Cowell made final decision on Emily\'s future
 

I read that, it was the right one. What she did was out of order.

Dickhead Cowell. Ah well, at least their's Alisha and Hope!

good for him

Go Simon for making the right decision

I find it funny how all the way through the show she was in tears, right up until the final twelve. Constantly seeming vunerable and upset, whilst playing on her "life threatening illness" story.

Then all of a sudden she started smiling in an arrogant manner, answering back to the judges and coming accross rather smug with herself when people critisised her.

Now we find out she performs happy slaps, she suddenly doesn't seem the sweet, innocent, crying wreck she once was =]

One of her sides she showed us was false, so she's fake in my opinion.

Although I haven't seen the happy slap incident, surely it can't have been that bad? Did she slap them herself in an extremely violent way or something? and then the person was really offended by it?

Then I might slightly understand why she was removed.

bottom line is she deserved it!

Exactly.

I saw the video and I didn't see any slapping, but she wa pulling the girls hair, and when asked to stop by the girl she didn't.

Retroman - your comment about her al answer judges back is ridiculous. If you look at the first live show she said "the judges are the experts, they know what they are talking about Im here to learn from them" and the last one Simon applauded her for saying what she did.

Why? It was totally the right decision. What Lady Shiverz did to that poor girl was plain nasty and she doesn't deserve a chance like this, horrible little cretin. People who do things like that really make my blood boil.

Here's something from the article I also found interesting:


It shocks me that anyone would want her to stay after that video! Surely they realise what a bad message it sends across about the show by keeping someone like that on it?

I haven't seen the video yet, and I'm not sure I want to. It will truly shatter and taint the image of the 15-year-old Emily I had. She always seemed extremely mature for her age, and genuinely nice at the same time to me. I'm also shocked that some members of the production team wanted her to stay - perhaps they didn't want to take too drastic steps?

But I think Simon made the right decision, no doubt. It's just a real shame for Sharon now, as she only has Alisha... who hasn't exactly been doing fantastically well.

Glad Simon made that decision
it was the right one