[Beastie]

I am watching American Idol at the mo and well I have noticed this ages ago as well.. but Simon seems to have better opinions on American Idol rather than the same old "cliche's" we hear on The X Factor!

Does anyone notice this?

[Harry!]

I dont watch AI but AI is viewed differently to americans then XF is to british people. What works on american TV does not always work over the pond. UK TV is more gimicy to the US shows which most gullable UK people like.

[Tom4784]

I think he tends to try to hard to be nasty on AI, it's like he's playing a role while he'll acknowledge if something is good more on XF.

[Patrick]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

I think he tends to try to hard to be nasty on AI, it's like he's playing a role while he'll acknowledge if something is good more on XF.

Completely Agree.

[Raph]

I don't watch AI either, but I think Simon is really in it for the money now