View Full Version : Should Sharon be allowed to join onto another group?
Should Sharon be allowed to join onto another mentor (most likely Louis) and help them with their acts? It would be better than her just being sat there like a spare part. Someone on another forum suggested that Hope should be axed, and Phoebe should become a solo artist and work with Sharon for the rest of the competition.
Billy
17-11-2007, 10:02 PM
I suggested that here too :P
But No, she should just go and leave now
Jackie
17-11-2007, 10:02 PM
No she shouldnt.
By the way, I don't mean be an official mentor and come out with that category on results show, I mean a second opinion type thing
Shaun
17-11-2007, 10:11 PM
No...
And I find the third option totally unnecessary.
Retroman
17-11-2007, 10:18 PM
She lost...
Any changes would just be in a bid to make her feel better. Where's the logic in that?
It's like having a race and someone losing, so we take the actual winner out of the competition so the loser can win/still have a chance >_< sounds rather stupid if you ask me? Avoids the entire point in a competition perhaps? Im thinking so.
Originally posted by Retroman
She lost...
Any changes would just be in a bid to make her feel better. Where's the logic in that?
It's like having a race and someone losing, so we take the actual winner out of the competition so the loser can win/still have a chance >_< sounds rather stupid if you ask me? Avoids the entire point in a competition perhaps? Im thinking so.
No not at all you have taken the complete wrong end of what I am saying. I (later) said not an official mentor but more a second opinion.
Retroman
17-11-2007, 10:23 PM
She already is a second opinion, as she's still a judge? =/ she'll have nothing better to do than walk around observing the acts and making comments.
Attaching her onto an act/acts she's had nothing to do with will just give them a free vote to stay in.
Also, her helping acts from someone elses category gives them an unfair advantage of having two people who know what they're doing, instead of one.
Not to mention she might get in the way, and conflict with the original mentors style/approach. Not that they'd want someone who LOST helping them? as she obviously did an awful job this year.
No. And the person who suggested Hope should be dismantled should be shot.
:)
Sharon has no acts left. The position she's in now is actually very useful, she's got no bias whatsoever, in fact, the remaining acts will want to chum up to her so they can get her vote if they're in the bottom two.
Spike
18-11-2007, 10:54 AM
No, Sharon has lost its her own fault there's no need for her to help mentor another category her job now is to give an opinion on a Saturday night.
No way. She lost. Maybe not fairly, because the depature of Emily was not her fault but still she lost and shouldnt be allowed to join another group.
BigSister
18-11-2007, 04:00 PM
no because she lost and all the others have mentors anyway. Plus as some1 said they will want to chum up to her as she has potential to hold a key casting vote
Captain.Remy
18-11-2007, 04:02 PM
She lost, end of. Her group was rubbish this year actually.
Wasted
18-11-2007, 04:02 PM
No, she should remain impartial now. She should've chosen better acts and worked better with them if she still wanted to be in the competition.
Billy
18-11-2007, 04:04 PM
Theywould be aswell as putting Phoebe with Sharon, the other 4 are just for show anyways
Wasted
18-11-2007, 04:10 PM
Originally posted by Billy
Theywould be aswell as putting Phoebe with Sharon, the other 4 are just for show anyways
It's too late to split up Hope now, but I definitely think Phoebe should've been solo in Sharon's category. She should never have been eliminated in Boot Camp in the first place.
Shaun
18-11-2007, 05:01 PM
Originally posted by Billy
Theywould be aswell as putting Phoebe with Sharon, the other 4 are just for show anyways
...no, it's just that Phoebe has the best voice. That doesn't mean the others are rubbish, because we've heard them sing and we know they aren't. :)
SairBabi92
18-11-2007, 05:20 PM
Axe Hope and put Phoebe in the girls category
Nicola
18-11-2007, 05:48 PM
I think Sharon should remain an "impartial" judge, Hope are doing well as they are and shouldn't be split up. I agree she's been the unluckiest judge this year and didn't have any chance of winning with Alisha, all the others have strong acts left in the contest (i.e. Rhydian, Beverley and Hope).
Sharon will most likely have the deciding vote when it comes to the bottom 2 before the decision is based on public vote alone.
vBulletin® v3.8.11, Copyright ©2000-2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.