[Tom]

Cheryl was good, Whitney was shocking, all she did was sing "Oh" a few times and walk around the stage whilst her dress was falling off. She also turned up pissed

Cheryl wiped the floor with her, never thought I'd be writing that!!

[LemonJam]

Agree.

[Ross]

Whitney's costume girl has already been sacked.

[ILoveTRW]

[Sam!]

Also agree.

[Adamw92]

Yeah I think Cheryl put on a better performance

[Harry!]

So true. She looked so rough afther that.

[Firewire]

Cheryl.

Is the new god.

[Stephanie]

agreed.

[xDramatick]

agree <3

[Wildcat!]

Completely disgree. It was obvious Cheryl was singing to a backing track, because she never got out of breath, and she was dancing. That was pretty clear.
Whitney, did a lot better than I thought, She hit notes that I didnt think she could anymore. I thought she did really well. The wardrobe malfunction aside.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Wildcat!

Completely disgree. It was obvious Cheryl was singing to a backing track, because she never got out of breath, and she was dancing. That was pretty clear.
Whitney, did a lot better than I thought, She hit notes that I didnt think she could anymore. I thought she did really well. The wardrobe malfunction aside.

She did get out of breath, she missed a few words and went way off tune at one point

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Wildcat!

Completely disgree. It was obvious Cheryl was singing to a backing track, because she never got out of breath, and she was dancing. That was pretty clear.
Whitney, did a lot better than I thought, She hit notes that I didnt think she could anymore. I thought she did really well. The wardrobe malfunction aside.

Singing 'oh oh oh' every once in a while isn't exactly hard though. Whitney's wasn't a performance it was a trainwreck, worst guest performance ever. It was like she was drunk. At least Cheryl put on an entertaining show.

[King Gizzard]

Cheryl was poor, whitney was poor

they were as bad as each other

[Patrick]

Cheryl got the best reaction


Whitney was disrespectful and looked as if she wanted to be somewere else, I bet if it was American Idol she `d be given her all..

Well we dont need her anyway!

Cheryl was the best and probley the reason many people watched tonight

[bronaaaa]

Yes, I was while happy Cheryl performed live

[Shaun]

agreed.
ignoring the wardrobe problem, Whitney's song is a rubbish one, it was mostly backing vocals and she just stood there.

[King Gizzard]

I think I now love her for saying that about J&E

[Vicky.]

Whitney singing>Cheryl singing

Cheryls performance>Whitneys performance

But cheryls was prerecorded so overall I have more respect for whitney...

[30stone]

Cheryl impressed me, whitney didnt.
Cheryl kept me watching because she was entertaining, whitney didnt.

[Wildcat!]

Well, well have to disagree then Tom and 30. I thought it Whitney did much better than I expected.

[CaraRawr]

IA

[Arneldo]

I didn't think either performance was amazing, but yeh - Cheryl's performance was the better of the two. Whitney was a disappointment 09.

[Stacey.]

yep... cheryl is wayyyyy better than whitney