[TomC]

Not necessarily my top 20 returnee choices but it's like half realistic, and a cast I'd be excited to watch!

HEROES
Hayden Moss, Blood vs Water, 6th place. Let's be real, we all loved him and want to watch him again!
Mike Holloway, Worlds Apart, Winner. Probably the most heroic winner since HvV.
Tai Trang, Kaoh Rong, 3rd place, Game Changers, 4th place. A unique archetype!
Christian Hubicki, David vs Goliath, 7th place. Not a fan personally, but like he is definitely returning given the opportunity.
Davie Rickenbacker, David vs Goliath, 6th place.
Jerri Manthey, Australian Outback, 8th place, All-Stars, 9th place, Heroes vs Villains, 4th place. I NEED her to come back as a hero and win! It adds a nice bit of continuity between old-school and new-school.
Trish Hegarty, Cagayan, 5th place. She would add spice to the Heroes tribe!
Cydney Gillon, Kaoh Rong, 4th place.
Chrissy Hoffbeck, Heroes vs Healers vs Hustlers, Runner Up. Perhaps a tenuous hero, but she was robbed, and deserves a second chance.
Alison Raybould, David vs Goliath, 5th place. Every returnee season needs at least one wtf choice, and Alison is it for HvV2! She was effortlessly heroic in DvG, and I'd love to see her again.

VILLAINS
Tony Vlachos, Cagayan, Winner, Game Changers, 19th place. Probably the most obvious choice of all, and he needs redemption after GC.
Kyle Jason, Kaoh Rong, 6th place. Great villain!
Jay Starrett, Millennials vs Gen-X, 6th place. Another one I think would be a fantastic choice as a villain.
Chris Noble, Ghost Island, 13th place. Despite GI being such a terrible season, Chris was an amazing (and beautiful) panto villain.
Domenick Abbate, Ghost Island, Runner Up. Literally so that Chris can get his revenge.
Abi-Maria Gomes, Phillipines, 5th place, Cambodia, 7th place. Villainous queen!
Kass McQuillen, Cagayan, 3rd place, Cambodia, 13th place. Another shoe-in villainess.
Natalie Anderson, San Juan Del Sur, Winner. Literally this season's Sandra.
Carolyn Rivera, Worlds Apart, Runner Up. An UTR but I loved ha and she was such a hard-faced cow
Angelina Keeley, David vs Goliath, 3rd place. I am literally 99% sure we will see her on the next returnee season.