Quote:
Originally posted by jimdan
Quote:
Originally posted by BB22
Quote:
Originally posted by jimdan
Gobblygook!
Noirin knew she was sitting in the lions den when she sat with Siavash, Freddie and Marcus...it was foreign territory. She has been nominating Siavash and Freddie for weeks, so they were no friends of Noirin. Freddie had also nominated Noirin. Their scheming plan to get Noirin onside had been brewing all week with comments from Marcus and Freddie about getting Noirin to settle into a single group (theirs!).
When Siavash (prompted by Freddie) released his bit of slander, she saw red...and quite rightly so. Any girl would be hurt to find out that her friends were talking behind her back.
After that conversation it was 2hrs later and after further remarks from Siavash, also intended to get Noirin to join their group because they are **** scared of being nominated again. Noirin owed them nothing...
Noirin was not the one to a) name Karly/Kris not b) say who said it (Siavash).
Siavash himself did that when he entered the bedroom and then lied again in front of everyone. Noirin was defending her name and to berate her for trying to resolve the issue is just plain inhuman.
Put yourself in Noirin's shoes for a minute.
|
I repeat the simple unassailable point that Noirin directly and openly promised Siavash that she would not repeat their conversation, prior to Siavash speaking.
Then she did exactly that.
That is all.
|
Hardly an unassailable point when Noirin did what was asked and did not "repeat" the conversation.
She simply asked the other group if anyone had called her a rabbit and refused to state who said it and also who it was said about. Noirin didn't break her word, it was Siavash who entered the bedroom and told all.
|
Oh dear. With respect, I think you are playing a semantic game with the word "repeat" in order to provide Noirin with a legalistic technical get-out.
It is quite plain from viewing what happened that she broke her promise to Siavash, a fact which really does remain unassailable.
10-07-2009, 09:23 AM
Reply With Quote
Threaded Mode