Quote:
Originally posted by GiRTh
Quote:
Originally posted by Matt10kTrue, but I think music is more subjective than football (in my opinion anyway) and talent in music is more based around opinion and less around fact as it would be in football.
And just having a good voice isn’t good enough for me. She may be able to sing but I don’t like her style of singing at all or the songs themselves. So basically, I can understand why other people would like her, but it's just not my thing.
|
Talent is a subjective thing no matter what we're talking about but, you know it when you see it. However, in order to see it you have to know what you're looking for in the first is place. Her four or five octave range is the thing that sets aside from the rest. That's raw talent.
I dont like her music either but I have to concede she is able to do things with her voice that others will never be able to do. Thats talent.
|
But I think talent is less about opinion and more about fact when looking at it in sport such as football. It's like if a guy won the 100m 5 times at the olympics, he's talented without question! If an artist wins 5 brit awards, a lot of people might still think they're crap and they wouldn't sound stupid for saying it.
If someone said the guy that won gold 5 times at the olympics was "crap" that would be pretty stupid so do you see what I mean?
Talent IS subjective in all things, but more so in certain areas, music being one of those areas...
28-02-2008, 12:19 PM
Threaded Mode