[DemolitionRed]

Originally Posted by Liberty4eva

My question is this and I'll put it in bold so you can't miss it:
If, for decades, the official number of dead in Auschwitz was 4 million but then, one day, that number was reduced to 1.5 million, how can the total number of 6 million remain unchanged and, moreover, how can we be confident that the 6 million figure is accurate?

To my knowledge there is no answer to this question. But if you can muster a sensible answer I will seriously consider changing my views on this subject. A reasonable thinking person will ponder this question (or some variation of it) but very few will dare ask it because that invites all sorts of accusations that they are a "Nazi-sympathizer" or a "Denier". I am a free-thinking person and I couldn't care less what people on here think of me so I am not afraid to ask it.

Nobody is denying the numbers gassed or who perished from starvation and disease in Auschwitz haven't changed. But it wasn't just the change of a plaque on a wall. There were huge amounts of research done before that plaque was corrected.

The original numbers came from the Soviets and were accepted at the Nuremberg trials in 1945. It was though, acknowledged in 1989 by the intense works of both Yehuda Bauer (Israeli Holocaust historian), Israel's Yad Vashem Holocaust Center and 1990 the Auschwitz State Museum, that the correct numbers must be declared to the public.

Let's also remember that Auschwitz was only one of 15,000 labor, death, and concentration camp built by the Nazis.

[MTVN]

Yes that was an initial Soviet estimate which they inflated for their own purposes (as they did frequently), it was not particularly scientific and historians have realised it was not the true figure since long before the plaque was changed.

If that is the most suspect thing you can put forward then it is not a particularly strong basis to question the whole history of the Holocaust.

[user104658]

Originally Posted by Liberty4eva

My question is this and I'll put it in bold so you can't miss it:
If, for decades, the official number of dead in Auschwitz was 4 million but then, one day, that number was reduced to 1.5 million, how can the total number of 6 million remain unchanged and, moreover, how can we be confident that the 6 million figure is accurate?

Originally Posted by DemolitionRed

Let's also remember that Auschwitz was only one of 15,000 labor, death, and concentration camp built by the Nazis.

There's your answer good chap.

There were thousands of Nazi death camps where prisoners were held and killed, and the 6 million total figure was calculated completely separately to the original four million Auschwitz estimate, not by "adding up known totals for each camp".

In simple terms;

- They were confident in the total estimate of 6 million total, based on the population before and after the holocaust.

- They estimated 4 million at Auschwitz and 2 million elsewhere.

- Thorough examination revealed a more accurate figure of 1.5 million for Auschwitz.

- They are STILL confident in the 6 million total figure, the only difference is that 4.5 million must have been elsewhere, not 2 million. Which really makes more sense (2/3 killed in one location seems unlikely).




You need to stop reading Nazi / holocaust denial propaganda sites, there are clearly some perfectly simple explanations for your "great mysteries". It's like the argument that there's evidence that not as many were gassed as thought, like the fact that they were shot or executed by various other means is some sort of important revelation. Exactly where they were held, and how they were killed, is not really the most relevant detail, and questioning those things isn't holocaust denial. Attempting to revise down the total death toll - or claim that it didn't happen at all - is a completely different story and --- most importantly --- has completely different motivations.