Cheryl > Whitney
 

Cheryl was good, Whitney was shocking, all she did was sing "Oh" a few times and walk around the stage whilst her dress was falling off. She also turned up pissed

Cheryl wiped the floor with her, never thought I'd be writing that!!

Agree.

:thumbs:

Also agree. :thumbs:

Whitney's costume girl has already been sacked. :joker:

Yeah I think Cheryl put on a better performance

So true. She looked so rough afther that.

Cheryl.

Is the new god.

agreed.

agree <3

Completely disgree. It was obvious Cheryl was singing to a backing track, because she never got out of breath, and she was dancing. That was pretty clear.
Whitney, did a lot better than I thought, She hit notes that I didnt think she could anymore. I thought she did really well. The wardrobe malfunction aside.

Cheryl was poor, whitney was poor

they were as bad as each other

Cheryl got the best reaction


Whitney was disrespectful and looked as if she wanted to be somewere else, I bet if it was American Idol she `d be given her all..

Well we dont need her anyway!

Cheryl was the best and probley the reason many people watched tonight

Yes, I was while happy Cheryl performed live :D

agreed.
ignoring the wardrobe problem, Whitney's song is a rubbish one, it was mostly backing vocals and she just stood there.

I think I now love her for saying that about J&E

Whitney singing>Cheryl singing

Cheryls performance>Whitneys performance

But cheryls was prerecorded so overall I have more respect for whitney...

She did get out of breath, she missed a few words and went way off tune at one point

Cheryl impressed me, whitney didnt.
Cheryl kept me watching because she was entertaining, whitney didnt.

Well, well have to disagree then Tom and 30. I thought it Whitney did much better than I expected.

IA

I didn't think either performance was amazing, but yeh - Cheryl's performance was the better of the two. Whitney was a disappointment 09.

yep... cheryl is wayyyyy better than whitney

Singing 'oh oh oh' every once in a while isn't exactly hard though. Whitney's wasn't a performance it was a trainwreck, worst guest performance ever. It was like she was drunk. At least Cheryl put on an entertaining show.