[Jake.]

Originally Posted by Salman!

I don't give a rat's arse whether or not an X Factor act gets the xmas #1. That doesn't mean anything.

In terms of the music industry in general though, Alexandra Burke/JLS/One Direction/Olly Murs/Little Mix etc have poisoned the charts but who is more to blame are the likes of will.i.am/Lady GaGa/Pitbull/Flo Rida/David Guetta/RedOne.

Agreed apart from Gaga, I personally respect her because everything she writes is her own and she has a naturally good talent.

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by JingleHorse95

Agreed apart from Gaga, I personally respect her because everything she writes is her own and she has a naturally good talent.

Yeah I agree about GaGa, I wouldn't say I was a fan necessarily but she is a talented woman no doubt

[Jake.]

Originally Posted by Christmas Neeve

Yeah I agree about GaGa, I wouldn't say I was a fan necessarily but she is a talented woman no doubt

Yes pretty much the same, I respect her talents more than anything. Her singing Speechless live a few years back at the royal variety made me realise that she is naturally good at what she does.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by JingleHorse95

Agreed apart from Gaga, I personally respect her because everything she writes is her own and she has a naturally good talent.

She has a good voice and that's about it. Bad Romance, Edge of Glory, Marry The Night = utter tripe. She tries to be unique and artistic but comes across as a freak I mean what the **** is Judas?

I'm no Madonna fan but it makes me cackle when people say Lady GaGa is better than her. As Jack White rightly pointed out she's all image with no meaning.

[ChristmasNeeve]

Originally Posted by Salman!

She has a good voice and that's about it. Bad Romance, Edge of Glory, Marry The Night = utter tripe. She tries to be unique and artistic but comes across as a freak I mean what the **** is Judas?

I'm no Madonna fan but it makes me cackle when people say Lady GaGa is better than her. As Jack White rightly pointed out she's all image with no meaning.

She's a song writer and a musician which is two up on Madonna already tbf