[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Soldier Boy

No you don't and you'll see that I predicted that you wouldn't - because you can't.

So instead I'll just describe what I saw and you can tell me that I'm wrong (or not, as you say you don't have to do anything).

1) Liam posted a video of someone suggesting/advocating/threatening/perhaps promising(?) genocide of a civilian population as an inevitability.

2) You called him antisemitic, because the person in that video happened to be Jewish.

3) It was suggested that you couldn't justify that remark

4) You incredulously refused to justify the remark, with a silly air of "I could if I wanted to but I don't so there".


Have I missed the mark?

As a note to mods: I would suggest that dropping an accusation of antisemitism (and yes, you could apply this to any other -ism or -phobe) without any attempt whatsoever to justify the reasoning for saying it (I'm not advocating a ban on saying it, just that people show their working, so to speak) should be considered a baseless personal insult and thus a violation of forum rules. Just a thought.

After I don't know how many times now and over years too as to myself.

Your last paragraph is one I endorse 100%
Absolutely.

Plus I saw nothing at all to justify terming what Liam posted as of anything remotely antisemitic
It's become an easy accusation to throw out however it is an inflammatory, incitive and dangerous accusation to make