ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums

ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/index.php)
-   TV Chat (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Carol Thatcher dropped from 'The One Show' after 'Golliwog' Comment (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/showthread.php?t=80579)

NettoSuperstar! 05-02-2009 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by arista
Quote:

Originally posted by NettoSuperstar!
Calling someone a gollywog is racist end of!


Everyone who knows her says she is not Racist
at all.

This was not said On Air.


A BBC worker
jumped at this - sold it to the Press.

Give her 3 months off
would solve this.
She made a racist comment over

ange7 05-02-2009 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by arista
Did that BBC woker have to leak this to the Press?

This looks like someone in the
background, wanted her off that show.
ooooo does it arista.... ok then ...
.... when you talk racist horse sh@t in front of co- workers and you are retarded and meat headed enough not to apologies then what you'll find is that you get the sack. Why is this a surprise to you.... "We have ascertained subsequently from the people that were party to the conversation that by nobody's reckoning could it have been deemed to have been used in a jokey fashion.". Ie the other 2 or more people did NOT think she was joking. Please tell us arista in what context call someone who is not in the room a golliwog could in anyway be funny. Given you thinks it fine and not rasist are you prepared to call any people on this forum, who are black, a golliwog,?

andyman 05-02-2009 02:47 PM

When did i say that word is ok?..

You wrote that i would say that word to ama... So your head thinks it then writes it, its true? What a stupid post you made ange7... Not once have i agreed tjhat that word is ok to be used.. And no i would never say that word or think that word... Ange7 you do enjoy to stir things to make it a racial issue..

Plus your trying to stir things up between me and ama by writing that i would call him that word! The fact is NO... I dont agree with that word, but you (ange7) is trying to stir racical problems by posting things like that... Bit low of you, no in fact its very low.

Calling a member a racist and implying that they have mental health problems isn't on.

It best to stick to the issues and avoid getting personal.

Post edited - Red

ange7 05-02-2009 02:52 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Callum
Personally I don't think she should have got fired, she probably didn't mean any harm when she said it. I expect the person who she was referring to just laughed it off. What I find disgusting though is that someone leaked it out to the press, whatever's said in the greem room should be kept there. :bored:
So racisms in the green room should stay in the green room?... you say it as though it's some kind of known TV show etiquette. Dude... balls! Hehe
And how is it "in jest"?.DO us a favour Calum and explain how calling someone who she does not know and is not a mate of and isn't even in the room, a golliwog could be funny. Mate I'm all ears.

arista 05-02-2009 03:04 PM

What Carole said in Full sentance
is not in the Press - at this time.


On the Ch5 Wright Stuff this morning
they talked about this
and concluded she should not have been sacked.
Also how nasty it was for a BBC worker to
give it to the Press.

It is now
big news,
and the fact the Queens shop was selling golly dolls.


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...ndringham.html

Red Moon 05-02-2009 03:06 PM

Please stick to the subject and don't personalise posts by talking about other members

Red

andyman 05-02-2009 03:08 PM

I remember these jam jars i think that had them on... Maybe ange7 thinks everybody is racist...


Ange7, is a white dog racist white?
Ange7, if a child only likes white chocolate does that make the child racist?.. If whatj i wrote seems daft then i'm just going by your logic dear.

andyman 05-02-2009 03:10 PM

Red, ange7 is calling me a racist, i must defend myself because its not true... I am not a racist.

ange7 05-02-2009 03:12 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by andyman
When did i say that word is ok?..

You wrote that i would say that word to ama... So your head thinks it then writes it, its true? What a stupid post you made ange7... Not once have i agreed tjhat that word is ok to be used.. And no i would never say that word or think that word... Ange7 you do enjoy to stir things to make it a racial issue.. Your the racist ange7, and you call yourself a person of faith.. Your sure your a church person ange7???
Plus your trying to stir things up between me and ama by writing that i would call him that word! The fact is NO... I dont agree with that word, but you (ange7) is trying to stir racical problems by posting things like that... Bit low of you, no in fact its very low.

Dear ange7 you do find alot of things to be racial when its not... Go see a doctor, your head needs to.
reported ... "go see a doctor, your head needs to"

I'm a racist? ... for bring up a racial issues...?? .... so pointing out clear examples of racism is in of itself racist. ? lol wow
When is calling someone a golliwog not a racial issue? That's pretty straight up and down in my book.
Re ama ... mate I couldn't care less frankly about you or ama .... I don't know either of you nor do I need to try separate you.... dude...wtf... you been watching too ,many daytime soaps. I brought up ama because I wanted to bring home the idea that calling someone a golliwog wasn't some theoretical question of what is or isn't political correctness and what is racist... ( a shady place where you spend most of your time) but in fact effects real people. I used ama because he's someone you know. In all of these post you NEVER said the term golliwog wasn't racist ... in stead you kept adding fuel to the fire by making the call regarding the double standards. “White person says "golliwog".. Is that racist?

Black person says "white trash".. Is that racist? “

Mate that was YOU bring up the racial divide LONG before I got involved.
In future try to argue a point and not attack me personally by telling me I ought to see a doctor nor question my morality by through my faith. Low you say? Huh?

Can we get back to just the subject and make things less personal. I delt with the reported post so lets just get on with talking about the subject and just the subject.

