[Apple202]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Because she got lost in the crowd of 12 contestants where as District3 are only gonna average about 5 to 7% each week.

You can think of all the excuses you like, but seen as though Melanie had the least votes, she quite clearly was the smallest threat.

[Me. I Am Salman]

She's dull as dishwater, which is probably what she used to bathe in as a child

[reece(:]

She should go back to doing what she does best.. and it's not the singing.

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Apple202

eurgh this elimination is just giving people even more a chance too slag off tulisa

Originally Posted by Salman!

She's dull as dishwater, which is probably what she used to bathe in as a child

Originally Posted by reece(:

She should go back to doing what she does best.. and it's not the singing.

point proven.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Apple202

point proven.

She's a skank with no morals

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Salman!

She's a skank with no morals

Again, because she gave her boyfriend a blowjob? Get a grip.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Apple202

Again, because she gave her boyfriend a blowjob? Get a grip.

No thanks I'll leave that to Tulisa

[Jamie585]

first bad decision and everyone hates her suddenly? She hasn't made one bad decision yet, he's been the best mentor so far, She has picked great songs for all her acts and is the only Judge not to have had a contestant in the bottom 2, says it all really

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

first bad decision and everyone hates her suddenly? She hasn't made one bad decision yet, he's been the best mentor so far, She has picked great songs for all her acts and is the only Judge not to have had a contestant in the bottom 2, says it all really

Jamie talking sense once again

[Black Dagger]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

first bad decision and everyone hates her suddenly? She hasn't made one bad decision yet, he's been the best mentor so far, She has picked great songs for all her acts and is the only Judge not to have had a contestant in the bottom 2, says it all really

She has good acts... (well those liked within the GBP anyway) if she mentored Carolynne/Melanie I'm sure they'd have still gone.

I don't see how this makes her superior to everybody else because she has 3 well liked acts who were never going to be B2 in the early weeks.

[Cherie]

Maybe she preferred District 3 to Melanie, I did?.... there should be no judges vote it should always be the public vote that decides who stays, whats the point in voting if your vote is going to be overruled by the judges?

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by CherieB;5545208[B

]Maybe she preferred District 3 to Melanie, I did[/B]?.... there should be no judges vote it should always be the public vote that decides who stays, whats the point in voting if your vote is going to be overruled by the judges?

It's ok you will be cured soon.

And to respond in a serious manner what's the point of having a bottom two if they are just going to take it to deadlock?

[Jamie585]

Love Tulisa.. Don't hate!!

[Ramsay]

Not surprised people have lowered themselves to calling her a slut

[Mystic Mock]

I can and especially when Melanie wiped the floor with The Backstreet Boys in the sing-off.

Although Carolynne wiped the floor with Rylan last week and yet Louis ****ed up, and Simon's decision to save Katie over Aiden a couple of years ago so I don't know why I am shocked anymore tbh.

[Raph]

Yeah like Rachel Adedeji was sent home over Lloyd.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Raph

Yeah like Rachel Adedeji was sent home over Lloyd.

And Lucie sent home over Jedward

So many bad decisions. But thats what keeps people talking about the show.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

And Lucie sent home over Jedward

So many bad decisions. But thats what keeps people talking about the show.

Yes but normally they are not in the first two weeks.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Yes but normally they are not in the first two weeks.

I think this week just seems worse because of all the controversy of last week...had it been a 'normal' elimination last week noone would really care this week.

I dont think a joke act has been in the bottom first before? With the exception of cocozza, but the group he was against were absolutely ****e. This is probably why it stands out more...coz carolyn was a decent singer. But they cant lose the characters early, people would lose interest with noone to hate so early on

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

I think this week just seems worse because of all the controversy of last week...had it been a 'normal' elimination last week noone would really care this week.

I dont think a joke act has been in the bottom first before? With the exception of cocozza, but the group he was against were absolutely ****e. This is probably why it stands out more...coz carolyn was a decent singer. But they cant lose the characters early, people would lose interest with noone to hate so early on

But District3 aren't characters, they are just a very boring boyband and at best average vocalists (that's me being kind btw) noway should they have stayed tonight.

[Raph]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

And Lucie sent home over Jedward

So many bad decisions. But thats what keeps people talking about the show.

Lucie Jones!

[Ramsay]

Mock you're making an embarrassment of yourself

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Karl

Mock you're making an embarrassment of yourself

^

[Jamie585]

She's not going anywhere! her job is safe as houses!!

[MTVN]

The two acts this series weren't really "sent home" considering it went to public vote though, in a way it's the fairest result