scotty07]

1) Aaron Allard-Morgan (BB12)
2) Isabelle Warburton (BB18)
3) Luke Anderson (BB13)
4) Rachel Rice (BB9)
5) Jason Burrill (BB17)
6) Craig Phillips (BB1)
7) Brian Dowling (BB2)
8) Nadia Almada (BB5)
9) Anthony Hutton (BB6)
10) Helen Wood (BB15)
11) Josie Gibson (BB11)
12) Kate Lawler (BB3)
13) Pete Bennett (BB7)
14) Brian Belo (BB8)
15) Sophie Reade (BB10)
16) Chloe Wilburn (BB16)
17) Sam Evans (BB14)
18) Cameron Stout (BB4)

[CaPPa]

1. Pete
2. Isabelle
3. Craig
4. Kate
5. Aaron
6. Brian D
7. Brian B
8. Luke
9. Sophie
10. Josie
11. Helen
12. Nadia
13. Rachel
14. Sam
16. Cameron
17. Chloe
18. Anthony

I liked the top 8, indifferent to 9 and 10, didn't like 11 or 12 (but accept they were big characters) and 13 to 18 were awful.