[nanaimo]

Why did Dermot tell louis if he voted for treyc she would be out, weren't they one vote all at that stage and either could have went?

[Mystic Mock]

because cheryl refused to vote.

[nanaimo]

don't think you get what i mean, why single out treys as they were 1-1 why not say one of the girls will go

[fruit_cake]

sounds like he was trying to guide Louis to vote out TreyC if thats true?

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

don't think you get what i mean, why single out treys as they were 1-1 why not say one of the girls will go

because if katie was losing 2-1 cheryl would have demanded deadlock,simon would have allowed it and they would have pretended that treyc came bottom of the votes.

[Novo]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

because if katie was losing 2-1 cheryl would have demanded deadlock,simon would have allowed it and they would have pretended that treyc came bottom of the votes.

No. Dermot said on live TV it was going to be a Majority vote straight after Cheryl refused to vote so that would never have happened.. stop being silly.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Novo

No. Dermot said on live TV it was going to be a Majority vote straight after Cheryl refused to vote so that would never have happened.. stop being silly.

you never know with the x factor.

[joeysteele]

I think since Cole refused to vote and therefore do her job that;s she is paid to do, it should have automatically gone to the public vote.
It was massively unfair to put Louis in the position of deciding who would go.not fair at all.

Had Louis voted for Katie to go, that woudl have been 2-1 for Katie to go out and I dare bet anything that Ms Cole would have screamed the place down insisting she said if it went to 2-1 she would take it to deadlock.

You know what, I believe no matter what Demot had said,if that had happened deadlock would have been done too.

As it was Louis voted for Treyc so Ms Cole sat back and was content, saying nothing for a change amazingly.

[Niamh.]

I agree, something very strange going on there. I don't blame Cheryl for not voting but why come to her second so she would have no option but to refuse? Why not leave her till the end as they always do???

and Nanaimo as far as I can remember Dermot said that after Simon had picked so the next vote would have sent treyc home if she was picked.

[nanaimo]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

I agree, something very strange going on there. I don't blame Cheryl for not voting but why come to her second so she would have no option but to refuse? Why not leave her till the end as they always do???

and Nanaimo as far as I can remember Dermot said that after Simon had picked so the next vote would have sent treyc home if she was picked.

yeah i know but when it was louis turn danni had voted Katie so at that stage they were even, were they not?

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

yeah i know but when it was louis turn danni had voted Katie so at that stage they were even, were they not?

I might be wrong but they way I remember it Dermot said it after Simon had voted before Dannii voted not louis but I'm not a 100% sure on it

[nanaimo]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

I might be wrong but they way I remember it Dermot said it after Simon had voted before Dannii voted not louis but I'm not a 100% sure on it

Its all getting really confusing...hehe

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

Its all getting really confusing...hehe

well, whatever happened last night, something was rotten in Denmark that's for sure!

[Novo]

Something very strange indeed..

[fruit_cake]

I found an edited version of the judges last night go to 0:45

Youtube video

[Novo]

What are you complaining about now.. what's wrong with that video?

[fruit_cake]

well maybe because it was edited out so nobody can see what really happend????

[Novo]

What was so bad originally that was edited out?

The bit where Cheryl says " I'll take it to deadlock and then dermot says they are going on the Majority vote instead "

They should have shown that actually it would hopefully Drill into the public's head's that it wasn't fixed one bit

[nanaimo]

Treyc such a nice girl, maybe too nice to survive in the music industry and wish she said how she really felt, maybe signed something not to let her tell the truth. At least Katie is horrible and fake enough to be a puppet for the powers that be.

[fruit_cake]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

Treyc such a nice girl, maybe too nice to survive in the music industry and wish she said how she really felt, maybe signed something not to let her tell the truth. At least Katie is horrible and fake enough to be a puppet for the powers that be.

TreyC's still clinging on to some hope that Simon's going to sign her up.. give it a few months when she realises shes finished and she'll change her tune I reckon

[Novo]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

Treyc such a nice girl, maybe too nice to survive in the music industry and wish she said how she really felt, maybe signed something not to let her tell the truth. At least Katie is horrible and fake enough to be a puppet for the powers that be.

How do you know she is such a nice girl? you have only ever seen her on TV and you hardly get to see what they are like on the X factor and how do you know Katie is so horrible? she can't be that horrible if the people that have got to know her the best - Judges - want to keep her in the competition

[nanaimo]

and how do you know she is nice and not horrible?

[Novo]

Originally Posted by nanaimo

and how do you know she is nice and not horrible?

I never questioned that you did.

[Ammi]

all these conspiracy theories I'm sure thats why Simon wants to keep her in - be much better to let it go and as soon as we all stop talking about her perhaps we'll finally manage to to get rid of Katie Wurzall - at the moment she's the best publicity he's gonna get and its all free!!!!!!!

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by rhino

all these conspiracy theories I'm sure thats why Simon wants to keep her in - be much better to let it go and as soon as we all stop talking about her perhaps we'll finally manage to to get rid of Katie Wurzall - at the moment she's the best publicity he's gonna get and its all free!!!!!!!

lmao, love it!!