Replace judges?

[BBUK-Fan]

I find the judges really biased now and don't like any of them. I think they should scrap all four of them and replace them. Agree?

[smudgie]

Nah, it's all a pantomime, family entertainment for a Saturday night.
They normally end up with the true best three come the final.

[RileyH]

scrap Darcey and Bruno

[Nicky91]

NO

[stewartf]

Scoring a bit high for me...10s given on errors. Shirley is influenced by who she likes. But hey keep them all, it's controversy and panto.

[lewis111]

They hardly ever over or under make someone ALL series
Like people saying Aston was undermarked yet he had revived 10s in past week?
And Debbie has been middle of the leaderboard before so she can't always be over marked

[GoldHeart]

no judges did one good thing this week getting Mollie OUT :D

You don't like Mollie anymore?? :conf:, you sound confused :rolleyes: .

[joeysteele]

Craig's always been volatile so I'd keep him.
However yes,clear out the other 3.
Shirley is awfully biased and even unfair.
Bruno has outlived his time as a judge.
Darcey(your top line) Bussel,is now really irritating.

Bring in 3 new ones for me and rotate weekly which one is top judge that week too.

[GoldHeart]

I find the judges really biased now and don't like any of them. I think they should scrap all four of them and replace them. Agree?

Aren't things going your way ?? Awwww :whistle: LOL . Everyone already knows the judges are biased so no point stating the obvious when it's been happening for a few years now :laugh3:

[Amy Jade]

I would be happy to see Bruno fired. I find him highly irritating. The rest are good.

[GoldHeart]

I would be happy to see Bruno fired. I find him highly irritating. The rest are good.

All of the judges are useless and biased ! and need to be fired ! :bored: . The best line up for a judging panel would be previous professional dancers as they know exactly what the whole experience is like and they've been there and got the tshirt etc . It will never happen though as the producers clearly prefer old rum soaked has been farts :notimpressed: :hehe:

[Marsh.]

The judges ARE all former professional dancers.

[GoldHeart]

The judges ARE all former professional dancers.

:facepalm: I mean previous professionals who have competed in Strictly and since left , for e.g Karen Hardy who won with Mark Rampakesh ( it's ashame she left the show). Flavia was another good dancer , even Brendan could be a judge lol .

I know it would never happen as the current rum soaked old fart judges are here to stay forever, they're part of the furniture like dusty cobwebs you can't get rid of :bored: .

I know previous SCD pro's have gone across the pond to take part in DWTS , and other pro's are probably busy with other projects . But I just think previous dancers would do a better job on the judging panel .

[Nicky91]

You don't like Mollie anymore?? :conf:, you sound confused :rolleyes: .

Mess, me appearing drunk while i haven't drunk any alcohol last night :laugh2:


and i made up my mind LOL, i want producers to have a few words with the judges, cause i am so not liking how they target the ones they don't like first aston, now mollie :suspect: :(

[Marsh.]

:facepalm: I mean previous professionals who have competed in Strictly and since left , for e.g Karen Hardy who won with Mark Rampakesh ( it's ashame she left the show). Flavia was another good dancer , even Brendan could be a judge lol .

I know it would never happen as the current rum soaked old fart judges are here to stay forever, they're part of the furniture like dusty cobwebs you can't get rid of :bored: .

I know previous SCD pro's have gone across the pond to take part in DWTS , and other pro's are probably busy with other projects . But I just think previous dancers would do a better job on the judging panel .
What difference would it make?

It doesn't make them any more or any less qualified. Craig and Bruno have been there from the start, they know the show inside and out. Any former professionals from the show would only have the same accusations levelled at them.

But, no, the viewers who know bugger all about the art of dance must know better.

It's a Saturday night light entertainment popularity contest and nothing more.

[Crimson Dynamo]

Get rid of Bruno and replace him with Lotan

[GoldHeart]

What difference would it make?

It doesn't make them any more or any less qualified. Craig and Bruno have been there from the start, they know the show inside and out. Any former professionals from the show would only have the same accusations levelled at them.

But, no, the viewers who know bugger all about the art of dance must know better.

It's a Saturday night light entertainment popularity contest and nothing more.

