[Stu]

Originally Posted by Tom

I'm sorry but what utter bollocks. Using that thinking means the likes of Amy Winehouse is a complete failure.

As you said later in the post there are other things to consider- huge album sales but poor singles doesn't doesn't equal one hit wonder. Far from it.

And I never had a strict definition. You've got selected reading where the definition I did give is concerned anyway.

Pink Floyd's career is over and thus is subject to overall critical and commercial evaluation. The same can't be said for Amy Winehouse.

Huge album sales but poor singles doesn't doesn't equal one hit wonder. Far from it. Your right. That was my only point. That you have to use some common sense and rational thinking to judge a one hit wonder. In which case The Bloodhound Gang are certainly not one hit wonders, which is what you said.