[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Vixen

Yeah thats a bit of as stupid reason.

I do think the singoff was planned now though, once the rage has gone. However I think it was planned as a safety net for cher, so that they could make sure she was in the final. Since she had been bottom before and obviously wasnt as popular as they originally thought.

I agree they wanted a get out clause in case certain contestants came bottom. But until we know for sure that Cher got least votes then nobody can say it was an unfair outcome.

and they did both get least votes so the public did have a large say up to a point. Both have been bottom two recently so they were equally un/deserving really.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Zippy

I agree they wanted a get out clause in case certain contestants came bottom. But until we know for sure that Cher got least votes then nobody can say it was an unfair outcome.

and they did both get least votes so the public did have a large say up to a point. Both have been bottom two recently so they were equally un/deserving really.

IK but I disagree with the judges putting one handpicked contestant in the final...no matter who it is. This years fixing has been so blatant.

Yeah, in a way the public are getting a say by being able to pick the bottom two...however, at this stage its ridiculous for the judges still to be able to overrule the public. I would imagine more people vote in the semi final than in the earlier shows...and it just makes it all kinda pointless.

Mary could have got say 1m votes.
Cher got 500k.
Rebecca Matt and OD 1.01m each.

IK this is very unlikely but its an example...why should cher go through on her 500k votes just because the judges lick her ass? When Mary was so close to the other finalists?

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Zippy

I agree they wanted a get out clause in case certain contestants came bottom. But until we know for sure that Cher got least votes then nobody can say it was an unfair outcome.

and they did both get least votes so the public did have a large say up to a point. Both have been bottom two recently so they were equally un/deserving really.

well it is taking the piss out of all the Mary fans who voted though, she may not have won the show but she would have been in the final (assuming she had more votes that is)