Dannii is nowhere near as skinny as Cheryl? If your gonna defend Cheryl at least speak sense.

of course she is, they both are, both have great figures though.

hey i think they av both nice bodies.....

I lurvee Dannii!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Team Minogue!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Its just pathetic really, both are as good as each other and both deserve their place on the panel. If Dannii was that bad then she wouldn't have won last year, she wouldn't have been praised for her mentoring and she wouldn't have topped most favourite judge polls.

I just find it really tedious when two sets of fans start arguing over whos best and just start making things up/things seem worse than they are like the anorexia comment, comments about Dannii's plastic surgery. Its just showing how noones arguments hold any weight because they have to resort to personal appearance, and I can't see anyone making them comments to be lookers themselves.

Cheryl is more successful than Dannii. Dannii also has success. Simple as really.

Defo, both gorgeous too. I just perfer Cheryl.

The Danni Minogue plastic surgery/botox stories aren't "made up" - they've been proven to be truthful. Most argumentative posts in here have held weight, not everyones replies but a lot have.

I agree with the conclusion you came to.

Cheryl > Danni. :devil:

But is her appearance relevant? No.

Exactly!!!!