[Beastie]

Pop Idol V X Factor

Which do you prefer?

I like the X Factor.. but preferred Pop Idol! I preferred the judges back then too!

[MTVN]

Pop Idol

From what I can remember of it anyway

[Stacey.]

The X Factor.

I loved Pop Idol though actually. Nikki and Pete <3

[Jack_]

X Factor. Has lots more elements to it that I like - the categories and Judges' Houses in particular.

[Zippy]

Well Xfactor is like Pop idol but with additional categories. It was too narrow with its agenda....young, attractive and poppy.

I bet it looks cheap now compared to Xfactor too. XF is just bigger and better.

Now America is going from Idol to Xfactor and Im sure theyll welcome the more diverse line up.

[joeysteele]

I liked pop idol but prefer X Factor.