[Amy Jade]

I was just reading that they hate each other, Elton literally dispises her but who who is better?

For the Lion King soundtrack alone I vote Elton John

[LukeB]

Elton John!

Circle of Life and can you feel the love are one of the best songs ever and he can sing

[Morgan.]

Neither but I'll say Elton because of Kingamam 2

[reece(:]

Madonna for her iconic discography

When will Elton release Hollywood

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by reece(:

Madonna for her iconic discography

When will Elton release Hollywood

When will Madonna sing anything as iconic as Circle of Life?

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

When will Madonna sing anything as iconic as Circle of Life?

Bedtime Story is the lullaby Elton wishes he could produce

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by reece(:

Bedtime Story is the lullaby Elton wishes he could produce

Never heard of it. Neither have most people judging by it's critical and chart performances.

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

Never heard of it. Neither have most people judging by it's critical and chart performances.

Madge remains unbothered with her other 10s of #1s

[RileyH]

Madge by a mile

[Jake.]

Elton’s far more talented

[thesheriff443]

Both have made great classic tracks

[LukeB]

Your Song and i'm still standing are another legendary songs

[Denver]

Rocketman is a great song

[Denver]

In his five-decade career Elton John has sold more than 300 million records, making him one of the best-selling music artists in the world. He has more than fifty Top 40 hits, including seven consecutive No. 1 US albums, 58 Billboard Top 40 singles, 27 Top 10, four No. 2 and nine No. 1.



Elton wins

[joeysteele]

I rate Elton John as a songwriter but prefer others singing his songs than him.

Madonna is excellent all round so for me Madonna ahead by miles.

[smudgie]

Has to be Elton for me.

[Candy Annie Cane]

Elton has the biggest seeling song ever because he jumped on Diana's death. Some if his early stuff was great....

Madonna is amazing.

Madonna for me

[Denver]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

Elton has the biggest seeling song ever because he jumped on Diana's death. Some if his early stuff was great....

Madonna is amazing.

Madonna for me

Diana was his best mate

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

Elton has the biggest seeling song ever because he jumped on Diana's death. Some if his early stuff was great....

Madonna is amazing.

Madonna for me

[Nancy.]

The thing is, Elton might've sold around the same amount of records she has, but he's recorded 30 studio albums over those 5 decades, whereas Madonna only recorded 13 albums across 4 decades.

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

Elton has the biggest seeling song ever because he jumped on Diana's death. Some if his early stuff was great....

Madonna is amazing.

Madonna for me

That's a terrible thing to say, he was Diana's best friend.

[Candy Annie Cane]

Originally Posted by Amy Jade

That's a terrible thing to say, he was Diana's best friend.

Not terrible, its the truth. He would never have sold that number of copies if the country wasn't in mourning.

Not doubting their friendship, its well documented but just saying that's the reason he has that record.

He is a massive diva, also well documented and not a nice person at all if stories ive read are true

[Denver]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

Not terrible, its the truth. He would never have sold that number of copies if the country wasn't in mourning

Its also the biggest selling song in the US

[Candy Annie Cane]

Originally Posted by Adam.

Its also the biggest selling song in the US

Because the workd loved Diana....Not necessarily the song

[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

Not terrible, its the truth. He would never have sold that number of copies if the country wasn't in mourning

Sorry but I believe accusing him of such a thing is terrible. He released it to honour his friend. He was already massive why would he capitalise on his friends death?