[Stu]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

She really charmed the execs lol that is brill Chavryl has about as much charm as a fuken millipede

[Zippy]

Just heard this story repeated on Viva news. Also, Nicole denying she will ever be joining Xfactor.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Just heard this story repeated on Viva news. Also, Nicole denying she will ever be joining Xfactor.

She hasn't actually denied it, shes just said that she'll have to give it a long think (if offered) because of her workload. I doubt she'll join the British panel but it would be nice to have her involved in some capacity, she could be to Louis what Sinitta is to Simon at judges houses

[Marsh.]

I thought US producers were being persistant about getting an American woman for the job like Paula Abdul. Cheryl's gonna be like Vernon Kay's presenting job, gonna get panned for the accent. And Cheryl trying to talk the Queen's english to be understood would be funny though.

If it's true though they're gonna have to get a megastar as another judge on the panel because with Simon, Cheryl and another nobody the show's gonna fall flat on its face.

If both Simon and Cheryl are missing next year and as I predict Dannii quits to go back to Australia then it's gonna be little old Louis left behind. lol

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by 08marsh

I thought US producers were being persistant about getting an American woman for the job like Paula Abdul. Cheryl's gonna be like Vernon Kay's presenting job, gonna get panned for the accent. And Cheryl trying to talk the Queen's english to be understood would be funny though.

If it's true though they're gonna have to get a megastar as another judge on the panel because with Simon, Cheryl and another nobody the show's gonna fall flat on its face.

If both Simon and Cheryl are missing next year and as I predict Dannii quits to go back to Australia then it's gonna be little old Louis left behind. lol

Well I think Paula abdul and another famous US star would make up the four judge panel. That would make Cheryl the only relative unknown so could work.

And Dannii divides her time between UK and Australia anyways as her husband/BF is English but she also does Australia's got talent. So the UK gig suits her just fine. I doubt she'd quit.

[Callum]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Well I think Paula abdul and another famous US star would make up the four judge panel. That would make Cheryl the only relative unknown so could work.

And Dannii divides her time between UK and Australia anyways as her husband/BF is English but she also does Australia's got talent. So the UK gig suits her just fine. I doubt she'd quit.

Paula Abdul is part of America's version of "Got to Dance" and therefore would be unable to judge both. I think she would be great but it's looking more likely that Nicole or Mariah will make up the second female judge role.

[Tom4784]

I won't believe anything until it comes out of Simon's mouth. I'd be surprised if she did it as apparently one of the stipulations with Brian Friedman's US contract is that he can't work on the UK one simultaneously meaning if it's a similar contract Cheryl would have to give up the UK version. Then again I'd imagine Simon would get her a deal without that stipulation like I'm guessing he'll have.

She'd be foolish to abandon the UK X Factor completely as it'll pretty much guarantee her constant success as the UK is a lot easily conquered then the US so I'm guessing she'll do both if this is true.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Prezzie

I won't believe anything until it comes out of Simon's mouth. I'd be surprised if she did it as apparently one of the stipulations with Brian Friedman's US contract is that he can't work on the UK one simultaneously meaning if it's a similar contract Cheryl would have to give up the UK version. Then again I'd imagine Simon would get her a deal without that stipulation like I'm guessing he'll have.

She'd be foolish to abandon the UK X Factor completely as it'll pretty much guarantee her constant success as the UK is a lot easily conquered then the US so I'm guessing she'll do both if this is true.

X Factor USA is airing on ITV2- Simon can pull the right strings to have it airing simultaneously with our X Factor and there is nothing stopping Cheryl doing a guest performance on ours, that would continue her success without physically being on our show

[Legend killer]

lol the Cheryl hate is brilliant on this thread long may it continue

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

lol the Cheryl hate is brilliant on this thread long may it continue

just the same usual haters like your sad sap self.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Zippy

just the same usual haters like your sad sap self.

i think you will find her hate is growing more and more.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

i think you will find her hate is growing more and more.

You'd know about growing hate.....being a Jedward fan.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Zippy

You'd know about growing hate.....being a Jedward fan.

ouch your getting katty zippy.

its ok at least jedward dont get all the help off simon like cheryl does.

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

lol the Cheryl hate is brilliant on this thread long may it continue

You're more obsessed with her then her fans.

[Legend killer]

Originally Posted by Prezzie

You're more obsessed with her then her fans.

Everywhere i post your there!!!

I think your as obsessed with me as Zippy is

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

Everywhere i post your there!!!

I think your as obsessed with me as Zippy is

It's because everywhere i look you're posting about how you hate Cheryl yet you can't stop talking about her. I hate Peter Andre yet I'm not creating a new thread about him every five minutes.

[Legend killer]

Originally Posted by Prezzie

It's because everywhere i look you're posting about how you hate Cheryl yet you can't stop talking about her. I hate Peter Andre yet I'm not creating a new thread about him every five minutes.

Well it would be a bit pointless as it is an X-factor forum.

If i want to make a Cheryl hate thread why shouldn't i if you don't like it just don't read my thread/ comments SIMPLE!!! Or better still just put me on ignore , either that or just stop your whinging

[Legend killer]

Jedward ur avatar is brill lol

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Legend killer

Jedward ur avatar is brill lol

thank you.

[Marsh.]

Dannii's not going to the US one so could a return from Mrs O be on the cards? Or not do you think?

[Callum]

Originally Posted by 08marsh

Dannii's not going to the US one so could a return from Mrs O be on the cards? Or not do you think?

Are you being serious? Dannii would never even question staying if Sharon came back

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Callum

Are you being serious? Dannii would never even question staying if Sharon came back

I'm talking about Sharon on the US version. With Dannii having no part in it, Sharon would probably consider it. Unless of course she's doing Britain's Got Talent or whatever.

[Callum]

Originally Posted by 08marsh

I'm talking about Sharon on the US version. With Dannii having no part in it, Sharon would probably consider it. Unless of course she's doing Britain's Got Talent or whatever.

She's already a judge on America's Got Talent, panellist on The Talk (America's answer to Loose Women) so I don't think there's a chance she'd be able to do American X Factor too.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Callum

She's already a judge on America's Got Talent, panellist on The Talk (America's answer to Loose Women) so I don't think there's a chance she'd be able to do American X Factor too.

There are also rumours she'll be doing Britain's Got Talent alongside Paul O'Grady

[fruit_cake]

says more about Simon's judgment than about Cheryl tbh..