jaxie |
21-08-2016 11:53 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Niamh.
(Post 8904397)
imo the IRA is not comparable here when you're talking about using Religion as a war tool. This was not why the IRA was formed, the IRA was formed because Ireland was taken over by Britain and then split in two and the IRA were fighting for the country back, not because they were trying to convert anyone to Catholicism or were doing it in the name of Catholicism, it really annoys me when British people try to pass it off as some sort of religious war. Yes most of the "Republicans" in the North are/were Catholics but that's just because Catholicism was the predominant Irish religion. There were actually Protestant members of the IRA too.
I'm not defending the IRA here btw especially in later years there was no going back but I hate the fact that alot of times British people are under the impression that the North was some sort of Religious war where the Catholics are trying to convert the Protestants or something when in Reality it was always a fight for our country back that you lot started by the way by invading us and beating our language out of us, etc etc
If it weren't for the IRA or the earlier version of it the whole of Ireland would still be part of Britain
|
I think that is generally an accurate assessment except that it's vastly simplified and missing out on about 500 years of history. The state made many mistakes and there were dreadful choices made and no support during the potato famine when many people starved to death. However you are missing out the fact that a lot of the problem was because there were two factions of people living in Northern Ireland with extremely strong opposing opinions and a lot of hate for each other. Most people call it Catholic v Protestant because that's a fairly easy thing to do but it was of course much more political and much less religious. IMO violence is always the wrong way and peace can achieve much greater things.
We can only learn from the mistakes of the past, we can't change what's been but we can hope never to repeat.
With regard to the OP question I would say that all religion causes wars and dispute because some those who ought to be focusing on the love of their deity get involved in a my god is bigger than your god thing and get carried away by misinterpreting their doctrine while others sit passively by. This has happened in most religions.
Most religion was forged in times of ignorance, lack of education, violence and extreme cruelty and it boggles me that anyone in 2016 would interpret and follow violent doctrine whatever the flavour of their worship is.
|