PDA

View Full Version : BB19 Edgic Thread


reece(:
16-09-2018, 10:33 PM
For last years: http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/showthread.php?p=9424840#post9424840


History of Edgic: Edgic, a portmanteau of editing and logic, was a tool devised in the early-mid 2000s used to help predict winners of the US reality TV show Survivor. Each contestant was assigned a rating for each episode they appeared in, and their ratings and edits were analyzed in an effort to predict who the winner would be. If you've recently entered the Survivor subforum, you've probably encountered people arguing about whether or not edgic discussions constitutes spoiler tags, mainly stemming from the fact that Michele, the winner of the spring 2016 season of Survivor, was one of the more obvious winners by edgicians and one of the more surprising winners to non-edgicians.

In terms of edgicing BBUK..... it's pretty pointless alol. Maybe someone else has a different perspective but to me, there's something therapeutic about assigning colored cells to reality TV contestants and using the composite rating to organize my thoughts and feelings and visually represent the series.

How Edgic Works: Each cell has two components - rating and tone. Rating is breaking down what type of content you had in an episode, while tone is breaking down how the viewers are supposed to perceive the content. There are mainly four different ratings and four different tones, and they can be mixed and matched.

Edgic Ratings: UTR ~ you more or less weren't in the episode, and if you were your content was either unmemorable or you were deliberately edited to be under the radar. Think of Sam Evans, Hira, most recently Charlotte, etc.
MOR ~ you're present, but not particularly dynamic. The content and airtime is there, but there is a lacking of personal insight or character development. You're middle of the road. Think of someone like Kieran.
CP ~ you are a complex personality. You're one of the main forces driving the narrative and we are learning and who you are as a person as you are providing your personal insight. Deana Uppal, Aisleyne, Aaron, etc. You can also throw in your obnoxious GAMEPLAYERS in here like Victor and nasty Nick.
OTT ~ over the top. I don't think this needs much explaining, BBUK pretty much rewrote the definition for over the top when it introduced people like Nikki and Charley and Kinga.

Edgic Tone: Neutral ~ we're not supposed to feel a particular way about you. Think like.... Liam or Karly or Laura McAdam.
Positive (P) ~ you're a protagonist and someone who the editors are explicitly telling us to root for. This is actually surprisingly rare due to the format of BBUK. Think of people like Brian Belo, Nadia, Luke A, Brian Dowling (hey they all won). If you're looking for someone who didn't win..... Samanda also work.
Negative (N) ~ we're either supposed to dislike you or love to hate you. Charley, Victor, Bea, Helen ****ing Wood, etc.
Mixed (M) ~ there are both positives and negatives to how you're presented. Due to the nature of BBUK, like 80% of the people end up with mixed tone. Nikki, Aaron, Aisleyne, Freddie, etc.



Episode 1:

Akeem - UTR2
Anamélia - OTTN5
Brooke - MOR2
Cameron - CP3
Cian - MORM3
Isaac - MORN4
Kay - MORP3
Kenaley - UTR2
Lewis F - CPM5
Lewis G - OTTN4
Sian - MOR2
Tomasz - OTT4
Zoe - CPP3
-
Ellis - OTTN4 (OTTN2 overall)

JoshBB
16-09-2018, 10:36 PM
What do the numbers mean? I kinda understand the concept but also find it hard to imagine "on a scale" if that makes sense.

interesting idea tho

reece(:
16-09-2018, 10:38 PM
What do the numbers mean? I kinda understand the concept but also find it hard to imagine "on a scale" if that makes sense.

interesting idea tho

Numbers are visibility rating how visible they are on the episode from 1-5

Epic.
16-09-2018, 10:41 PM
If anyone wants more insight to the colors, check out my CBB22 one :love:
https://i.imgur.com/EFgrsbe.jpg

JoshBB
16-09-2018, 10:53 PM
Okay, ty! I think I understand, and here are mine;

Akeem - MOR2
Anamelia - OTTN5
Brooke - UTR1
Cameron CPP3
Cian - MORP4
Ellis - OTTN4
Isaac - OTTN4
Kay - MORP3
Kenaley - UTRM2
Lewis F - CPM5
Lewis G - OTT-CP4
Sian - UTRP2
Tomasz - CPP3
Zoe - CPP3

(i thought Lewis G was kinda a hybrid, so I picked two. sorry if thats some kind of edgic sin lmao)

Macie Lightfoot
16-09-2018, 11:11 PM
(i thought Lewis G was kinda a hybrid, so I picked two. sorry if thats some kind of edgic sin lmao)

YOU MUST PICK ONE :devil:

lol you all know I love my edgic but I'll only be posting my chart weekly. I actually *do* keep a record of daily edgic ratings bc my memory is so ****e that I need accurate notes in order to get my weekly ratings, but the charts are sooooo huge that I would need to like past two or three screen grabs in Photoshop and it's not worth it lmao

But yes, I am slowly working towards my goal of having a full set of BBUK edgic charts, which is one of the reasons I'm kinda fine with the show being cancelled? If they keep churning this show out then it truly is a Sisyphean task.

reece(:
17-09-2018, 10:03 PM
Episode 2

Akeem - UTR2/MOR2 :think:
Anamélia - OTTN5
Brooke - CPP3
Cameron - CPP4
Cian - MORP2
Isaac - UTR2
Kay - MORM4
Kenaley - MOR2
Lewis F - CPM4
Lewis G - OTTN4
Sian - UTR2
Tomasz - OTTP4
Zoe - MORM3

iRyan
17-09-2018, 10:09 PM
Dead @ Anamelia’s consistent OTTN5

reece(:
17-09-2018, 10:11 PM
Dead @ Anamelia’s consistent OTTN5
Sis is giving Charley a run for her money with all these arguments

