[Shaun]

Interesting move, I imagine she's attributed it to Bowie/Grace Jone's androgyny.

[Shaun]

PLUS she looks kinda like a young Bob Dylan in those pics:

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Shaun

PLUS she looks kinda like a young Bob Dylan in those pics:

:O
She does

I think that's her real hair too :/

[Stacey.]

I thought she was a man in them next photos

[M X]

I don't have a favourite, I'll love her to death no matter what.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Old Gaga
Alejandro video put me off her

[Stacey.]

Harry stop being annoying

[Harry!]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

Harry stop being annoying

I speak for all the Madonna fans who are fed up of this.

[Jase.]

The ignorance of some people in this thread is actually making me laugh out loud. Wow.

[Braden]

Older, I think she's losing a big spark. Imo reently she's trying to copy Madonna and Grace Jones with her weirdness. But when she was her old self , it was much more individual.

[Harry!]

Originally Posted by Smithy

There is no homework to do it's all opinion

Ok, in what sense will Madonna be better than GaGa?

GaGa is an amazing song writer, writes all her own songs
She has the better vocals
She has directorial input into every video she makes

The only thing you have is that she's had more number 1's and sold more records, well yes, she's been around 15 times longer

So therefore imo, GaGa > Mandonna

I think the fact that she has been in the industry for 30 years and still going strong is more then enough an explanation.

And a entry in the Guiness Book Of Records 2011 astge Top-Selling Female Recording Artist justifys my point further.

Originally Posted by MichaelSpears

Stop saying 'teens like you'. Lady Gaga has fans of all ages.
and to be honest, i don't have anything against Madonna, but showing your unkept vagina in a sleezy book for money and publicity isn't anything special.
and fyi, that telephone hat was created by Philip Tracey, one of the most respected designers of all time, and i'm sure has worked with Madonna before.

At the time of the Sex book it was still tabbo to pose nude like that. If Lady Gaga was to do a book like that many wouldnt blink an eye to be honest. Becasue of Madonna more people are expressing themselves scuse the pun.

A telephone on a hat doesnt ring as many bells as inative as Madonna's work.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Harry!

I think the fact that she has been in the industry for 30 years and still going strong is more then enough an explanation.

And a entry in the Guiness Book Of Records 2011 astge Top-Selling Female Recording Artist justifys my point further.

See thats all you ever answer with, the length she's been in the business, nothing about her skills, vocal ability or talents, oh wait....

[M X]

Originally Posted by Harry!

At the time of the Sex book it was still tabbo to pose nude like that. If Lady Gaga was to do a book like that many wouldnt blink an eye to be honest. Becasue of Madonna more people are expressing themselves scuse the pun.

A telephone on a hat doesnt ring as many bells as inative as Madonna's work.

Erm, no. At the time of the 'Sex' book, Playboy had been around for many years. And also, Madonna has admitted that she has no idea why she did that book and that when she looks back on it, it isn't artistic.

And to be honest, the spoiler in your sig is pathetic. To say that Lady Gaga is untalented is complete ignorance. Even if I wasn't a fan you have to be able to admit she is talented. You can't accuse her of being a Madonna wannabe. She's said before - 'I'm not going to be the second Madonna, I'm going to be the first Lady Gaga.'

Madonna is talented, no doubt. But maybe your upset because as Madonna's star is beginning to fade, Lady Gaga's is on the rise?

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by MichaelSpears

Madonna is talented, no doubt. But maybe your upset because as Madonna's star is beginning to fade, Lady Gaga's is on the rise?

Obviously :P

[Harry!]

Originally Posted by MichaelSpears

Erm, no. At the time of the 'Sex' book, Playboy had been around for many years. And also, Madonna has admitted that she has no idea why she did that book and that when she looks back on it, it isn't artistic.

And to be honest, the spoiler in your sig is pathetic. To say that Lady Gaga is untalented is complete ignorance. Even if I wasn't a fan you have to be able to admit she is talented. You can't accuse her of being a Madonna wannabe. She's said before - 'I'm not going to be the second Madonna, I'm going to be the first Lady Gaga.'

Madonna is talented, no doubt. But maybe your upset because as Madonna's star is beginning to fade, Lady Gaga's is on the rise?

The sex book is 'art' but at its most vulger form.

MY picture in my sig is there because of Smithy and a row we had a few days back. It was the only picture I could find on google which as a ''comeback'' to picture gate. Not what I personally think of her.

I admit and have said this countless times Lady Gaga IS talented - does se use her 'talent' well is the question.

You said ''Madonna's star is beginning to fade'' which is completely incorrect, The only reason why she is not in the papers as much this year is because she is directing her latest film which fills most of her time up and has little time for recording new music. She will at some point over the next year or so release another album and possibly go back on tour again once she has finished her film.

How long is Lady Gaga's star going to shine is the question you need to ask.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Harry!

I admit and have said this countless times Lady Gaga IS talented - does she use her 'talent' well is the question.

Yes she writes music everyday, is currently touring the US singing live near enough every night and is trained in classical piano (which she plays on the tour)

[Jase.]

Harry, quit being an ignorant child. All GaGa fans are "teenagers"? If you're going to be ignorant, come out with something which at least sounds believable.

The fact remains she's the biggest pop star on the planet right now. She's pushing boundaries with her music and fashion. As Mika said, she has given every female pop star who is currently relevant an identity crisis.

I just find it so embarrassing how fans of one major artist can appreciate what another artist is doing. So...embarrassing.

[Scarlett.]

Old Gaga, the Alehandrawn video was a long drawn out nonsensical pile of self indulgent trash

Saying that, I like her new music more than her old (bar Poker Face, Paparazzi and Just Dance)

[Tom]

I think this is her best song (well one shes featured on, its not actually hers). Shes really normal in it and suits that style IMO.

Youtube video

She just looks like a bad drag queen now

[BB_Eye]

I just wish her dull and ordinary music was half as 'crazy' as her outfits.

[Sophii3x]

I REALLY miss the early Gaga (late 08/early 09). Her style was far better, she looked great and acted normal.. fame clearly changed her. She's acts and dresses ridiculous now, attention *****.

[Smithy]

Well you cant see her on the radio harry

[Harry!]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Well you cant see her on the radio harry

Thank god for that. Saying that I dont listen to the radio and have to have it off when I am in a car because it annoys me.

[iRyan]

I miss the old Gaga from the Just Dance/Poker Face/Love Game era. She actually looked hot and she had this young, fresh, energetic appeal. Now she looks like a 40 year old wacky fashion designer.

[Smithy]

She's back





Last time i'll bump I promise :L