[cub]

Fingers crossed! Gary Barlow would be ideal to take over from Simon Cowell.


X Factor UK
Gary Barlow
Dannii Minogue
Louis Walsh
Cheryl Cole

X Factor US
Simon Cowell
LA Reid
Paula Abdul
Nichole Scherzinger

[Niamh.]

I'd love to see Gary there, he's credible enough to judge people anyway imo

[Smithy]

noooooooooooo I hate him so much

[Ninastar]

Originally Posted by Smithy

noooooooooooo I hate him so much

deep down you love him really

[joeysteele]

I personally don't care much for him but he can write great songs, he is a performer and knows a hit tune so he is better to be on the judging panel than most.

[Locke.]

As long as Cheryl and Louis stay it's all good

[Z]

Credit where credit's due, but he just doesn't really have the personality to be on a judging panel IMO, I hope this isn't true!

[cub]

He's a bit boring and his voice is a bit monotone but I think he would give genuine and constructive feedback. Better than OTT Robbie.

[james130]

He's no Simon.
As long as Dannii's there I don't mind.

[Tom.]

Unless they get a female music executive in then the panel will be a complete joke with 3 performers and 1 manager. And Gary is so boring.

[Judas]

So has Simon quite for good or is this just for the first few weeks?

[cub]

Originally Posted by Tom.

Unless they get a female music executive in then the panel will be a complete joke with 3 performers and 1 manager. And Gary is so boring.

Gary owns his own record label - Future Records.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by cub

Fingers crossed! Gary Barlow would be ideal to take over from Simon Cowell.


X Factor UK
Gary Barlow
Dannii Minogue
Louis Walsh
Cheryl Cole

X Factor US
Simon Cowell
LA Reid
Paula Abdul
Nichole Scherzinger

i thought cheryl cole was leaving x factor uk?

[cub]

^ Those lists were my own personal choices.

No-one knows if Cheryl has the US gig or not. I think it would be a big mistake.

[Princess]

Ain't the auditions in summer? Gary has this little thing called an European tour going on then. Plus all his writing and then his own life,he won't do X Factor.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by cub

^ Those lists were my own personal choices.

No-one knows if Cheryl has the US gig or not. I think it would be a big mistake.

oh ok thanks for saying.

lets hope cheryl cole can **** off,but sadly for us she can only have good single sales when shes performing her songs on the x factor uk,so sadly i think shes staying.

[Tom.]

Originally Posted by cub

Gary owns his own record label - Future Records.

They're going to have trouble hyping him up then, with Aggro Santos as his most successful act

[Judas]

Can't believe this is happening after the affair with Mario Kart... who next, Louis Walsh?

[cub]

Latest line up ...

Gary, Louis, Dannii and Lily Allen. Looks like C. Cole has the US gig, if true. Mistake.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

i thought cheryl cole was leaving x factor uk?

So did most people jf, but it is beginning to appear as if no one else wants her.

[joeysteele]

I hope C Cole is going to be involved in the USA on and as anything if it keeps her away from the UK X Factor, Gary Barlow is a bit boring to listen to when he is talking but at least he will know much more as to the business and real talent.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by cub

Latest line up ...

Gary, Louis, Dannii and Lily Allen.

Nobody with authority. The idea of Louis being like the head judge is just laughable. He's usually the giggling silly one at the end that nobody can hear because the audience are still cheering.

Garys a good guy and knows his stuff...but a bit dull.

[cub]

How about all of Take That as the new panel?

[Smithy]

no

Id shoot myself in the face if that happened

[Princess]

Originally Posted by cub

How about all of Take That as the new panel?

Eh no. Also the entire TT fanbase would turn up for auditions.