[Calderyon]

What would be your suggestion of they should have done the picking then?

Personally i think they should have first done paper, rock, scissors a few times (the one who gets first right gets first pick, then the other two face off and the one who gets the second right gets the second pick. The loser gets to pick third), to get the order of picking and then after that go in turn on picking who they want to keep in the jury.The one who is left last is the one who is evicted from the jury.