Red

NettoSuperstar! 05-02-2009 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by ange7
Quote:

Originally posted by Callum
Personally I don't think she should have got fired, she probably didn't mean any harm when she said it. I expect the person who she was referring to just laughed it off. What I find disgusting though is that someone leaked it out to the press, whatever's said in the greem room should be kept there. :bored:
So racisms in the green room should stay in the green room?... you say it as though it's some kind of known TV show etiquette. Dude... balls! Hehe
And how is it "in jest"?.DO us a favour Calum and explain how calling someone who she does not know and is not a mate of and isn't even in the room, a golliwog could be funny. Mate I'm all ears.
lol@TV show etiquette! yeh probablys, maybes, whatever. If she called a black person a golliwog she deserves disciplinary action. And I really wouldnt imagine they laughed it off.... oh hahaha

ange7 05-02-2009 03:15 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by andyman
Red, ange7 is calling me a racist, i must defend myself because its not true... I am not a racist.
mate we're all ears... go for it... I've asked time and again... dude CLEARLY say the word golliwog IS racist and that you don't agree with all your mates here hehe.

Tom4784 05-02-2009 03:16 PM

In what context did she say it though? I think it was an idiotic thing to say but we can't throw the book at her or support her without knowing exactly what she said.

Always remember, there's a difference between rascism and ignorance. Just because someone uses a word doesn't mean they are rascist. For example it wasn't until year 11 when i was told that 'half caste' was an offensive term, but since I found out I never use it. Carol should have known better but maybe she didn't mean it in the context everyone thought she was? I don't know.

I'll abstain from forming an opinion untill more information is known.

NettoSuperstar! 05-02-2009 03:19 PM

Well the people who knew what context it was said in, they did throw the book at her

andyman 05-02-2009 03:21 PM

Ange7 you ALWAYS bring the racial thing into alot of your posts, maybe you have hiddn issues...


Anyway back on topic... The word Carol used was bad taste by her, she should have known what it means. I have never used that word, spoken it or even wrote it... And never will, and as for ange7 calling me a racist? No i am not a racist.

Red Moon 05-02-2009 03:21 PM

Do you think they would have sacked if she had the same sort of status as say Jonathan Ross?

NettoSuperstar! 05-02-2009 03:23 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Red Moon
Do you think they would have sacked if she had the same sort of status as say Jonathan Ross?
Yes if they'd called someone a golliwog, I think so.

Dom:D 05-02-2009 03:24 PM

:bored:

ange7 05-02-2009 03:29 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dezzy
In what context did she say it though? I think it was an idiotic thing to say but we can't throw the book at her or support her without knowing exactly what she said.

Always remember, there's a difference between rascism and ignorance. Just because someone uses a word doesn't mean they are rascist. For example it wasn't until year 11 when i was told that 'half caste' was an offensive term, but since I found out I never use it. Carol should have known better but maybe she didn't mean it in the context everyone thought she was? I don't know.

I'll abstain from forming an opinion untill more information is known.
the term golliwog is a known racist term for at least 20 years Dezzy...she knew that. It was a racist term back when Callum and 30stone were getting their Golliwog toys given to them from their parents too.
Re Ignorance... it's is still racism... just racism lite. It's your social responsibility to make an effort in a multicultural society to at least have a clue about other peoples cultures ( and sub-cultures :P).... ignorance is no excuse but obviously is not as bad as the full blown racial hate of people who go out of their way to attack and instil hate in others. As for context... the others in the room were in no doubt that it was not a joke on her part and what's worse ... she felt too proud to apologies and in so doing concede that see screwed up. Now we have all these people arguing that she was in the right and ought not apologies because apparently black comedians attack whites so they ought be able to have their fun too. Honestly I can't follow Andyman and co's position at all ...and if there is no logical position then that one leaves the illogical.

andyman 05-02-2009 03:32 PM

People around her might use that word, grown up with it more like... And no it does not make it right, we all know what it means and can never be used in jest.


I'm sure they was used on jam labels years ago.

ange7 05-02-2009 03:33 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by andyman
Ange7 you ALWAYS bring the racial thing into alot of your posts, maybe you have hiddn issues...


Anyway back on topic... The word Carol used was bad taste by her, she should have known what it means. I have never used that word, spoken it or even wrote it... And never will, and as for ange7 calling me a racist? No i am not a racist.
"Ange7 you ALWAYS bring the racial thing into alot of your posts" nah dude... just into YOUR posts :P

"No i am not a racist."
Ummm unfortunately that ain't your call .... people can read this thread and see how you whip up hate....

ange7 05-02-2009 03:37 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by andyman
Peope around her might use that word, grown up with it more like... And no it does not make it right, we all know what it means and can never be used in jest.


I'm sure they was used on jam labels years ago.
It certainly CAN be used in jest ... comedians can use it and more.... point is she didn't mean it in jest, nothing AT ALL points to her using it in jest yet you claim she did and that it's all an over reaction by the PC police. Rubbish... I hate the PC stuff as much as you ... but your trying to sneak this blatant racism under the "oh it's pc correctness gone mad" banner....... yet again.

Red Moon 05-02-2009 03:38 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by NettoSuperstar!
Quote:

Originally posted by Red Moon
Do you think they would have sacked if she had the same sort of status as say Jonathan Ross?
Yes if they'd called someone a golliwog, I think so.
I don't think they would as long as they had said it off air.

What she did was disgraceful but it was hardly a sacking offense. A official warning yes, maybe even a suspension, but they over reacted in doing what they did.

Red Moon 05-02-2009 03:40 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by andyman
Ange7 you ALWAYS bring the racial thing into alot of your posts, maybe you have hiddn issues...
Will you stop making the thread personal!

Red

NettoSuperstar! 05-02-2009 03:40 PM

Well maybe not sacked but disciplined. Im sure they would if it got leaked out

ange7 05-02-2009 03:40 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dom:D
:bored:
your strangely quite .... some point you'd like to make mate … has your band wagon that you jumped on busted a wheel?....


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:41 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.