[rusticgal]

Well I hope that Helen and Ash get punished severely for discussing nominations and suggesting Ashleigh should go up as she was loudly booed....

This is a serious infringement of discussing and influencing other HM's on nominations.

[Verbal]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

Well I hope that Helen and Ash get punished severely for discussing nominations and suggesting Ashleigh should go up as she was loudly booed....

This is a serious infringement of discussing and influencing other HM's on nominations.

Is that against the rules this year? It's all they all ever talk about.

[Josy]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

Well I hope that Helen and Ash get punished severely for discussing nominations and suggesting Ashleigh should go up as she was loudly booed....

This is a serious infringement of discussing and influencing other HM's on nominations.

How were they discussing noms?

They were using that as an example of what would happened had the boys got the power..

[rusticgal]

Originally Posted by Josy

How were they discussing noms?

They were using that as an example of what would happened had the boys got the power..

I realise they are discussing a pre-meditated situation but in doing so they are influencing people to nominate Ashleigh because she got the loudest boos...albeit in a situation where the boys will have to do what the girls did last week.
Last week the girls had the power to discuss the boys and their reasons for remaining nominated or being saved. They discussed it amongst the other power housemates only....they were not allowed to discuss it with the boys and they didn't.
The boys are thinking they will have the power this week and blatantly discussing reasons why or why not Ashleigh should go up since she had been booed.... It is obvious who Helen and Ash are going to put up and they want Ashleigh nominated. Now had Stevens name been chanted and booed they would have been telling Winston...he will go if he is up so we need save him... Now that is influencing nominations.... The boys DONT have the power, they shouldn't have had that discussion but they did and Helen and Ash were IMO giving their reasons for Ashleigh to face the public vote and therefore influencing other housemates to nominate in order to save others that they don't want to go.

[Josy]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

I realise they are discussing a pre-meditated situation but in doing so they are influencing people to nominate Ashleigh because she got the loudest boos...albeit in a situation where the boys will have to do what the girls did last week.
Last week the girls had the power to discuss the boys and their reasons for remaining nominated or being saved. They discussed it amongst the other power housemates only....they were not allowed to discuss it with the boys and they didn't.
The boys are thinking they will have the power this week and blatantly discussing reasons why or why not Ashleigh should go up since she had been booed.... It is obvious who Helen and Ash are going to put up and they want Ashleigh nominated. Now had Stevens name been chanted and booed they would have been telling Winston...he will go if he is up so we need save him... Now that is influencing nominations.... The boys DONT have the power, they shouldn't have had that discussion but they did and Helen and Ash were IMO giving their reasons for Ashleigh to face the public vote and therefore influencing other housemates to nominate in order to save others that they don't want to go.

Fair enough.

I don't see as that though I see it as Winston being a but pissed off at the girls automatically assuming he was safe and them trying to explain that reason to him.

[rusticgal]

Originally Posted by Josy

Fair enough.

I don't see as that though I see it as Winston being a but pissed off at the girls automatically assuming he was safe and them trying to explain that reason to him.

Yes that was the case Josy...but it's what Ash and Helen went on to say after that which was IMO opinion influencing with a reason to nominate Ashleigh regarding the chants.
It was a random discussion and Bb should have interrupted the discussion with a reminder because of the way the conversation progressed.