Macie Lightfoot
18-09-2018, 04:06 AM
Not to be That Guy and criticize other people's ratings but Lewis G has been like textbook OTTM so far. Like for all the annoying antics that all of y'all hate him for he's probably gotten more positive SPV than negative lol.

reece(:
19-09-2018, 02:37 PM
Day 3

Akeem - MOR3
Anamélia - OTTM5
Brooke - MORM3
Cameron - MORM4
Cian - MOR2
Isaac - MORM3
Kay - MORM3
Kenaley - UTR2
Lewis F - OTTM4
Lewis G - OTTM3
Sian - UTR2
Tomasz - OTTM4
Zoe - CPM3

Daniel.
23-09-2018, 09:09 AM
I havent done this before properly so the people who do this all the time tell me where im going wrong

Akeem - MORP
Anameia - OTTN
Brooke - MORM
Cameron - MORM
Cian - MORP
Isaac - MORN
Kay - MOR
Kenaley - MORM
Lewis F - CPM
Lewis G - OTTM
Sian - MORP
Tomasz - OTTP
Zoe - MOR

Epic.
23-09-2018, 09:27 AM
I havent done this before properly so the people who do this all the time tell me where im going wrong

Akeem - MORP
Anameia - OTTN
Brooke - MORM
Cameron - MORM
Cian - MORP
Isaac - MORN
Kay - MOR
Kenaley - MORM
Lewis F - CPM
Lewis G - OTTM
Sian - MORP
Tomasz - OTTP
Zoe - MOR

If you're basing this on the whole week, I disagree with the people who put Anamélia as OTTN since Friday's show she was randomly OTTP in the midst of her beginning of OTTNs as well as a few M ratings here and there.

Kenaley also was only visible in the episode she clashed with Anamélia so unless the first half of tonight's show changes anything, she's definitely UTR/UTRM imo.

Macie Lightfoot
23-09-2018, 11:03 PM
Will have my chart posted soonish ugh I'm so slow especially while I'm trying to edgic BBUS as well as trying to be a working girl! But post ur charts ladies so I can steal and criticize ratings......x

Epic.
23-09-2018, 11:16 PM
Finished my one

https://i.imgur.com/ibAjWN8.jpg

Nearly put Lewis G as OTTM but trying to poison the house changed that and I can't see why any of you would put him as anything other than OTTN because of it

reece(:
25-09-2018, 04:58 PM
https://i.imgur.com/u7bnqSa.png

RileyH
25-09-2018, 05:23 PM
Why is Brooke MOR sis has had like 5 minutes of airtime and that's being generous

Macie Lightfoot
01-10-2018, 02:49 AM
https://i.imgur.com/5dlr3hH.png

Lewis G was definitely OTTM because as annoying as he was he *did* receive a significant amount of positive SPV about how he's actually funny and fun and likable and whatever else. Like 10 minutes of #CrossContaminationGate doesn't negate a week how The Real Lewis G isn't actually that bad.

I'm a week behind sooo idk when I'll have my next update :3

Macie Lightfoot
12-10-2018, 02:28 AM
Slowing catching up!

https://i.imgur.com/mGDpMLm.png

Macie Lightfoot
18-10-2018, 01:14 AM
I'm slowly catching up, ladies!

https://i.imgur.com/QoKCImh.png

Macie Lightfoot
23-10-2018, 03:16 AM
Slowly catching up ladies awoooooo

https://i.imgur.com/hkQmAc8.png

RileyH
23-10-2018, 11:53 AM
Oop @ Sian's UTRN edit awoooooo

Macie Lightfoot
28-10-2018, 07:01 PM
https://i.imgur.com/lWW1bI3.png

Only one week behind! and there's only one week left :skull:

Also Sian ftw? Week 1 she was just *barely* MOR but i might go back and make her UTR retroactively just so she can get all four types of UTR :love: I think Tracey BB8 might be the only person to achieve that?

Matthew.
28-10-2018, 07:07 PM
Tomasz didn’t have a negative edit

Macie Lightfoot
28-10-2018, 07:19 PM
ACTUALLY I never gave Tracey UTRM in any week, only as her overall rating. So Sian would be the first :o

Rachel Rice also came close but lol at her ever being UTRN :love:

Macie Lightfoot
28-10-2018, 07:20 PM
Tomasz didn’t have a negative edit

He's been continually ****-talked for ~playing da game~ and has been the target in like ever Big Coin Task since the third week, it's classic CPN and I say that with love.

Matthew.
28-10-2018, 07:51 PM
Idk a whole lot about Edgic and I get the general idea from looking at the OP, but I would say that he’s CPM?

Macie Lightfoot
28-10-2018, 08:00 PM
Overall probably yes but there wasn't really any positivity to him in the middle weeks

Macie Lightfoot
05-11-2018, 05:03 AM
https://i.imgur.com/8gdbJwb.png

Tomasz nearly having a symmetrical edgic strip :love: he actually did get a lot of positivity in his boot week buuuut there was that whole suggestion box ordeal about TOO MUCH SEX TALK #dickdickdickdickdick #daddy sooooo yeah OTTM is his rating.

Sian's edgic strip continues to be a delight!

Macie Lightfoot
14-11-2018, 03:15 AM
https://i.imgur.com/W0KTdJI.png

Finally done :love: The final week wasn't BAD but it was a bit of a lovefest and it could be nauseating at times, but it would've been nice if I cared about the cast? Like this wouldn't be a bad final week with the BB18 or BB13 finalists, it's just that the 19 finalists were really tepid :shrug: