[Tom]

Which head judge and his annoying sidekick are the best?

[Smithy]

Simon > Gary
Kelly > Cheryl

[Black Dagger]

Cheryl/Simon were gruesome last series, they spoilt it for me.

Still not nearly as annoying as Kelly or as boring as Gary though.

[Locke.]

Simon and Cheryl

Words can't describe how much Kelly pisses me off. And Cheryl was amazing.

I like both Simon and Gary, but Simon is better.

[Saph]

I like Simon but hate Cheryl. I like Kelly but hate Gary.

I chose Kelly and Gary because Cheryl doesnt even deserve my vote

[Jordan.]

Simon and Cheryl

[Callum]

Simon and Cheryl >>>>

Although they were awful on the last series, I still prefer them two over Gary and Kelly.

[joeysteele]

I cannot vote because I would have Simon back but never would want Cheryl Cole back at all in any capacity.

Hopefully had Simon been here, Kelly would have had to tone down rather. However I would be really glad to see the back of Gary Barlow from X Factor,he has totally ruined it for me this series already and he says very little that is relevant or constructive, a very poor judge indeed and he actually comes across as not a very nice person at all.

[Doogle]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Simon > Gary
Kelly > Cheryl

Yeah this