[Raph]

Let me know if I've forgotten anyone! For me:

1. Dannii Minogue
2. Tulsa Contostavlos
3. Mel B
4. Simon Cowell
5. Louis Walsh
6. Sharon Osborne
7. Cheryl Cole
8. Gary Barlow
9. Nicole Sherzinger
10. Kelly Rowland

To me, Dannii and Tulisa always came across most committed to their acts

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

dannii

[LukeB]

1.Simon
2.Cheryl
3.Gary
4.Kelly
5.Sharon
6.Mel B
7.Nicole
8.Danni
9.Louis
10. Tulisa

they all have there bad qualities tbh
cheryl,gary and tulisa have all given bad treatment towards an act
Cheryl - Raign
Gary - Sam and Rylan
Tulisa - Christopher Maloney

[Ninastar]

dannii
simon
alesha
kelly
louis
aids
gary
death
sharon

[Black Dagger]

1) Louis Walsh
2) Nicole Scherzinger
3) Dannii Minogue
4) Simon Cowell
5) Sharon Osbourne
6) Mel B
7) Cheryl Cole
8) Kelly Rowland (weak as piss on UK but absolutely adored her on the US show last year)
9) Tulisa (she'd have been higher if she'd just done the one series, her 2nd series was atrocious)
10) Gary Barlow (for lots of reasons, the main one was him sending James Michael home in favour of Frankie Cocozza (idfc if it was the producers) and then slating Nicole the year after for taking Rylan through over 'better singers' when he sent home plenty in favour of Frankie)

[Locke.]

1. Simon Cowell
2. Louis Walsh
3. Cheryl Cole
---
4. Sharon Osbourne
5. Gary Barlow
6. Tulisa
7. Nicole Scherzinger
---
8. Mel B
9. Dannii Minogue
10. Kelly Rowland

[reece(:]

1. Simon
2. Sharon
3. Nicole
4. Kelly
5. Louis
6. Mel
7. Tulisa
8. Dannii
9. Cheryl
10. Gary

[Braden]

1) Dannii
2) Mel B
3) Simon
4) Nicole
5) Louis
6) Tulisa
7) Cheryl
8) Sharon
9) Kelly
10) Gary

[Liam-]

1. Dannii
2. Simon
3. Mel B
4. Sharon
5. Nicole
6. Tulisa
7. Cheryl
8. Kelly
9. Louis
10. Gary.

[JoshBB]

1) Sharon
2) Nicole
3) Mel B
4) Tulisa
5) Simon
6) Louis
7) Cheryl
8) Dannii
9) Gary
10) Kelly

[ruiphillips]

1. Nicole Sherzinger
2. Kelly Rowland
3. Sharon Osborne
4. Mel B
5. Dannii Minogue
6. Tulsa Contostavlos
7. Simon Cowell
8. Gary Barlow
9. Louis Walsh
10. Cheryl Cole

[Cal.]

1. Simon
2. Sharon
3. Mel
4. Nicole
5. Kelly
6. Danni
7. Tulisa
8. Louis
9. Gary
10. Cheryl

[Samm]

1. Sharon
2. Simon
3. Dannii
4. Nicole
5. Louis
6. Kelly
7. Mel
8. Tulisa
----------
9. Cheryl
10. Gary

[Withano]

1. Louis Walsh
2. Simon Cowell

3. Sharon Osborne
4. Mel B
5. Nicole Sherzinger

6. Kelly Rowland
7. Dannii Minogue

8. Tulsa Contostavlos
9. Cheryl Cole
10. Gary Barlow

[Jack_]

1) Simon
2) Sharon
3) Louis

4) Nicole
5) Gary
6) Dannii

7) Mel
8) Tulisa
9) Cheryl
10) Kelly

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

1. kween burke as guest judge
2. the rest

[Tom4784]

1. Dannii
2. Mel B
3. Simon
4. Nicole
5. Louis
6. Sharon
7. Kelly
8. Gary
9. Tulisa
10. Cheryl

[Headie]

1. Sharon
2. Kelly
3. Simon
4. Louis
5. Mel B
6. Dannii
7. Nicole
8. Cheryl
9. Gary
10. Tulisa

[erinp5]

Mel's best bit last night lol


https://vine.co/v/OAj2UrHgrrH

[Pete.]

1. Kelly
2. Sharon
3. Mel B
4. Nicole
5. Simon
6. Cheryl
7. Gary
8. Dannii
9. Tulisa
10. Louis

[Black Dagger]

Originally Posted by erinp5

Mel's best bit last night lol


https://vine.co/v/OAj2UrHgrrH

She's come alive in the live shows, it's great.

[Sophiee]

1) louis walsh;
2) sharon osbourne;
3) cheryl cole;
4) simon cowell;
5) nicole scherzinger;
6) tulisa;
7) kelly rowland;
8) gary barlow;
9) mel b;
10) dannii minogue.

[Daniel-X]

1. Simon - LOVE
2. Cheryl - LOVE
3. Sharon - LOVE
4. Tulisa - LIKE
5. Louis - LIKE
6. Kelly -LIKE
7. Mel - MEH
8. Gary - DISLIKE
9. Nicole - DISLIKE
10. Dannii - HATE