[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Ammi

…I thought this was all known already …that none of this is any new development but that there are and have always been complexities in the specific case of Imane….that she has a genetic condition that impacted her sexual development pre birth and was then assigned female at birth…and she was soicialised, raised etc as a female…anyways I have nothing else to add atm as I don’t feel this article is revealing anything that wasn’t already known and I also don’t feel that it’s a ‘good faith’ article and very slanted in its vein as it comments on Imane’s journey and having his journey despite being fully aware that he was genetically male…him/he/his is not for me atm an informative article and really shabby as this someone who was assigned a female at birth by the medical profession and that was how she was raised…and whatever her sexual development/specific condition etc…what she is and knows is female…


…the combat competitive sporting aspect for me is another aspect to be discussed…

This is and should be all that matters in this particular case. Women's safety should be the number 1 priority followed by women's right to fair play in sport.