[Tom]

I think its quite funny that Cheryl is a trained dancer in a few fields who can't sing but shes judging a singing competition whilst Alesha is a singer by trade and her only dancing experience is a dancing show/the odd choreographed routine and shes judging a dancing competition

I don't think Alesha would have got the stick she got if she didn't replace Arlene but was just added as a 5th judge

[Z]

Originally Posted by Tom

I think its quite funny that Cheryl is a trained dancer in a few fields who can't sing but shes judging a singing competition whilst Alesha is a singer by trade and her only dancing experience is a dancing show/the odd choreographed routine and shes judging a dancing competition

I don't think Alesha would have got the stick she got if she didn't replace Arlene but was just added as a 5th judge

Good point, they should really be in reversed roles... and yeah, Alesha only got stick because she replaced Arlene, I agree; if she'd just been added to the panel then she'd have been welcomed with open arms I think.