[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by Livia

I was using that as a "for instance" for a "one punch sentence" as I think you know. You don't know whether the force used was proportional, nor whether it was a spur of the moment action, nor what the man who was punched said... in fact, you know as little about the case as I do. All you do know is what you've read today. The legal teams on both sides would have had access to all kinds of information that you're just guessing at.

I agree decent people don't go around punching people, but I am telling you what the law says. There's no point in arguing with me over that. Like I said before, the legal system isn't perfect but it's the best we've got.

We do know it was not proportional because we can see it clear as day on the CCTV.
Of course I don't livia what a silly thing to say I'm just commenting on this as unusually we can actually see the attack as it happened, I'm just passing comment on the event as I see it ok?
In my opinion as a member of the public I don't agree with the explanation as given for this case is all.