[Marcus.]

dont like her

[Petershaw1984]

Originally Posted by bigbrother12

dont like her

does this mean me and you are agreeing for once marc? pmsl

[Marcus.]

Originally Posted by pio5ukuk

does this mean me and you are agreeing for once marc? pmsl

yes we are

[reece(:]

She's totally lifeless this year.

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by reece(:

She's totally lifeless this year.

I know, its really sad like all the spirit has been sucked out of her...
Maybe it's sitting in cheryls chair? she has turned into one of 'them'

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by reece(:

She's totally lifeless this year.

I agree with this, I think last year she outshone Kelly Rowland and felt in control, this year she is being overshadowed by Nicole and I dont think she likes it, at times she looks bored with it all..Maybe she is not to happy with Simon as allegedly he told Cheryl she could sack either Tulisa or Kelly last year so she could return, you wouldnt be a very happy bunny if that is true.

[Stevep]

Good person i'd say who has persevered from a very young age to make it, credit where it's due. Good example for anyone who is looking to make it into the industry; persistence pays off.

As for being a mentor, i find her a bit cringe-worthy. The way she, in a serious not pissing about manner, goes on and on (mostly on the xtra factor) about the various techniques shes employs to help out her acts is not needed, especially when it's spouting out cliches.

[Jamie585]

She is obviously a good mentor, the only judge who hasn't ****ed up a song choice yet!! She has toned it down this year, which is understandable because of all the bad press she's been given, i think people need to stop giving her such a hard time.

[Brother Leon]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

She is obviously a good mentor, the only judge who hasn't ****ed up a song choice yet!! She has toned it down this year, which is understandable because of all the bad press she's been given, i think people need to stop giving her such a hard time.

She gave Lucy Gold Digger to perform and as a result we got a crime to music.

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by Brother Leon

She gave Lucy Gold Digger to perform and as a result we got a crime to music.

opposed to the rest?

[Brother Leon]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

opposed to the rest?

Still ****ed up a song choice which was the point

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

She is obviously a good mentor, the only judge who hasn't ****ed up a song choice yet!! She has toned it down this year, which is understandable because of all the bad press she's been given, i think people need to stop giving her such a hard time.

Really? so what was Ella given last night? or last week when she gave Jade Hero by Enrique Iglesias?

Tulisa is very lucky that the Girls category is basically immune from elimination in the first couple of weeks because if they was in any other category they would have hit the bottom two with those song choices.

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Really? so what was Ella given last night? or last week when she gave Jade Hero by Enrique Iglesias?

Tulisa is very lucky that the Girls category is basically immune from elimination in the first couple of weeks because if they was in any other category they would have hit the bottom two with those song choices.

Oh just shut the **** up.

Melanie went home! Get over it.

Tulisa is quite clearly an excellent mentor, seen as though on most polls her acts are always towards the top, the only judge this year to have escaped the bottom 2 as of yet and oh what else? Who won last year? And with what category? That's right, Tulisa won with a girlgroup that were 100/1 pre live shows. You just put all blame on Tulisa but give her no credit for what she has achieved as a mentor on the show.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Apple202

Oh just shut the **** up.

Melanie went home! Get over it.

Tulisa is quite clearly an excellent mentor, seen as though on most polls her acts are always towards the top, the only judge this year to have escaped the bottom 2 as of yet and oh what else? Who won last year? And with what category? That's right, Tulisa won with a girlgroup that were 100/1 pre live shows. You just put all blame on Tulisa but give her no credit for what she has achieved as a mentor on the show.

1. Rude and if you don't like other peoples opinions then you shouldn't be on a Forum.

2. This has nothing to do with her poor decision tonight.

3. Little Mix never would have won last year if they wasn't given every late slot, The Risk and Sophie being dismantled, and Amelia missing half the series so if anything the producers deserve the most credit for last years winner.

[Doogle]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

1. Rude and if you don't like other peoples opinions then you shouldn't be on a Forum.

2. This has nothing to do with her poor decision tonight.

3. Little Mix never would have won last year if they was given every late slot, The Risk and Sophie being dismantled, and Amelia missing half the series so if anything the producers deserve the most credit for last years winner.

