[Nancy.]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Well this is where you make yourself look idiotic. She clearly has vocal talent where Madonna never has done. Madonna's career at no point was ever due to her (flat as a pancake) voice.

I've only really liked some of her recent stuff when it comes to Gaga's music rather than the stuff so many would call her "peak", but to deny her talent just makes you look silly.

I could say something nasty here but i'm not going to. (don't want an infraction).

So now i'm being "idiotic" because I don't share the same views as you about her voice? Typical little monster reaction. I don't like her voice, that's my opinion. Big deal. To me, the only talent Gags has is wearing hideous costumes, ripping off others, telling porkies and tweeting every hour or so. If it wasn't for those costumes she wouldn't have lasted as long as she had. Without those she's just another Gwen Stefani/Christina Aguilera clone. The fact that her recent music flopped spectacularly after she ditched her weird outfits speaks volumes. No one's interested and they haven't really been interested since 2011. She needs to let it go and stop flogging that dead horse. She's over, finished...k'put. The superbowl won't do bugger all for her sales either. Poor thing. Must stink knowing she's over at the grand old age of 30.

As for Madonna, well, I hardly think Andrew Loyd Webber, Tim Rice and Alan Parker would've agree'd to let Madonna play Eva Peron in Evita if she didn't have any vocal talent.
I'm also going to remind you that Madonna's sold 300+ million records, and she's just extended her previous record as the highest grossing touring artist in the world. Not bad for someone who "can't sing" and is up there with the best selling legendary artists ever eh?