[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by kazanne

Ok,so Gamu is gone,i doubt many people will lose sleep over it,but they can still express their disappointment afterall this IS a forum,imo Gamu was far better than Cher or Katie and one thing it has done is highlight Cheryls inability to spot talent,So,Gamu did not dress as a tramp or a chav,she didn't cake herself in makeup(which is what some people seem to love!!)and she didn't fluff her lines or break down,but it is as plain as the nose on your face,she is a far superior singer than the other two,as for her stage presence that could have been worked on(if needed)she wasn't given a chance so we will not know what she was capable of instead we have two girls who frankly are dire,Katie does have the edge on Cher,most of us know why she was put through,lol.

The voice of reason,thank you kazanne,this is a great post.I ahve made my points near all day yesterday and while I would have likely put Gamu through,the fact she wasn't for the other 2 was my main moan.
I would have likely put any of the other 4 through over 2 girls who not only didn't sing,remember the words or perform or show any stage presence at all.

As I said though, kazanne you have made the point very effectively.