[Niamh.]

So, Pacino V's DeNiro has been done a million times but I think it's time Daniel Day Lewis was added to the list. If he wins the Best Actor award in the Oscars this year, he'll make history by being the first actor to have won 3 Best Actor Oscars.

[Marc]

Mr Robert.

[AnnieK]

Pacino for me....but only just

[Josy]

This is as bad as my Morgan vs Samuel thread.

Robert Deniro edges it for me.

[Niamh.]

I would rank them :

Day Lewis > Pacino > Deniro

They're all brilliant though

[Marc]

So basically, the opposite to how the poll is going right now

[Niamh.]

Yeah, pretty much

[Novo]

Only seen Gangs of New York and There will be Blood, both good films but not in the same class as Films like The Godfather, Taxi Driver and Scarface

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Novo

Only seen Gangs of New York and There will be Blood, both good films but not in the same class as Films like The Godfather, Taxi Driver and Scarface

Despite whether or not you prefer a film or not, Day lewis has been outstanding in some some films. My left Foot for example, he was incredible in that even though the film itself wasn't as popular as Gang of New York etc

[Locke.]

Al and DeNiro are both better than him, the only thing he has over them is that he hasn't sold himself out and made loads of terrible movies in the last 10 years or so just for the money.

Good old Al is the best though.

[the truth]

these are the 3 along with nichlson are the greatest living actors , deniro is the best imho , pacino second, day lewis third
all are almost supernaturally gifted actors with extraordinary energy
in real life all 3 are reserved softly spoken shy intelligent men who come alive in front of the camera
whilst its fun to compare it vital to appreciate all their genius
also not to forget the legends who inspired them to start with i.e. bogart, cagney, stewart, dean, clift, lancaster, douglas, brosnon, newman, wayne, mcqueen,burton, lemmon, brando, etc

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by the truth

these are the 3 along with nichlson are the greatest living actors , deniro is the best imho , pacino second, day lewis third
all are almost supernaturally gifted actors with extraordinary energy
in real life all 3 are reserved softly spoken shy intelligent men who come alive in front of the camera
whilst its fun to compare it vital to appreciate all their genius
also not to forget the legends who inspired them to start with i.e. bogart, cagney, stewart, dean, clift, lancaster, douglas, brosnon, newman, wayne, mcqueen,burton, lemmon, brando, etc

Absolutely, I think all three are amazing actors, there isn't much in it at all for me

[Brother Leon]

Al. I'm abit biased though as Scarface is my favourite Movie.

[Stu]

In fairness Daniel Day Lewis probably is a far better actor. But Pacino and De Niro have all the cool characters and movies.

[King Gizzard]

Haven't really watched any of their movies and don't really intend to

[Shaun]

voted DeNiro because Taxi Driver is probably the best acting performance I've seen

[Vanessa]

De Niro for me. But Pacino and Day Lewis are equally brilliant. i can't wait to see Lincoln!

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

De Niro for me. But Pacino and Day Lewis are equally brilliant. i can't wait to see Lincoln!

You voted for Daniel Day Lewis

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

You voted for Daniel Day Lewis

I know. I changed my mind after i voted on the poll.

[the truth]

deniro is miles more prolific, hes made the most great and the most original movies
many of his classics were made in the 70s 80s and 90s though hes still been in a few great films since
hes also got way more movies graded over 8 out of 10 on the worldwide internet movie database than any actor in history
statistically hes made more movies, made more critically acclaimed movies and made more money than these other 3 legends
it underlines how great the other 3 are that this is even a discussion
I would say beyond these 4 alive today only the likes of sean penn and anthony hopkins, maybe harrison ford ,are even in the same ballpark

[Lee.]

Daniel Day Lewis He's my favourite actor of all time. He actually gives me goosebumps

[InOne]

Bob

[Livia]

De Niro for me. He can play any part. The other two take themselves waaay too seriously. I remember watching a programme with Al Pacino called "Looking for Richard" about Shakespeare's Richard III. He did a scene from it and totally over-egged it. Afterwards he asked everyone how they liked it and they were all "Oh you were amazing Mr Pacino..."

[Locke.]

Originally Posted by Livia

De Niro for me. He can play any part. The other two take themselves waaay too seriously. I remember watching a programme with Al Pacino called "Looking for Richard" about Shakespeare's Richard III. He did a scene from it and totally over-egged it. Afterwards he asked everyone how they liked it and they were all "Oh you were amazing Mr Pacino..."

Youtube video

I still can't believe he actually done this

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Livia

De Niro for me. He can play any part. The other two take themselves waaay too seriously. I remember watching a programme with Al Pacino called "Looking for Richard" about Shakespeare's Richard III. He did a scene from it and totally over-egged it. Afterwards he asked everyone how they liked it and they were all "Oh you were amazing Mr Pacino..."

Daniel Day Lewis is pretty serious alright I'd say, he's into that method acting isn't he? He's still an unbelievable actor though, serious or not