[Marcus.]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

1. Rude and if you don't like other peoples opinions then you shouldn't be on a Forum.

2. This has nothing to do with her poor decision tonight.

3. Little Mix never would have won last year if they wasn't given every late slot, The Risk and Sophie being dismantled, and Amelia missing half the series so if anything the producers deserve the most credit for last years winner.

well said

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

1. Rude and if you don't like other peoples opinions then you shouldn't be on a Forum.

2. This has nothing to do with her poor decision tonight.

3. Little Mix never would have won last year if they was given every late slot, The Risk and Sophie being dismantled, and Amelia missing half the series so if anything the producers deserve the most credit for last years winner.

You're acting as if every decision she's made has been a bad one? Are you forgetting something? Last week she saved Carolynne. There, looking back just one week I've found a perfect decision by Tulisa.

And again, you completely undermime everything Tulisa did for the girls. Who was the one that first gave them a market? On the first few live shows, who really hammered an appeal for the girls? Who, despite them being favourite to leave the first live show, kept them in the competition when she could have easily dropped them and just gone for an apparently easier ride? Who was the only mentor that looked fully invested in their acts - going out of her way to spend time with the girls? As a Little Mix fan, I am extremely grateful for everything Tulisa did for the girls. And trust me, that was alot.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

She was better last year. I like her. I like that she seems strong, is opiniated and articulate. She has good things say but this year, she's a bit different.

[Petershaw1984]

Originally Posted by ithinkiloveyoutoo

she was better last year. I like her. I like that she seems strong, is opiniated and articulate. She has good things say but this year, she's a bit different.

articulate???? Ha ha ha ha

[Black Dagger]

Pointless this year.

Queen Nicole has taken her spotlight.

[Petershaw1984]

blackdagger is right nicole is queen

[King Gizzard]

Horrible

trashy, can hardly give other people opinions when her own music dire...and she's still pretty chavvy

''I know I'll just model my acts on Amy and Adele this year''..predictable

[Mystic Mock]

A rude bitch that should be sacked after countless times of not making the right decisions.

Already she's ruining Ella's chances of winning.

[Black Dagger]

Little Mix won because they were seen as a 'we won't steal your boyfriends' girl-group, every girl-group before them were not even seen as remotely like-able etc.

And you make it out as if Tulisa did everything, the girls had their say as well and people vote on the act, not the mentor.

And this 'only judge not to be in the B2 is bollocks' SHE HAS 3 STRONG ACTS FFS, OF COURSE THEY WILL BE SAFE EARLY ON.

The overs had fodder, Rylan was never going to get a lot of votes and a group was going to split votes.

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Im not saying that Tulisa is 100% evil because as you pointed out she voted Rylan out last week and she did care about Little Mix so much that she dismantled The Risk and had a no hoper group in Nu Vibe, but if that year didn't have the week 1 twist or the rest of the acts being sabotaged for Little Mix and Marcus then I bet that either The Risk, Amelia, or Sophie would have won.

1) How did she? They pretty much dismantled themselves because of their constant swap around of members, and actually Nu Vibe were a group that showed promise in judges houses. And besides, on week 1 it was obviously going to be 2 Shoes or Nu Vibe leaving, and Tulisa likely thought the boyband would get more votes than 2 Shoes, so I'd hardly say that was her picking fodder for LM.
2) You're only saying that because they were top 2. It's easy to say that the top 2 were only there because other's were sabotaged, but really? I wouldn't say Amelia was sabotaged, 3/5 times she was in she had pimp slot, I wouldn't say Misha was either, saved 3 times doesn't scream 'sabotage' to me..

Originally Posted by Black Dagger

Little Mix won because they were seen as a 'we won't steal your boyfriends' girl-group, every girl-group before them were not even seen as remotely like-able etc.

And you make it out as if Tulisa did everything, the girls had their say as well and people vote on the act, not the mentor.

And this 'only judge not to be in the B2 is bollocks' SHE HAS 3 STRONG ACTS FFS, OF COURSE THEY WILL BE SAFE EARLY ON.

The overs had fodder, Rylan was never going to get a lot of votes and a group was going to split votes.

That's exactly my point, seen as though it was Tulisa who insisted upon this every week towards the start to secure a fanbase for them.