[Patrick]

They say Red Dead Redemption has the best replay value of any game, I was going to say 'This Year' of course I mean last year, but I really don't get the appeal.

I love that game and the look of it but there isn't THAT much to do.

Grand Theft Auto has amazing replay value.
I find The Ballad Of Gay Tony is better to go back and play again rather than IV because of the fact there's more to do than in GTA IV.

When you complete IV there's ****** all to do apart from getting police chases which at some point get boring when there isn't enough weapons to throw at them [BoGT fixes this].

Plus in Ballad Of Gay Tony if you get bored you can go to the club and take a couple of shots, get hammered and it's always great to see what random place in Liberty City the bouncers leave you the morning after.