[arista]

http://news.sky.com/story/1031525/fr...-rate-for-rich

"French president Francois Hollande has suffered a fresh setback as the country's highest court threw out his plan to tax the ultra-wealthy at a 75% rate, saying it was unfair.
It had been one of the flagship campaign promises of Mr Hollande's election and the government has vowed to resubmit the measure.
But France's Constitutional Council ruled that the way the highly contentious tax was designed was unconstitutional."


http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012...jects-tax-rate
Link for Kizzy



Gérard Depardieu has become the most high-profile opponent of the proposed 75% tax rate, offering to rescind his passport in a row with the government.



Socialism Does not Work.

[Niall]

I suppose that seems a bit steep but if they're the wealthiest of the wealthy then they'll surely have a fair bit of money still lying around to make up for it.

Originally Posted by arista

Socailism Does not Work.

Neither does Capitalism, as shown in the past 6 years.

[Marcus.]

yeah they would

[arista]

Originally Posted by Niall

I suppose that seems a bit steep but if they're the wealthiest of the wealthy then they'll surely have a fair bit of money still lying around to make up for it.



Neither does Capitalism, as shown in the past 6 years.

No it gets Corrected
you are wrong

[Niall]

Originally Posted by arista

No it gets Corrected
you are wrong

Yes of course, a system where the richest prosper at the expense of everyone else is something that's so desirable isn't it?

It will never be corrected. Capitalism is an inherently selfish thing.

Arista is incorrect yet again. It was capitalism that brought the world to it's knees a few short years ago.

The reason this was rejected in the courts, were for anomalies, such as a couple living together, and both earning 900,000euros/yr each would have have avoided this tax, but a single person earning 1.2meuros/yr would have been hit by it.

Just some issues to work out.

[arista]

Originally Posted by Niall

Yes of course, a system where the richest prosper at the expense of everyone else is something that's so desirable isn't it?

It will never be corrected. Capitalism is an inherently selfish thing.

Yes but its the Way of the World
China is the Example
Corrupt Communist Control
but Capitalism keeps them Alive

[arista]

"world to it's knees "

No that was Stupid/Greedy Americans

Originally Posted by arista

Yes but its the Way of the World
China is the Example
Corrupt Communist Control
but Capitalism keeps them Alive

What about the millions of people living in slum shanty towns?

[Niall]

Originally Posted by arista

Yes but its the Way of the World
China is the Example
Corrupt Communist Control
but Capitalism keeps them Alive

You can't say that just because it's the status quo now, that we shouldn't do anything about it.

China is communist in name only. There has never been a true communist state on this planet anyhow. Plus I'm not saying communism is the correct alternative so I don't know why you've brought that up.

The rampant and unfettered capitalism of recent years has served only to line the pockets of the richest, and plunge the world into an abyss of debt. It's clear that the system is toxic in it's current implementation.

[arista]

Originally Posted by Jesus.H.Christ

What about the millions of people living in slum shanty towns?

Yes they got Worse
because of the American bubble of toxic money.



Sign Of The Times.

[arista]

"The rampant and unfettered capitalism of recent years has served only to line the pockets of the richest, and plunge the world into an abyss of debt."

No Not the World

Greece

[Niall]

Originally Posted by arista

"The rampant and unfettered capitalism of recent years has served only to line the pockets of the richest, and plunge the world into an abyss of debt."

No Not the World

Greece

So the trillion pound debt this country is saddled with doesn't come into that at all, does it?

[arista]

Sure its a Circle
so it all comes round.


But we still buy our bread and Milk
Life Goes On.

[MTVN]

A 75% tax isn't really feasible, those who would fall into that bracket would just be persuaded to emigrate, find loopholes and ways around having to pay that much and manage to stay out of it, I doubt it'd really generate any more revenue just like the 50% tax in this country didnt

The greatest period of growth in US history was when their tax rates were 95% on top earners. The problem is, the world has become smaller with modern travel so it's easier to move somewhere else. If other countries were actually willing to tackle the wealth disparity issue with similar tax rates, then it could work, but a lone country like France will always struggle.

[arista]

Originally Posted by MTVN

A 75% tax isn't really feasible, those who would fall into that bracket would just be persuaded to emigrate, find loopholes and ways around having to pay that much and manage to stay out of it, I doubt it'd really generate any more revenue just like the 50% tax in this country didnt

Yes he is a Socialist Fool.