Janet vs Diana
 

Diana for me.

Janet for me

Im no Diana fan but Janet is just a rip off version of her and isnt anywhere near as good as her Imo.

Diana by a mile.

Diana.

Same

I think Janet is probably the better singer but I prefer Diana

I love Janet but its gotta be Diana. :lovedup:

Diana!!
Janet is my favourite this year though :love:.
Diana is my 2nd favourite X-Factor act ever.

hahahahahahahhaha. it's like saying MCVITIES JAFFA CAKES or LIDL ORANGE JELLY ROUNDS.

Clearly Diana.

Diana :love:

:joker:

Janet, she's a better singer and her voice is far less annoying

Diana. But I love Janet too.

Janet all the way

Love both but I prefer Diana :lovedup:

Both are great but Diana :lovedup:

Janet by far. Diana's voice just annoys me.

Janet. Diana has a sort of strained voice, Janet's is just kinda mesmerising. I know she'll get boring but she's probably gonna win

A lot of Diana fans but according to another thread about X Factor album sales on this site, she only shifted 170,000 copies of Songs From The Tainted Cherry Tree.

Diana Vickers was original, and was the orignal Simon Cowell "marmite singer"

Janet has less power, less confidence, but maybe a little more likeability because you can see that she is vulnerable, and in the UK we like "vulnerable".

The problem is with both girls, this 'style' of singing is very limited and not suited to theme weeks. Diana pulled off big band week with "Smile" and disco week with Blondie's "Call Me". Not sure if Janet has the power, so she will really have to work on some arrangements. I'm not a fan of themes because every singer has a style, be it pop, blues or jazz etc so why have a Michael Jackson or Beatles week and force them to sing in a style that they have never been suited to?

Hated Diana with a strong passion, but Janet is just awful so I chose Diana.

Janet. She was great tonight

Diana