[LukeB]

I mean, he didn't know who had the lowest votes

it's not his fault, people should of voted Paul.

[GypsyGoth]

I'm guessing it's because in the sing off Paul sang better, so Louis should have saved him.

[erinp5]

Originally Posted by LukeB

I mean, he didn't know who had the lowest votes

it's not his fault, people should of voted Paul.

Based on the sing off it was obvious who performed best ....and it wasn't Jay .

[LukeB]

but don't we all have different opinions on things?

[Natalie.]

Paul is better

[mizzy25]

because paul was by far the better singer not only in the sing off but in the competition. Its just a shame that mel gave a soul singer a queen song that's why he was in the bottom 2 and Louis should have not taken it to deadlock going off both sat night even though paul sang the wrong song, he was still by far the better singer sat night and in the sing off!

[Shaun]

because Paul was better in the sing off, and he was wrong to send Paul home from judges' houses last year.

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by mizzy25

because paul was by far the better singer not only in the sing off but in the competition. Its just a shame that mel gave a soul singer a queen song that's why he was in the bottom 2 and Louis should have not taken it to deadlock going off both sat night even though paul sang the wrong song, he was still by far the better singer sat night and in the sing off!

That is yours and their opinions, but Louis doesn't care about anyone else's opinions on the sing off but his own,

IMO, I preffered Jay's

there is not facts on who was better because no one can prove it

[mizzy25]

You asked why everyone is upset with Louis, theres your answer. most people think paul was the better singer.

[Natalie.]

You tell him mizzy

[Liam-]

Originally Posted by Shaun

because Paul was better in the sing off, and he was wrong to send Paul home from judges' houses last year.

He wouldn't have won last year either though, not with the Sam Bailey train at full speed.

[Braden]

Why did you start a thread asking for people's opinions, to then say 'but everyone has different opinions'? Lmao

[Black Dagger]

He's always the scapegoat.

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by LukeB

I mean, he didn't know who had the lowest votes

it's not his fault, people should of voted Paul.

because its a no brainer and Paul should of been saved
Jay is ok but Paul has a better voice
and louis had the chance to save Paul but instead left it to silly deadlock but notice how he still said "im sending paul home" when dermot pushed for an answer
because Louis didn't want to save him

[Vicky.]

Well Louis didnt actually say he preferred Jay...he said he didnt want to make the choice. Judges should make the choice, IMO

[LukeB]

People being angry at Louis seems really ridiculous

[mizzy25]

Originally Posted by LukeB

People being angry at Louis seems really ridiculous

People are angry @ Louis because they feel he cheated Paul out of his plave on the tour.

[hijaxers]

Originally Posted by LukeB

I mean, he didn't know who had the lowest votes

it's not his fault, people should of voted Paul.

Cos he's a dopey old goat !

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by mizzy25

People are angry @ Louis because they feel he cheated Paul out of his plave on the tour.

Still Ridiculous, how they angry, when it's their fault for not voting

[Liam-]

Because Paul sang better and is obviously a better singer than Jay and Louis should have sent Jay home straight out.

[LukeB]

tbf both of them brought nothing to the show

[sassysocks]

Originally Posted by LukeB

People being angry at Louis seems really ridiculous

Nope - the judges continuously tell us that they will vote for who sings best in the sing off. Paul as usual was absolutley brilliant and out-sung Jay with ease.

Louis was judging Paul on appearance rather than singing ability. He is an old superfial idiot who deserves to be judged on his appearance rather than his experience in the music industry - complete waste of space.

Besides I think Paul is a good-looking guy with a very cute smile. He knocks spots off dowdy old Louis in every way.

I really hope this is not the last we see of Paul. I have looked forward to hearing his lovely soulful voice every week and will really miss him. I would buy his cds without hesitation. If I continue to watch the show, it will only be to see how well Andrea does. It has lost its sparkle for me.

[joeysteele]

I would have done the same as Louis and taken it to deadlock. In fact I really just don't know why the lines are not closed at the start of the results show,do the results,have the sing off with the bottom 2.
then re-open the lines for those 2 acts and do the show as usual with its guests.
Closing the lines in the last 5 minutes and announcing who got the least votes from the public after the sing off and that's that.

None of this with the judges, where usually 2 of them are going to vote for their own act obviously anyway.

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I would have done the same as Louis and taken it to deadlock. In fact I really just don't know why the lines are not closed at the start of the results show,do the results,have the sing off with the bottom 2.
then re-open the lines for those 2 acts and do the show as usual with its guests.
Closing the lines in the last 5 minutes and announcing who got the least votes from the public after the sing off and that's that.

None of this with the judges, where usually 2 of them are going to vote for their own act obviously anyway.

Would be a good way of doing it Joey.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Cherie

Would be a good way of doing it Joey.

Thank you Cherie, I just think the public should decide it all anyway,the only other way would be to have 4 other independent guests voting who went after the sing off and not the judges/mentors at all.

I however prefer the public to really,I mean the act who was 2nd last could have loads more votes than who actually got the least.
The public are paying to vote so let them decide the whole thing.