Tibb On Ice 2023. Results Show. Scottish Artists.
 

Hello and welcome to the Round 6 results show.

Here we go.....

Parmy's Scores

BOTS




Good song, but skating wise it started if well in the intro but then the song suddenly drops a level that cant be skated to. It doesn't lift up again until we get the instrumental chorus..disappointing begining. 6

Barry



Really average entry for this stage of the tournament. 6


LT



A great song for the ice, lots of variety and change of direction in the song. Had jumps and swirls.. just what I'm looking for..10

Alf



Energetic performance, but not your best of the series. 7.5

Cherie




All voice, no action. I need more rythm. 6.5

Vanessa




I cant give this anymore than a 10 can I? If I can make it a 12..if not it's a 10....perfection, absolute song perfection.

Kate





Fun and funky performance, just lacking something but I'm not sure what...7.5

Hijaxers




I really wanted this to score high, sorry it lacks just about everything I like in a performance..6.5


Parmy's Scores

BOTS




Good song, but skating wise it started if well in the intro but then the song suddenly drops a level that cant be skated to. It doesn't lift up again until we get the instrumental chorus..disappointing begining. 6

Barry



Really average entry for this stage of the tournament. 6


LT



A great song for the ice, lots of variety and change of direction in the song. Had jumps and swirls.. just what I'm looking for..10

Alf



Energetic performance, but not your best of the series. 7.5

Cherie




All voice, no action. I need more rythm. 6.5

Vanessa




I cant give this anymore than a 10 can I? If I can make it a 12..if not it's a 10....perfection, absolute song perfection.

Kate





Fun and funky performance, just lacking something but I'm not sure what...7.5

Hijaxers




I really wanted this to score high, sorry it lacks just about everything I like in a performance..6.5

Jake's Scores

BOTS

1. I like the song but I'm struggling to see what an ice skating performance would look like to it. However yeah good track. 8.0

Barry

2. This is my fave Texas track. Good choice. 9.0

LT

3. This is such a 80s classic. Everything worked. 10.0

Alf

4. This song reminds me of my fave show the Derry girls. It's a really cheerful song. 9.5

Cherie

5. Not a fan of this song it's always annoyed me. 6.5

Vanessa

6. Nope sorry this is too predictable. Think Scottish. You think of Lewis Capaldi. Not only that. The most obvious Lewis song there is. 6.0

Kate

7. This gave me a headache. Not a fan. 6.0

Hijaxers

8. This was a wonderful choice. 9.5

Why did no one post this. Instant 11.

Slim's Scores

BOTS

Gerry Rafferty - 8

Smooth tones, and an engaging bass line makes this an instant hit on the ice.

Barry

Texas - 6

It was ok, but a bit of a nothingy track

LT

Eurythmics - 7

Here comes the rain again exists, and should always be the first choice eurythmics song.

Alf

The Bluebells - 5

The whole back catalogue of Scottish excellence in music, and yet here we are :facepalm: Really deserves lower than 5.

Cherie

Deacon Blue - 8

On the ice, I'll do some real gone skids :smug:

Vanessa

Lewis - 7

Not really my thing, but it gets an extra point because the chorus sounds like that meme song from the 00's

Kate

Aztec camera - 6

If this is the best Scotland has to offer, then I'll vote for them to have independence.

Hijaxers

Rod - 7

Not the best Rodney track around, but does a job.

Now I'll add up the scores

The song I wanted to go for was "Read all about it" by Emilie Sandie.

While she's classed as a Scottish artist. She was born in the North East of England to English and Nigerian parents and only grew up in Scotland. That's why I didn't go for it.

What an arse Slim.

Another 11

I was shocked when it was revealed as your song. Tut tut

Scores

LT 27
Vanessa 23
Hijaxers 23
BOTS 22
Alf 22
Barry 21
Cherie 21
Kate 19.5

I was gonna go with this but I didn't think you'd get it so I thought I'd try play safe, turns out I only played safe to Jake. I love this song.

Bet hes back soon.:joker:

Should have - easily a 6 :smug:

Am I the only judge who sends their comments back with each video attached to the post kate?

Because Parm went to see Rod. I was tempted to go for one of his. But I thought he'd see it as creeping. Same with Sunshine on Leith.

Overall Leaderboard

Vanessa 157.5
LT 153
Hijaxers 150
Cherie 146.5
Alf 143.5
BOTS 143
Barry 141
Kate 137.5 :bawling:

Yep, the others do their write ups separate

So lazy.

Still Game had the Bluebells singing "Young at heart" in one of their final episodes so I saw it as a Scottish classic. If it makes it on Still Game then it's royalty in Scotland.

I'd have given it a 10.

I was hoping they were all going to be rod

LT nearly toppling Ness from the top of the leaderboard but our Italian lass is clinging on!

Don't worry, I'll win the Country round. I''ve got one of the best.

:hmph:

Both got a ten from your head judge.:smug:

If you send in some keith urban or other nonsense, it's getting a 5.

Don't tell my heart. My akey breaky heart. I just don't think you'll understand.

U2 have done some songs I would class as country.

More aligned with Irish week.

Oh, yeah. Of course.:creep:

Bring back Nicky.

Get rid of Slim

Country Week :flutter:


umm well, as i am no longer a judge, i can give contestants some advice, think it through and through

you also have quite a lot of variety when it comes to country music

Country Pop, Country Rock, you even have a bit of Country Soul but also Americana and Bluegrass, or Latin Country



wish i could submit something (for the fun of it) i envy you guys with this theme :lovedup:

Why has Cherries post been deleted?

Just LT, Hijaxers and BOTS to send their country songs

Is LT still in?

news of my demise has been greatly exaggerated

He flounced out the other day, didn't he :laugh:

I can confirm LT is back with us, and has submitted a cracking country song in my opinion