[Nicky91]

a game in the style of Great British Bake Off, but then TiBB does Bake Off





okay, i'll need 12 people as contestants, and 2 judges to be our TiBB's Paul and Mary


we'll have 3 challenges each week, a Signature Challenge, a Technical Challenge and a Showstopper

Rules & Points System;

Points System
Signature Challenge
Max Points for Googled Image - 5
Max Points for Designed/Drew - 8
Max Points for Baked - 10
Technical Challenge
Cannot win with Googled Image
Signature Challenge
Max Points for Googled Image - 8
Max Points for Designed/Drew - 15
Max Points for Baked - 20



so is anyone interested in this game

Judges: 2

Nicky91

ProfessorSmooth

Contestants:

ESCArgy

Cal.

Amy Jade

Drew

Jamie89

[Nicky91]

i will be a contestant myself

[Crimson Dynamo]

er how does one bake?

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

er how does one bake?

it works with pictures of cakes/pies/biscuits/breads, of course some can also play for fun


and we'll have 2 judges, who will rank our cakes/pies/biscuits/breads from best to worst

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by Nicky91

it works with pictures of cakes/pies/biscuits/breads, of course some can also play for fun


and we'll have 2 judges, who will rank our cakes/pies/biscuits/breads from best to worst

but its all about the taste

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

but its all about the taste

for example



a cherry cake, looks delicious, but a disappointment that there are no cherry's inside the cake

[Ashley.]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

er how does one bake?

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by Ashley.

Paul wont buy that

come on

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Paul wont buy that

come on

i haven't seen Paul on this forum


we can make our own Bake Off, for fun LT

[ArgyESC]

I'm interested

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by ESCArgy

I'm interested

nice, i'll add you to the list of contestants

[ArgyESC]

Originally Posted by Nicky91

nice, i'll add you to the list of contestants

Wait, I'm not sure if I want to be a contestant or a judge

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by ESCArgy

Wait, I'm not sure if I want to be a contestant or a judge

well if you're a judge you need to know something about cakes and pies and biscuits and breads

[ArgyESC]

Originally Posted by Nicky91

well if you're a judge you need to know something about cakes and pies and biscuits and breads

Okay...

I will be a contestant then

[Jake.]

Originally Posted by Nicky91

well if you're a judge you need to know something about cakes and pies and biscuits and breads

[Nicky91]

i've made up my mind, i'm a Judge

[T*]

It could work if you did it in a better way like the photography competition did where people bake every week or something and take pics of what it looks like and what it looks like as a slice etc. rather than random pics off google

[ArgyESC]

Originally Posted by T*

It could work if you did it in a better way like the photography competition did where people bake every week or something and take pics of what it looks like and what it looks like as a slice etc. rather than random pics off google

We're too bored to bake every week.

[T*]

Originally Posted by ESCArgy

We're too bored to bake every week.

Baking is a boredom buster

[Shaun]

Originally Posted by ESCArgy

We're too bored to bake every week.

maybe don't call it a bake-off then

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by T*

It could work if you did it in a better way like the photography competition did where people bake every week or something and take pics of what it looks like and what it looks like as a slice etc. rather than random pics off google

with some Imagination as well of course, but thank you for your advice

[Jamie89]

Originally Posted by T*

It could work if you did it in a better way like the photography competition did where people bake every week or something and take pics of what it looks like and what it looks like as a slice etc. rather than random pics off google

I agree with this, otherwise wouldn't the winner just be whoever has found the best picture of a cake on google? It could be a lot of fun for people to do something creative and posting pictures of their baking and putting effort into it and getting feedback etc

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Jamie89

I agree with this, otherwise wouldn't the winner just be whoever has found the best picture of a cake on google? It could be a lot of fun for people to do something creative and posting pictures of their baking and putting effort into it and getting feedback etc

well it's more like finding pictures of cakes on google, but also finding a slice of the same cake picture on google


then we can give feedback

[Ammi]

.....hmmmm, maybe it needs some thought of how it's going to work, Nicky and have a definite score plan laid out..?.../so for instance, contestants can only get a potential maximum score for a googled pic but a higher maximum potential one for a 'designed bake' and a higher one again for an actual bake and posting of it..?...multiple choices but with only the potential of an appropriate maximum points attached..?...

[Morgan.]

Originally Posted by Ammi

.....hmmmm, maybe it needs some thought of how it's going to work, Nicky and have a definite score plan laid out..?.../so for instance, contestants can only get a potential maximum score for a googled pic but a higher maximum potential one for a 'designed bake' and a higher one again for an actual bake and posting of it..?...multiple choices but with only the potential of an appropriate maximum points attached..?...

Just came up with this, it could work quite well. The person with the most points that week gets Star Baker, the person with least gets eliminated. It removes any bias people might have to some extent too.

Points System
Signature Challenge
Max Points for Googled Image - 5
Max Points for Designed/Drew - 8
Max Points for Baked - 10
Technical Challenge
Cannot win with Googled Image
Signature Challenge
Max Points for Googled Image - 8
Max Points for Designed/Drew - 15
Max Points for Baked - 20