It makes a huge difference :nono:, and I bet they'd be a lot more fair ! .
I don't care , Len quit and he'd been there from beginning, Arlene got sacked , so why must we put up with Bruno the hyperactive stupid nutter , Craig the plastic constipated tool , Shirley the ignorant stuck up old hag and Darcy the boring snobby idiot . :bored:

[Nicky91]

It makes a huge difference :nono:, and I bet they'd be a lot more fair ! .
I don't care , Len quit and he'd been there from beginning, Arlene got sacked , so why must we put up with Bruno the hyperactive nutter Bruno, Craig the plastic constipated tool , Shirley the ignorant stuck up old hag and Darcy the boring snobby idiot . :bored:

why against Darcey and Bruno, they voted for Aston to stay ;)


or have you forgot :fan:

[GoldHeart]

why against Darcey and Bruno, they voted for Aston to stay ;)


or have you forgot :fan:

:laugh2: I don't care I still don't like any of the judges.

[Withano]

I voted change the scoring system, as in - as if judges get 50% of the leaderboard and choose from the bottom 2. Rip off.

[Marsh.]

It makes a huge difference :nono:, and I bet they'd be a lot more fair ! .
I don't care , Len quit and he'd been there from beginning, Arlene got sacked , so why must we put up with Bruno the hyperactive stupid nutter , Craig the plastic constipated tool , Shirley the ignorant stuck up old hag and Darcy the boring snobby idiot . :bored:
I never said that. I said judges who danced on the actual show would be no more qualified and nothing would change.

It would still result in viewers such as yourself having a wildly different opinion if they dare to mark people differently than you believe they should be.

[Marsh.]

I voted change the scoring system, as in - as if judges get 50% of the leaderboard and choose from the bottom 2. Rip off.
Well if it wants to pretend to be at all a dancing competition it needs to keep that, otherwise it really is purely public popularity competition.

[Withano]

Well if it wants to pretend to be at all a dancing competition it needs to keep that, otherwise it really is purely public popularity competition.

:cloud:

[Marsh.]

:cloud:
:rain:

[Nicky91]

Withano, i understand your worries i really do, and my mollie is so being a victim of their schemes, same goes for aston, judges only care about saving their faves, the rest is expendable in their eyes :mad:

[Livia]

As it's once of the most watched shows on telly I'm almost sure they're not going to change the judges because a handful of fans have taken against them. Each one of the judges is looking for different things. And to watch people say the judges are biased when they themselves are supporting an ex-stage school pupil, or an ex-ballerina, or someone who's danced in the West End, is hilarious!

[Livia]

:facepalm: I mean previous professionals who have competed in Strictly and since left , for e.g Karen Hardy who won with Mark Rampakesh ( it's ashame she left the show). Flavia was another good dancer , even Brendan could be a judge lol .

I know it would never happen as the current rum soaked old fart judges are here to stay forever, they're part of the furniture like dusty cobwebs you can't get rid of :bored: .

I know previous SCD pro's have gone across the pond to take part in DWTS , and other pro's are probably busy with other projects . But I just think previous dancers would do a better job on the judging panel .

Are you watching the same show as everyone else?

[GoldHeart]

Are you watching the same show as everyone else?

:idc: I'm not the only one who dislikes the judges, and alot of people dislike the new judge Shirley as well :hee: .

[Marsh.]

:idc: I'm not the only one who dislikes the judges, and alot of people dislike the new judge Shirley as well :hee: .

Because she's not got her face wedged in the backside of their favourite?

[GoldHeart]

Because she's not got her face wedged in the backside of their favourite?

Shirley clearly has her favourites so wake up , she has the hots for Joe ! :sleep:

[Marsh.]

Shirley clearly has her favourites so wake up , she has the hots for Joe ! :sleep:

Yes, and you only have a problem with it because her favourites or the subjects of her praise are not your favourites.

Wake up, if she shared your favourites you wouldn't have a problem! :pat:

[Nicky91]

i'm sorry but judges aren't popular so let them keep on hating Mollie, can only work in her favour :flutter:

[GoldHeart]

Yes, and you only have a problem with it because her favourites or the subjects of her praise are not your favourites.

Wake up, if she shared your favourites you wouldn't have a problem! :pat:

Poor you totally confused aren't you :facepalm: actually I would still have a problem, I like Debbie but I can see how favoured she is duuuuhhhh !! :crazy: which isn't fair .

[Marsh.]

Poor you totally confused aren't you :facepalm: actually I would still have a problem, I like Debbie but I can see how favoured she is duuuuhhhh !! :crazy: which isn't fair .

Of course you do.

[GoldHeart]

Of course you do.

What you talking about !?? , I've already said in posts that I like Debbie but I can see the over praise she gets more so than Alexandra :idc: . And Craig kneeing in front of her is pathetic and embarrassing :bored: .

Why you acting like it's only me who sees the biased unfair behaviour from the judges omg :facepalm:, other people on this forum have stated they dislike the judges as well .